Favorite Thanksgiving Pie

[ianoconnor]

Dutch Apple

 

[NetflixAndClone]

I Don't see Oreo, I'm dissappointed

 

[ISU42]

Caramel Apple /thread

 

[cyrocksmypants]

Cowgirl in polls:

"What's your favorite type of meat?"

CG: "Oranges."

"No, the question is about meat."

CG: "I don't care, I like oranges."

"But it's not about fruit, it's about meat."

CG: "You can make juice out of oranges."

 

[carvers4math]

Made five pies but only four remain for tomorrow, kids ate one tonight (one of three pumpkin ones I made). Have an apple and a pecan for tomorrow too.

Pumpkin kind of says Thanksgiving for me. Love banana cream, but it takes a long time the way I make it, making the pudding and meringue.

 

[cycloner29]

Coconut creme, cherry, pumpkin, key lime in that order.

Waiting for the spongebob "everybody loves pie" gif.

 

[RedDog]

I was cruising the channels last night and noticed Revenge of the Nerds was on, paused on it but couldn't commit to watching it. That is all.

 

[cyrevkah]

Always wait for the pie cook to take a bite also. My mom made raisen cream once, not my fav but will eat if offered, everyone each took one bite. All looked at each other and tried not to be mean to mom because it was awful. Mom takes a bite, looks at the recipe and said the dingy lady she got the recipe from doesn't have any sugar listed and threw the rest of it out. It was bad, so let someone else take a bite before even take any if possible.

This may be a good idea. I thought I picked up fresh ground nutmeg at the store and as I went to put it away I found out that I had gotten ground mustard. I must have reached into the wrong spice slot. Blech. I have everything for pumpkin pie except the nutmeg.

 

[NWICY]

Apple crisp.

Not a pie, stay on topic.

 

[cyrevkah]

For Thanksgiving, it is pumpkin pie and eggnog pie.

For Christmas, I can go between Candy Cane pie, French Silk, and Eggnog.

 

[NWICY]

Homemade cherry pie is my favorite, I've got a really simple recipe that is quick and easy to make. Apple is good. Blackberry pies are good but are harder to make. I'll eat pumpkin because it's the holidays, pass the whipped cream, 2:1 whipped cream to pie ratio makes pumpkin good.

 

[JohnnyFive]

All. All.

 

[arobb]

My vote is for Cheesecake. I'm not sure if it's technically a pie or not, but it has a crust and it's in a pie pan...

 

[cygrads]

It's Thanksgiving so I selected Pumpkin but and other time it is Apple all the way.

 

[Angie]

How can I be the lone vote for lemon meringue? Tart, good. Sweet, good. Crust, good.

 

[jdoggivjc]

As creator of the original poll, the correct answer is pecan. Southern communist people know this to be true.

FIFY

 

[jdoggivjc]

How can I be the lone vote for lemon meringue? Tart, good. Sweet, good. Crust, good.

Because meringue is disgusting? Lemon supreme from Village Inn, on the other hand, best pie there is 364 days of the year - all but Thanksgiving.

 

[RedDog]

Normally I'd vote pumpkin, but Key lime because of transitive property. Key West = KeyLimes = Florida = Destin = Emerald Coast Classic.

 

[HFCS]

Going with a Strawberry/Blueberry combo from a solid bakery this year and pairing it up with some damn good coffee.

 

[Angie]

Because meringue is disgusting? Lemon supreme from Village Inn, on the other hand, best pie there is 364 days of the year - all but Thanksgiving.

Lemon on supreme is far superior, but not in the poll. It would crush meringue.