Gladiator II trailer

Letterkenny

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 26, 2023
1,720
3,516
113
I like Denzel Washington, but I think he was not a good choice, just my opinion from that trailer.
Him using his typical New York accent when the rest of the characters are apparently British was an odd choice.
 

dahliaclone

Well-Known Member
Mar 4, 2007
16,148
24,948
113
Minneapolis
How many sequel retreads have made money this year? Inside Out 2? How well did Furiosa do? What makes you think this will make money? These movies haven't.
As amazing as Fury Road is it actually wasn't a huge box office success so not surprising Furiosa hasn't done well.

Gladiator on the other hand was a monster at the box office and won best pic. This will make a ton of money.
 

dahliaclone

Well-Known Member
Mar 4, 2007
16,148
24,948
113
Minneapolis
Cautiously optimistic.

The original is an all-time classic action film with impressive character and thematic depth.

Brilliant performances top to bottom with Russell Crowe as a "last of the Romans" figure, Joaquin Phoenix as the menacing and insane Emperor Commodus, Derek Jacobi as the noble Senator, Richard Harris as the dying Marcus Aurelius, and the last performance of Oliver Reed as the gladiator trainer.

And that Zimmer score... *drools*

It presented an interesting "What If?" counterfactual about the end of the Nerva-Antonine Dynasty and the period of Roman military dominance, economic prosperity, and cultural flourishing from 96 through the late 100s that went awry in 193 and never returned to the same levels. What if Marcus Aurelius had attempted to appoint the best man for the job, a magnificent general who abhorred politics with no personal ambition but nonetheless was a natural leader and had the loyalty of the army, instead of his mentally unstable and incompetent son, to be the next emperor the way the imperial throne had de facto worked since Nerva?

Great stuff.

A+

When Ridley Scott is on he's made some of the greatest films of all-time...

Alien
Blade Runner
Gladiator
Kingdom of Heaven
(criminally underrated if you watch the Director's Cut)

Plenty of "merely good" films in his catalog, too...

Thelma & Louise
Black Hawk Down
The Last Duel

etc.

But he's definitely a dude who can swing and miss, too.

Napoleon kind of sort of worked as a cringe comedy and parody of grand historical epics (the sort that Scott is known for directing) but... I'm 99.9% sure it wasn't intended to be satirical.

This sequel just has so much to live up to.
hot take: Matchstick Men is top tier Ridley Scott that not many people have seen. ******* love it.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,866
41,456
113
Waukee
...or an indicator.

Zimmer might be the biggest name in Hollywood right now. And I mean that over any director, writer, or actor/actress. He's seriously in competition with figures like John Williams, Ennio Morricone, and Max Steiner for the title of the greatest film composer of all-time (if he isn't already there now).

He's chosen to use this position not for money or fame but for art and picking projects that are interesting to him. He's like Daniel Day-Lewis -- he's held in such high regard that he can do whatever he wants, and as a result he only works with good directors on good screenplays. His alliance with Christopher Nolan was a huge factor in the latter's success, and Tenet suffered for a lack of Zimmer (though Göransson got better at doing a Zimmer impression for Oppenheimer). Villeneuve luring Zimmer away from Team Nolan for Dune and its sequels because Zimmer is such a fan of the original novels was a coup and greatly enhanced those films.

Zimmer going from Ridley/Tony Scott to Nolan to Villeneuve coincides strongly with those directors entering into the most productive and acclaimed periods of their careers (with some exceptions).

Black Hawk Down is an excellent movie. Especially if you are old enough to remember that incident and watching the aftermath on the news.

Sure is. I just don't think it's on a tier with Blade Runner (which is a strong contender for the greatest film ever made) and Gladiator (which is still 100% amazing and always will be forever).

hot take: Matchstick Men is top tier Ridley Scott that not many people have seen. ******* love it.

Again, I don't think films like this one are bad. It's just stiff competition when the top of the heap for Ridley Scott is stuff like Blade Runner and Gladiator. Few directors make even one film that good.

Him using his typical New York accent when the rest of the characters are apparently British was an odd choice.

That Greeks and Romans speak with a British accent (even if obviously they were Mediterranean and from Greece/Italy though who knows what their accents sounded like speaking ancient languages 2,000+ years ago even compared to modern Italian or Spanish in the case of the Romans) is just a trope that Hollywood adopted with mass importation of British actors for sword-and-sandals epics like...

Ben-Hur
Spartacus
The Ten Commandments
(okay not Rome or Greece but in the same style)
The Fall of the Roman Empire
Jason and the Argonauts

etc.

It's just something that's been carried forward. I don't think Denzel sounding like Denzel is going to be a problem if it is a good character -- and if it is, an actor like Denzel is going to bring it out.

