I personally loved the show overall. The comedy itself was nothing groundbreaking, but the overall plot device was an original idea that was a great way to get people to bear through some bad episodes (and seasons, like the last one) to continue ratings through the end.
I also don't get the hate for Big Bang Theory. Is it cutting edge or anything? No. But not all sitcoms need to be. It's a smart comedy that appeals to the masses. I actually consider that more like Friends than I do HIMYM.
I know we've had the "why I hate BBT" discussion many times on here, but I'll reiterate my stance. It's just so cliche. I have many, many acquaintances and friends who are "nerds," am probably one myself - the characters on BBT are so rote and one-note, they're caricatures of what a smart person should be. It's just really pandering and doesn't try very hard, IMO.
not sure a single season show like Freaks and geeks should be that high. Definitely not better than scrubs.
I love the poignancy and angst in F&G. As a big fan of the early Scrubs seasons (and watched all of it), I would agree that it shouldn't be higher than Scrubs - but it was a great show. It captured teenagers in a way that I don't think many other shows have, except maybe "My So-Called Life" (another one-season show that probably deserved to be on here).