ISU vs. Iowa dominance (for Clones21)

WalkingCY

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2008
6,894
2,591
113
Kansas City
And yet somehow that fan base full of morons believes deep down in their hearts that we are far, far, farrrrrr worse than them in every regard related to athletics. They are without a doubt, the dumbest fans in America.


this is true.

Very fickle fan base.... only when they're good is when closet sqawk fans come out and opening their mouths when they are decent in hoops. What a terrible fan base.
 

WalkingCY

Well-Known Member
Sep 26, 2008
6,894
2,591
113
Kansas City
uh, weird... why did my post come up 3 times?

Better than 9 times missing school in Ferris Bueller:

9 Times

3716325_f520.jpg
 

Palmer

Well-Known Member
Jun 10, 2008
7,942
472
83
Johnston, IA
Does this sound better Clones21....

ISU MBB has won 4 out of last 5 against Iowa.

And Kirk Ferentz still has lost more games against ISU than he's won.

And I believe ISU WBB has won the majority of the time over the last 5-6 years too over Iowa?

Iowa does have Wrestling though... I'll give them that. And sadly, they will probably own us in that sport for a while.


awesome...a potential battle between you and Clone21.....an epic struggle of the Cyclone Fanatic twits.

*getting popcorn*
 
  • Like
Reactions: CyDude16

hawkeyeguy85

Member
Jan 17, 2007
222
13
18
Compare facilities, budget and results. Tell me, who gets the bigger bang for their buck?

Short of Kinnick vs. Jack Trice, where is the facilities "gap?' Surely you aren't insinuating Carver is better than Hilton.

Isn't everyone always crowing about the ISU indoor basketball practice facility and indoor football facility over here? Isn't Iowa trying to catch up in that area?

You could probably make the argument that overall the past 5 years ISU has had a facilities edge.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,797
3,668
113
Menlo, Iowa
Short of Kinnick vs. Jack Trice, where is the facilities "gap?' Surely you aren't insinuating Carver is better than Hilton.

Isn't everyone always crowing about the ISU indoor basketball practice facility and indoor football facility over here? Isn't Iowa trying to catch up in that area?

You could probably make the argument that overall the past 5 years ISU has had a facilities edge.


Iowa's budget is $30M bigger than ISU's.
 

SplitIdentity

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2007
11,486
3,073
113
Minnesota
Iowa's budget is $30M bigger than ISU's.

And ISU has a competent AD.

I can't imagine JP being OK with the success of (or lack there of) some of Iowa's programs. Volleyball should be FAR ahead of where it is. If UNI and ISU can be annual tournament teams, Iowa should be able to compete as well. Not to mention, Iowa plays in one of the strongest volleyball conferences.

Baseball has been mediocre for quite some time, and their facilities are located in the football bubble. Duane Banks Field is a dump, and Jack Dahm is a horrible game-day coach.

Barta was also responsible for the Lick hire, although I'll give him props for fixing that mistake before it completely wrecked the program.

I guess my biggest complaints are with volleyball, baseball, and cross country. The other programs are at least respectable (with soccer and mens golf doing pretty darn well now, actually), and field hockey is a force as usual.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,797
3,668
113
Menlo, Iowa
And ISU has a competent AD.

I can't imagine JP being OK with the success of (or lack there of) some of Iowa's programs. Volleyball should be FAR ahead of where it is. If UNI and ISU can be annual tournament teams, Iowa should be able to compete as well. Not to mention, Iowa plays in one of the strongest volleyball conferences.

Baseball has been mediocre for quite some time, and their facilities are located in the football bubble. Duane Banks Field is a dump, and Jack Dahm is a horrible game-day coach.

Barta was also responsible for the Lick hire, although I'll give him props for fixing that mistake before it completely wrecked the program.

I guess my biggest complaints are with volleyball, baseball, and cross country. The other programs are at least respectable (with soccer and mens golf doing pretty darn well now, actually), and field hockey is a force as usual.

So what you are saying is Iowa wastes a lot of money. There is no reason for Iowa not be good in Baseball either.

I think Lick did a good job at wrecking the program.
 

jaretac

Well-Known Member
Nov 26, 2006
7,642
337
83
Frigidaire
Iowa's budget is $30M bigger than ISU's.

