I thought it was damn entertaining and told a story critical to the character. Showing is much better than telling.
Maybe that's fair, I haven't played the game and I haven't looked up anything that is to come so this might be important going forward. I'm just saying, a travel narrative is a propulsive narrative and if you're going to take me out of that, I don't want to be shown something that I already know the outcome of. For the first time on Sunday I spent about half the show on my phone. I haven't been tempted to second screen so far during this show at any point, and this time it could hardly keep my attention.
Prior to this episode, if I said there were 3 animating things about Ellie it's that she's been abandoned or lost everyone important in her life, she got bit and didn't turn, and she's got an (understandable) bit of a messiah complex. Maybe we learned something important that is to come, but I don't know what that might be and IMO that's not good storytelling.
It might not be fair because the Bill and Frank episode might be the best episode of TV we've seen in the last few years but we already got taken out of the story once for Bill and Frank. We didn't know what was going to happen with Bill and Frank. Everybody knew exactly what was going to ultimately happen as soon as Ellie went in that mall.
I agree with you. It was the slowest episode of the season but it was still an above average hour of a tv series. IMDB ratings (7.7 compared to 9.1 for the average of the show) would agree. We didn’t learn anything significant that was new and, unlike the Bill and Frank episode, there wasn’t much suspense or wonder about what would happen. But we did get some good Ellie backstory. In a 9 episode season, it felt a bit filler-ish but I still enjoyed it.
Episode 3 was one of the best episodes of television I’ve seen in awhile. No doubt there are some weirdos with agendas influencing these.Keep in mind that the second lowest rated episode is episode 3, which got review bombed by a certain segment butthurt about gay characters. The same segment appears to be doing the same review bombing for episode 7 with the large number of 1* reviews
View attachment 110203
Keep in mind that the second lowest rated episode is episode 3, which got review bombed by a certain segment butthurt about gay characters. The same segment appears to be doing the same review bombing for episode 7 with the large number of 1* reviews
View attachment 110203
Good point and agree. But Episode 7 couldn't hold a candle to Episode 3 and I think everyone would agree. I don't think many would disagree with that.
I really liked the game but this just didn't work on TV for me. When playing the game I was putting the hours in and flying through it. For a weekly TV series it feels like the story didn't progress for a couple weeks. Curious if I'd feel different if watching all at once.Maybe that's fair, I haven't played the game and I haven't looked up anything that is to come so this might be important going forward. I'm just saying, a travel narrative is a propulsive narrative and if you're going to take me out of that, I don't want to be shown something that I already know the outcome of. For the first time on Sunday I spent about half the show on my phone. I haven't been tempted to second screen so far during this show at any point, and this time it could hardly keep my attention.
Prior to this episode, if I said there were 3 animating things about Ellie it's that she's been abandoned or lost everyone important in her life, she got bit and didn't turn, and she's got an (understandable) bit of a messiah complex. Maybe we learned something important that is to come, but I don't know what that might be and IMO that's not good storytelling.
It might not be fair because the Bill and Frank episode might be the best episode of TV we've seen in the last few years but we already got taken out of the story once for Bill and Frank. We didn't know what was going to happen with Bill and Frank. Everybody knew exactly what was going to ultimately happen as soon as Ellie went in
It's a great episode but it's kind of a bummer they are consistently dropping moments with the infected in favor of adding background for side characters.
It's a great episode but it's kind of a bummer they are consistently dropping moments with the infected in favor of adding background for side characters.