I think ISU is better than Richmond especially on D, but Murray had a typical efficient game although not one of his best. 8/15 fg, 9 rebounds, 21 points. His efficiency is why I think he's such a good player, he scores a ton without huge # of shots. Maybe that isn't a sexy thing either.
I think you're probably right about Garza. To me he's a better player than Garza was. He can play in any style of play and doesn't have to demand the ball to put up big offensive #s. With Garza they had to play around Garza and sometimes that isn't going to work...definitely not in the NBA game.
It may be hard for some to put away the rivalry, but if I could add one of them to ISU's team it's Murray very easily. I'd say the same if I was starting a team from scratch. I was expecting a lot more impressive looking player since he won the award over Murray. Like I said, he struck me as a slightly weaker Nader. (I just looked up their measurements and they are almost identical except Davis longer wingspan, but also probably why he doesn't look as strong as Nader)