Exactly. Much bigger budget, ISU is quickly getting better facilities across the board. We are doing more with less. Once the new sports complex is done, I don't think you can argue Iowa having better facilities anywhere except for Kinnick and ISU is pushing JT to a comparable status.
 

kingcy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 16, 2006
22,797
3,668
113
Menlo, Iowa
Exactly. Much bigger budget, ISU is quickly getting better facilities across the board. We are doing more with less. Once the new sports complex is done, I don't think you can argue Iowa having better facilities anywhere except for Kinnick and ISU is pushing JT to a comparable status.


JTS has a long ways to go.
 

jaretac

Well-Known Member
Nov 26, 2006
7,642
337
83
Frigidaire
JTS has a long ways to go.

It does. We need to bowl it in and put in a new press box. That is probably going to be a good 80 million. I think when we get to that point we will be comparable. You could argue one better than the other because one has more seats or the other has a bigger score board, but in the sense of being a legit BCS stadium they will be equals.
 

hawkeyeguy85

Member
Jan 17, 2007
222
13
18
Iowa's budget is $30M bigger than ISU's.

So what you are saying is Iowa wastes a lot of money. There is no reason for Iowa not be good in Baseball either.

I think Lick did a good job at wrecking the program.

Exactly. Much bigger budget, ISU is quickly getting better facilities across the board. We are doing more with less. Once the new sports complex is done, I don't think you can argue Iowa having better facilities anywhere except for Kinnick and ISU is pushing JT to a comparable status.

Exactly where I was trying to go with this.

The difference between CPR and KF is ~3million.
Not sure the diff between Hoiberg and McCaffery, but it's not 27million.

So if it isn't going into facilities, where does it go?

I think this implies that, 1, ISU's AD is run more efficiently, but also 2, i don't think there is a linear relationship between budget and success.

Doubling ISU's budget would no doubt be a big help, but it also produces more chances/areas for waste and/or mismanagement.

Money isn't a cure all.
 

iahawkhunter

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2010
3,059
414
83
Huxley, IA
Exactly where I was trying to go with this.

The difference between CPR and KF is ~3million.
Not sure the diff between Hoiberg and McCaffery, but it's not 27million.

So if it isn't going into facilities, where does it go?


I think this implies that, 1, ISU's AD is run more efficiently, but also 2, i don't think there is a linear relationship between budget and success.

Doubling ISU's budget would no doubt be a big help, but it also produces more chances/areas for waste and/or mismanagement.

Money isn't a cure all.

Couldn't some be attributed to different operational costs? You only mention coaches' salaries here. I don't expect operations to eat up ~$27M, but it could definitely account for some of the difference. When you have to transport and feed that many bodies (regardless of sport), small per-person expense differences add up to real money.
 

cy1010

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2009
3,047
86
48
Couldn't some be attributed to different operational costs? You only mention coaches' salaries here. I don't expect operations to eat up ~$27M, but it could definitely account for some of the difference. When you have to transport and feed that many bodies (regardless of sport), small per-person expense differences add up to real money.

My GUESS is that Iowa has a more athletic teams to pay for than ISU does. This is just my guess. And surely it doesn't account for all the money, but it's got to be part of it. Baseball alone has to eat up a good chunk of that money.
 

hawkeyeguy85

Member
Jan 17, 2007
222
13
18
Couldn't some be attributed to different operational costs? You only mention coaches' salaries here. I don't expect operations to eat up ~$27M, but it could definitely account for some of the difference. When you have to transport and feed that many bodies (regardless of sport), small per-person expense differences add up to real money.

Probably. But why should they be different?

I think what you're saying is maybe Iowa stays in a nicer hotel, or eats a nicer meal just because they can. Because they have the money too?

I don't know if that's true or not, but that speaks to my point about how sometimes more money isn't always a great thing. Just more ways to waste it.

Easier to be disciplined when you're living paycheck to paycheck than when you have a seemingly endless flow.
 

hawkeyeguy85

Member
Jan 17, 2007
222
13
18
My GUESS is that Iowa has a more athletic teams to pay for than ISU does. This is just my guess. And surely it doesn't account for all the money, but it's got to be part of it. Baseball alone has to eat up a good chunk of that money.

You're right. 6 more sports. 4 men's and 2 women's.

Men's gymnastics, swimming/diving, baseball and tennis.
Women's field hockey and rowing.

Would be interesting to see how much that eats up.
 

Help Support Us

Become a patron