Lack of crowd noise?

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,351
17,736
113
Seems like at least half of Cyclone fans brought some damned Hawk tool to the game with them, no wonder they weren't loud.
 

Mtowncyclone13

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2012
20,023
9,769
113
grundy center
Seems like at least half of Cyclone fans brought some damned Hawk tool to the game with them, no wonder they weren't loud.

The hawk fan next to me took up half my seat. Him and his buddy were very large so it's not like they could "scootch down". Good thing my wife and are aren't very big.
 

Jerms

Well-Known Member
May 13, 2011
401
481
63
48
Atlantic, IA
I was very frustrated with fans in my section as they just watched for most of the game. Then I watched as it seemed that over half of the section erupted when Iowa scored the go ahead touchdown...
 

awd4cy

Well-Known Member
Dec 29, 2010
27,978
19,605
113
Central Iowa
The crowd was really quiet all game, but that's completely understandable. I guess at least it was full the last 2 games. That is the last game this year it will be full. Attendance will drop way off by the end of the year.
 

3TrueFans

Just a Happily Married Man
Sep 10, 2009
63,227
61,864
113
Ames
My wife planned to bring our baby to the Halloween game but after yesterday (she wasn't at the UNI game) she said anyone who brings a kid to the SEZ is crazy. We are upper deck and some of the time is fine but other times it's so distorted you can't hear anything understandable. The poster who said you won't understand unless you sit there is absolutely correct.

Serious question. Could they add angled speakers towards the east and west sides and turn the volume down?
We bought some ear protectors for our 1 1/2 year old after I heard how loud it was at the UNI game when he wasn't there. They're adjustable so I tried them on for a second at one point and they made a huge difference during pre-game. Sometimes the noise is fine, but some songs or noises are just ear piercingly loud, they definitely try to crank the system up to 11 when it should be at like an 8.
 

thrillcat

Member
Nov 27, 2006
600
11
18
Ames
Two things.

The sound system needs work. I'm guessing they will get to it after this season. Right now the speakers are in the NEZ towers and point straight forward. So if they're pointing at you, or if you're at the north end, they're really loud. If you're along the sidelines pretty much anywhere, they're average to silent. Where I sit on the SE 20, the opposing bands have completely drowned out the PA system both weeks so far, which hasn't ever happened in the past. My guess is they've turned it down to decrease echo since it's actually hitting something on the south end instead of flying past Vet Med & Highway 30. I'm sure they realize this and will be looking into a line array system soon, which will disperse the audio more evenly throughout the venue. Right now all they can do is turn it up or turn it down. A well-designed line array covers a very wide area with less volume needed, which allows it to be loud enough without blowing people out. That's the last time I'm going to post this answer. It should apparently be a ******* sticky.

Second thing. There's no point in making a ton of noise on defense when they're already halfway through their snap count. Noise makes a difference when they're trying to get the play in from the sidelines, when they're trying to make adjustments. Start screaming 10 seconds earlier and then take a break once they snap the ball. Hopefully you'll have a chance to cheer again at the end of the play when we sack them or intercept it.

I understand the "why cheer when we're going to lose" comments. I actually do get it. When you've screamed for two hours until your throat hurts and they **** it down their leg it sucks. It sucks for the players, too. But weren't we still up 17-10 on this play? At the very worst we were still tied 17-17. The OP has a great ******* point. This isn't Wimbledon. If you're going to go, make some ******* noise. Just like you learn as a basketball player, if you're going to rest, rest on offense. Never rest on defense. That **** goes same for cheering. The defense needs volume more than anything on the field because it disrupts the offense, it screws up their play calling ability, it takes away their ability to call an audible.

Make some ******* noise, seriously.
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
The music blare comes directly at the upper SEZ seats and it is distorted and overbearing. JP needs to get this fixed. Ears are still ringing. Speakers are louder than the crowd most of the time, Mr Corn Grower Assoc.
 

Cyballz

Well-Known Member
Aug 20, 2009
1,265
926
113
It was really hard to get into a game when there's only about 2 minutes of game action between 5 min commercial breaks. I know every game has media timeouts but Saturday seemed especially brutal with all of the stoppages of play. The crowd gets excited, starts making noise..... time to review an inconsequential play. The crowd goes nuts after a 3rd down sack and it's 10 minutes before ISU takes the first snap on their next possession. We can't really expect the crowd to stay into it with those momentum killing breaks.

College athletics has sold out to the almighty dollar so there's really nothing to be done about the issue, the networks gotta get paid, but I wonder at what point people get sick of sitting in a stadium for 4 hours to watch about 20 minutes actual game action. Those "bad fans" who tailgate and watch the TV from the back of their trucks in the parking lot may be onto something.
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
The hawk fan next to me took up half my seat. Him and his buddy were very large so it's not like they could "scootch down". Good thing my wife and are aren't very big.

For that to still work, you would almost have to be hobbit size.
 

thrillcat

Member
Nov 27, 2006
600
11
18
Ames
I know every game has media timeouts but Saturday seemed especially brutal with all of the stoppages of play. The crowd gets excited, starts making noise..... time to review an inconsequential play. The crowd goes nuts after a 3rd down sack and it's 10 minutes before ISU takes the first snap on their next possession. We can't really expect the crowd to stay into it with those momentum killing breaks.

Those "bad fans" who tailgate and watch the TV from the back of their trucks in the parking lot may be onto something.

Great points. Saturday did seem to have a lot of down time.

