What logo would you vote for now?

Which brand logo would you choose today?

  • ISU Block Letters

    Votes: 20 6.0%
  • I State Logo

    Votes: 163 48.9%
  • Cyclones Script

    Votes: 150 45.0%

  • Total voters
    333

Flynn4Heisman

Well-Known Member
Mar 24, 2006
516
411
63
I've been getting some sh*t for this, but how can anyone dislike this logo (Bird in a Blender)?

To me, it sums our history perfectly as formerly the Cardinals and then the Cyclones.

Though the "Iowa State Above a Tornado" is a close second (Is that the "Orrnado"?).

I personally have always disliked the "I-State" logo we have had since 2008, as I think it's boring as f***, but I understand Pollard's reasoning for wanting to keep things "simple" for branding purposes.
 

Attachments

  • R.png
    R.png
    407.7 KB · Views: 7
Last edited:

BoomerClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 27, 2010
979
891
93
North Carolina
I've been getting some sh*t for this, but how can anyone dislike this logo (Bird in a Blender)?

To me, it sums our history perfectly as formerly the Cardinals and then the Cyclones.

Though the "Iowa State Above a Tornado" is a close second (Is that the "Orrnado"?).

I personally have always disliked the "I-State" logo we have had since 2008, as I think it's boring as f***, but I understand Pollard's reasoning for wanting to keep things "simple" for branding purposes.
That was the logo when I was in school and I had a LOT of gear with that logo. I still don’t like it and glad they went with the I-State. When I was back in Iowa recently my mom handed me an old Iowa state hat of mine with that logo that she asked if I wanted to take home. I said, no, you can toss it. That’s how much I don’t like that logo even though it was the one in place for my entire time at ISU.
 

drlove

Well-Known Member
Mar 20, 2007
2,560
2,832
113
I've never liked the "I-State" that much.

It's too generic. Like a create-a-team logo. And we're not "I-State" like "K-State."

How we haven't ended up with a clean, classic-looking logo that combines something like the Orrnado (a Cyclone shaped like a "V" from the side) with an "ISU" overlaid on it... I'll never know.

The 90s bird in a blender sort of tried that but, as was the style at the time in the 90s, introduced a trendy color (navy blue) for no reason, forced Cy in there needlessly, and went way too busy.
I'm not a fan of the "I-State". Do people call is "I-State"? Seems like it was an attempt to change what we are called, but that is me.

FWIW, the old Iowa State "cyclone" logo should be attributed to Jim Criner, not Johnny Orr IMO. The department did a rebranding for football when Criner was hired. the logo didn't get to many of the other teams until years later including MBB. Shoot, the 84-85 MBB team was still using a logo from the Donnie Duncan era. 1716993081476.png
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Gorm

Jer

Opinionated
Feb 28, 2006
23,166
21,986
10,030
I've been getting some sh*t for this, but how can anyone dislike this logo (Bird in a Blender)?

To me, it sums our history perfectly as formerly the Cardinals and then the Cyclones.

Though the "Iowa State Above a Tornado" is a close second (Is that the "Orrnado"?).

I personally have always disliked the "I-State" logo we have had since 2008, as I think it's boring as f***, but I understand Pollard's reasoning for wanting to keep things "simple" for branding purposes.
I may be a bit irrational about it, but I banned my dad from entering our house with that on his hat and sweatshirt a few years ago (they come over every weekend). I bought him new ones and said if you want to see your grandkids, you'll kill Blender Cy.

Visceral hatred for the blue **** toilet swirling Cy logo.

But everybody's entitled to an opinion (even if your's sucks ass).
 

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
8,836
8,488
113
Rural U.S.A.
Illinois-State-Redbirds-Logo-1980.png

That screams Illinois State.
 

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
8,836
8,488
113
Rural U.S.A.
I may be a bit irrational about it, but I banned my dad from entering our house with that on his hat and sweatshirt a few years ago (they come over every weekend). I bought him new ones and said if you want to see your grandkids, you'll kill Blender Cy.

Visceral hatred for the blue **** toilet swirling Cy logo.

But everybody's entitled to an opinion (even if your's sucks ass).

The blue ruined it. Otherwise I'd be all for it. No ******* blue!!
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
5,650
6,416
113
Just curious, who stole from whom? Does anyone know the timing?

View attachment 129565

One site says Louisville used this from 63 to 78.

They were probably stock logos at the time, that were modified for each team.

There are some old catalogues from Collegiate Manufacturing Company of Ames, that show some logos as stock images, including the old vintage Hawk logo and several of the old Arthur Evans designs.

1717012948733.png






 

BoomerClone

Well-Known Member
Oct 27, 2010
979
891
93
North Carolina
That was the logo when I was in school and I had a LOT of gear with that logo. I still don’t like it and glad they went with the I-State. When I was back in Iowa recently my mom handed me an old Iowa state hat of mine with that logo that she asked if I wanted to take home. I said, no, you can toss it. That’s how much I don’t like that logo even though it was the one in place for my entire time at ISU.
I’m going to reply to my own post. Only because someone else said something about blue being introduced. The hat from above, was f’ing blue with the s$itty logo. Why the hell would I still want that and why the hell did I spend money on that in the first place??
 
  • Like
Reactions: wonkadog

1238576073jb

Well-Known Member
Jul 4, 2021
521
697
93
I've been getting some sh*t for this, but how can anyone dislike this logo (Bird in a Blender)?

To me, it sums our history perfectly as formerly the Cardinals and then the Cyclones.

Though the "Iowa State Above a Tornado" is a close second (Is that the "Orrnado"?).

I personally have always disliked the "I-State" logo we have had since 2008, as I think it's boring as f***, but I understand Pollard's reasoning for wanting to keep things "simple" for branding purposes.
I love Whirly Cy, Blender Bird, whatever it's called - agreed, it's a great mixture of the two "mascots"

I think they should have a few animations to use online & on the video boards of a modern version "walking Cy" (there's a great one floating around on this very forum) turning into "Whirly Cy", like he gets mad or he's running really fast & his lower body/legs turn into the Cyclone

Kinda cheesy, but the kids would eat it up & it sorta gives relevance to both Cy-styles

Whirly Cy should def be on the helmet - he's facing forward with implied forward motion, fist out front, that bird is about to go into battle
 
  • Like
Reactions: Righteous canoe03

Cyrealist

Well-Known Member
Sep 25, 2013
2,709
-2,183
63
68
I've been getting some sh*t for this, but how can anyone dislike this logo (Bird in a Blender)?

To me, it sums our history perfectly as formerly the Cardinals and then the Cyclones.

Though the "Iowa State Above a Tornado" is a close second (Is that the "Orrnado"?).

I personally have always disliked the "I-State" logo we have had since 2008, as I think it's boring as f***, but I understand Pollard's reasoning for wanting to keep things "simple" for branding purposes.
I also like this logo. I don't even mind the navy blue in it because it gives it more of a thuderstormy feel. I think the Orrnado artistically looks like something from the 70s as well as being associated with a bad period in Iowa State football. I-State has a good visual punch and is recognized around the country. If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
 
  • Puke
Reactions: wonkadog