Not attempting to down play the severity of accusations and potential ramifications here, but there is a lot to unpack here.
On the team side... seems like a real personal beef between Bartlett/Starocci with the Bartlett's being the only non-anonymous accusers. There are what, 35-40 other wrestlers in that room? You'd think you'd certainly have a plethora of information and evidence from there, especially if it was conduct in the wrestling room/locker rooms and other theft(s). Also, I'd be curious about former teammate "Mark". I have to assume they are using fake name there? Because the only Mark that was ever a teammate of Starocci was Mark Hall and I'd sure as hell bet he's got no fear of Carter.
Now on the alledged sexual assualts, I'm trying to carefully read the article as it relates to Cael. The article clearly says that Bartlett reported the theft to Cael and Cael said he'd support Beau's decision into an investigation. They also say the non-consensual photos we're reported to Cael and nothing was done. Now that is a big deal in it's own right, but I don't see anything that states any of the other allegations being reported to Cael? That's impactful in the sense of whether he was responsbile for initiating a Title IX investigation, etc.
There is a lot more that needs to come out here. Good on them for the scoop, but a student run paper isn't going to be the best investigative journalism out there! Could be a big issue for that program of course