At what point are those "bad fans" watching on TV funding more of the program than the actual ticket holders? :/
 

Ms3r4ISU

Me: Mea culpa. Also me: Sine cura sis.
Staff member
Bookie
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
May 7, 2008
12,869
8,430
113
Ames
My wife planned to bring our baby to the Halloween game but after yesterday (she wasn't at the UNI game) she said anyone who brings a kid to the SEZ is crazy. We are upper deck and some of the time is fine but other times it's so distorted you can't hear anything understandable. The poster who said you won't understand unless you sit there is absolutely correct.

Serious question. Could they add angled speakers towards the east and west sides and turn the volume down?

We said the same thing at both games. There might be crowd noise, the officials might explain a penalty call occasionally and the band might actually be playing, but far too often I'd have to take someone's word for it because the gosh-awful screeching noise that comes from the north speakers is mind-numbing, to say the least.
 

FocusTown

Member
Apr 3, 2014
128
19
18
How many teams will sell out not once but twice after two season with only 5 wins? They should be glad there are any fans there, let alone 61.5k. Thats a pretty strong fan base if you ask me. So lets not be mad if there making noise or not. Lets be proud of our fans.
 

BoxsterCy

Moderator
Staff member
Sep 14, 2009
48,274
47,150
113
Minnesota
Just thought I'd add my observations from afar from what I could sense thru HD TV:

I realize that ISU has incredible support considering the product on the field over the last few seasons. It's remarkable, really, in a day and age when college fb attendance is dwindling nationwide. But.. that being said, it boggles my mind how lame Jack Trice can be when ISU is on defense on downs 1 & 2, and then gets up, sometimes half-heartedly, for a 3rd down. I know historically the product hasn't been good on the field, but you pay decent money to sit in JTS, clad yourself in cardinal and gold, for what, 5-6x in a whole year, and yet sit on your hands while the defense needs your noise on every down, not just third (or fourth)! Believe, me it's very detectable through the TV. It pains me greatly to use the team to the southwest of Council Bluffs as an example, but those fans are LOUD every down when nebraska is on defense. It makes me wonder if the average ISU football fan has been to any other stadiums or watches other programs on tv ever.. or if it really is just about a saturday of drinking and tailgaitin'. I can relate to cygrads comment regarding no one standing up around him. The last game at JTS I attended was vs Baylor in 2012.. a very pivotal (and winnable) game to become bowl eligible. I was super excited just to be back there and yell when ISU was on defense, and the people in the surrounding seats were like statues. What is with ISU fan in football? is it the conservative, reserved demeanor of friendly Iowans? I don't think so, b/c take 14,000 out of JTS and put them in Hilton and they become maniacs that have willed more comebacks than I can recall. People.. if it works in basketball, it can in football too. I'm proud of the support Cyclone nation gives this football program, but just go one more step further than putting your fanny in the stands... yell like you won the lottery when ISU is on defense.. and maybe, just maybe, a big defensive stand can turn a game or even the program around someday.

Teams build the fan culture. The fan culture at Nebraska was built on Big 8 and national championships. The fan culture did not come first.

The first years at Hilton were church mouse quiet compared to the Old Armory noise. Part of it was the building where a small group could not make the place rock and part was the teams sucking. Johnny came and built Hilton Magic.

Not saying I don't wish were we more into it as fans and all but it might not be realistic until the teams shows something on the filed. It's not like it was not loud when we upset OSU.
 
Last edited:

3TrueFans

Just a Happily Married Man
Sep 10, 2009
63,227
61,864
113
Ames
How many teams will sell out not once but twice after two season with only 5 wins? They should be glad there are any fans there, let alone 61.5k. Thats a pretty strong fan base if you ask me. So lets not be mad if there making noise or not. Lets be proud of our fans.
How many of the teams in this hypothetical are playing two in-state rivals in a newly renovated stadium?
 

isuforlife

Well-Known Member
Sep 6, 2007
3,546
251
48
12:10:13-Purdue_Crowd.jpg

this is what we could have.

It will be by the end of the season
 

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,351
17,736
113
We bought some ear protectors for our 1 1/2 year old after I heard how loud it was at the UNI game when he wasn't there. They're adjustable so I tried them on for a second at one point and they made a huge difference during pre-game. Sometimes the noise is fine, but some songs or noises are just ear piercingly loud, they definitely try to crank the system up to 11 when it should be at like an 8.

Maybe I should try this. I am in upper SEZ so the music is loud but it's mostly bass and doesn't bother me. But these first two weeks, I have had high pitched screechy "woo" girls (both a PantherHawk and a Cyclone first game, drunk Hawk turd second game) behind me and the screeching woos give me a migraine. I can live with the music but everyone around us complains about it. The shrill screeching right in my ear is unbearable though.
 

NickTheGreat

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 17, 2012
10,802
4,771
113
Central Iowa
Crowd support is about #9,987,322 on the list of things wrong with ISU football. :realmad: :realmad: :realmad:
 

Wesley

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
70,923
546
113
Omaha
Crowd support is about #9,987,322 on the list of things wrong with ISU football. :realmad: :realmad: :realmad:
It is just that we are so young and inexperienced. Wait. The oline has lots of experience.. The qb is fifth year senior. The receivers are the same. The real youngsters are the defense if we must pick anyone....
 

VTXCyRyD

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2010
5,637
2,983
113
I was having a hard time yelling during our "3rd down Lets make some noise" after the 5th one in a row. Especially when we had them pinned deep several times and we let CJ escape and Vanderwhatever catch a pass.