The Death of Stalin let the actors speak with their natural accents rather than doing a goofy and fake Russian accent while speaking English. Hearing Steve Buscemi do Nikita Khrushchev with a Brooklyn accent and Jason Isaacs do Marshal Zhukov with a Yorkshire accent was pretty fun, I have to admit. However, it totally worked based on the quality of the performances and the writing underlying the characters.
 

NorthCyd

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 22, 2011
21,044
35,467
113
How many sequel retreads have made money this year? Inside Out 2? How well did Furiosa do? What makes you think this will make money? These movies haven't.
Might want to go check the box office on Inside Out 2. It's already one of the top 25 grossing movies of all time. By the way, almost the entire top 25 is a sequel or part of a franchise like the Marvel movies.
 

Cyclonsin

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 4, 2020
2,362
4,871
113
36
Savannah, GA
My only complaint is the music. Did we really need Kanye? Doesn't seem fitting.
It was 100% in there just because it says "blood stains the colosseum doors."

I'd like to think it won't be in the actual movie, although I didn't hate its usage in the trailer.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,866
41,456
113
Waukee
I wonder how they're going to set up the politics given the ending of Gladiator.

The main focus is on Maximus having his revenge on Commodus, which he has, but there's some vague notion of Maximus "giving Rome back to the people" through Senator Derek Jacobi.

Marcus Aurelius said there once was a dream that was Rome. And Maximus died to bring it back.

What exactly that means is tricky. Even at its best, the Roman Republic wasn't anything like what we would recognize as a modern democracy with enumerated rights, universal suffrage, competitive elections for public office, separation of church and state, civil liberties, and other basic political rights. I guess the Republic did lack a monarch, but even modern constitutional democracies can function with one around.

But there was some notion of "this madness stops with Commodus and the adults in the Senate, who are more concerned with upkeeping the sanitation system than cults of divinity will be in charge."

It looks like we're going to be in the middle of the Severan Dynasty in the sequel.

So... we're back where we started. Rome is being led by crazy military dictators (even if some of them, like Marcus Aurelius, were good at their job and decent but they are increasingly a distant memory).

Maybe that undermines the ending of the original. Or maybe it doesn't and seeing Commodus die was the whole point. And maybe it puts a dark, cynical layer on the second that this madness is incurable. A good director and a good screenplay can definitely do some weighty things with such themes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dahliaclone

BWRhasnoAC

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 10, 2013
29,961
27,646
113
Dez Moy Nez
Zimmer might be the biggest name in Hollywood right now. And I mean that over any director, writer, or actor/actress. He's seriously in competition with figures like John Williams, Ennio Morricone, and Max Steiner for the title of the greatest film composer of all-time (if he isn't already there now).

He's chosen to use this position not for money or fame but for art and picking projects that are interesting to him. He's like Daniel Day-Lewis -- he's held in such high regard that he can do whatever he wants, and as a result he only works with good directors on good screenplays. His alliance with Christopher Nolan was a huge factor in the latter's success, and Tenet suffered for a lack of Zimmer (though Göransson got better at doing a Zimmer impression for Oppenheimer). Villeneuve luring Zimmer away from Team Nolan for Dune and its sequels because Zimmer is such a fan of the original novels was a coup and greatly enhanced those films.

Zimmer going from Ridley/Tony Scott to Nolan to Villeneuve coincides strongly with those directors entering into the most productive and acclaimed periods of their careers (with some exceptions).



Sure is. I just don't think it's on a tier with Blade Runner (which is a strong contender for the greatest film ever made) and Gladiator (which is still 100% amazing and always will be forever).



Again, I don't think films like this one are bad. It's just stiff competition when the top of the heap for Ridley Scott is stuff like Blade Runner and Gladiator. Few directors make even one film that good.



That Greeks and Romans speak with a British accent (even if obviously they were Mediterranean and from Greece/Italy though who knows what their accents sounded like speaking ancient languages 2,000+ years ago even compared to modern Italian or Spanish in the case of the Romans) is just a trope that Hollywood adopted with mass importation of British actors for sword-and-sandals epics like...

Ben-Hur
Spartacus
The Ten Commandments
(okay not Rome or Greece but in the same style)
The Fall of the Roman Empire
Jason and the Argonauts

etc.

It's just something that's been carried forward. I don't think Denzel sounding like Denzel is going to be a problem if it is a good character -- and if it is, an actor like Denzel is going to bring it out.

The Death of Stalin let the actors speak with their natural accents rather than doing a goofy and fake Russian accent while speaking English. Hearing Steve Buscemi do Nikita Khrushchev with a Brooklyn accent and Jason Isaacs do Marshal Zhukov with a Yorkshire accent was pretty fun, I have to admit. However, it totally worked based on the quality of the performances and the writing underlying the characters.
I freeking LOVE Kung Fu Panda and had no idea that was Zimmer until I just looked at his filmography. The Dune movies are masterpieces IMO. Also wtf movies I didn't know he did: The Rock, Rango, Black Hawk Down. Honestly his list is stifling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sigmapolis

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron