I generally agree with most of their complaints, but not as passionately as their most outspoken commenters are.
The gameplay itself is fun, even if it does need a bit of refining. But RTG feels lifeless. It was fun for a season and a half, but once you've become WR1 and maxed out the coach trust scale it feels like there's nothing left to do. Not to mention the off-the-field stuff feels so sterile and bland.
I haven't tried dynasty yet, I'm going to wait until the sim for it gets patched before I get invested. And I'll never touch UT.
I was on the fence about getting it, and after a week of trying it out I wish I would have waited. As it stands, I just don't think I'll get $70 worth of fun out of this and I have extremely little hope that EA will make any significant quality of life improvements before CFB26.