The problem as I see it: one of the pro-VEISHEA arguments running through this thread is "Now there will be riots because there is no VEISHEA," which can be simplified to "Riots because VEISHEA." Whether you enjoyed legitimate VEISHEA activities, or just got drunk and stupid; whether you hated the riots, or tolerated them, or made excuses for them, or participated in them, the mere idea of rioting became part of VEISHEA. To anyone outside of the ISU community it was even more so. It got pretty embarrassing for this alumnus. The right decision has been made. Good riddance.