I would think that Rhoads has earned the benefit of the doubt for (at least) one more year, even after this year. The offense needs redone, but, that'll happen, and we are (legitimately) extremely young and will have a ton of returning experience the next two years. I was there--live--in 2009, and I miss that offense, but definitely not Chizik and that defense. Wally still gets the boys up to play (like today), and I think we'll have (at least) comparable talent at some point in the near future.
I figured the win in Lincoln the last time we will ever play there, the Minnesota bowl game, winning in Austin, killing the BCS, two against Iowa (including one in the People's Republic of Johnson County), 3/5 on bowl games (in an era *after* the Big 12 North and 4/8 schedules), TCU on the road, and coming oh-so-close on Nebraska again the year after, Texas this year, and giving NIU its only regular season win a few years ago earns us some benefit of the doubt.
If somebody told me in 2009 that, in the next five years, all of the above would happen, given we are IOWA STATE and Chizzle just left us for dead at 5-19 I would have taken it... And I still would have. Down years are going to happen. I thought we were past the losing to UNI days, unfortunately, but never again. This team had its open shots at UNI, Iowa, Texas, and TCU this year. Let's just enjoy the last days of the current seniors and look forward to next year, where things have to look up. We know Rhoads can surprise us. He always has.