Well, I am impressed by your passion, but no, my logic is not faulty. Common belief is that for ISU to sign someone else, either Carter or Ernst will be leaving (or possibly Cooke). I am not making these decisions, the staff is. If they replace one of Carter or Ernst with this grad transfer, then they are the ones deeming the kid as not being Big 12 worthy, not me. If they felt both are ready to contribute big minutes next year, we would not be having this discussion as we would not still be recruiting.
My point was simple, just because the staff would happen to chose to offer someone does not mean that someone will be anything special, just that it is the best player the staff feels they can get which is why I felt it odd of someone to question a poster about not having faith in the staff. Good players are very hard to get in the spring and that is why ISU has hardly ever landed good spring players except for transfers. Out of the last 30 or so spring signees, maybe a couple have done something worthwhile at ISU. Ernst and Carter could turn out to be exceptions, but logic and odds favor them not ever contributing much. Does not mean I personally think they will not or that they cannot be the exceptions, but the logical thing would be to assume they won't until they prove otherwise. I applaud the vigor that you are holding out hope with though. Kudos to you.