Best All-Time ISU Quarterbacks?

[ketelmeister]

Here's my ratings
1. George Amundson-took Iowa State to Liberty Bowl, runner up in Heisman, drafted 14th in the first round. All American
2. Seneca Wallace-led Iowa state to multiple bowl games, brought ISU back from the dead, drafted 4th round 110th
3. Sage Rosenfelds-draftet 109 in 4th round
4. Bret Meyer-all time passing leader, led Iowa State to bowl game

 

[cmoore_23]

actually sage kinda brought isu back.. when u think about it

 

[CloneFan65]

Archer has to be up there too.

 

[cyclonepower]

bob utter was pretty good...just kidding

 

[brianhos]

Espinoza... acutally I have no Idea if he was any good, he was just the qb when I was a kid.

 

[Cy Hard]

Without question Marv Seiler.

 

[djcubby]

Todd Doxon :yes:

 

[acgclone]

Gotta love Marv! It's been a while since the FB program has had an upset like that.

 

[cyclonedcm]

Buddy Hardeman, Wayne Stanley

 

[cyclonedcm]

Dean Carlson

 

[tyrelrobert]

:yes:Austin Flynn :yes:

 

[herbicide]

Here's my ratings
1. George Amundson-took Iowa State to Liberty Bowl, runner up in Heisman, drafted 14th in the first round. All American
2. Seneca Wallace-led Iowa state to multiple bowl games, brought ISU back from the dead, drafted 4th round 110th
3. Sage Rosenfelds-draftet 109 in 4th round
4. Bret Meyer-all time passing leader, led Iowa State to bowl game

I'd say the # 2 spot is a tie between Seneca and Sage. I will never forget Sage's bowl play. It was incredible

 

[keepngoal]

I'd say the # 2 spot is a tie between Seneca and Sage. I will never forget Sage's bowl play. It was incredible

My favorite play of Sage's: the bootleg at Iowa racing to the corner for a touchdown.

-keep

 

[CRcyclone6]

Without question Marv Seiler.

the best 78-yd run in ISU history that day, then Chris Ulrich banging it in from 2 yards out. awesome! Honorable Mention could be Bret Oberg, he put up some numbers.

 

[Cy Hard]

I think someday a few years down the road we'll see Arnaud's name on this list. He's the real deal.

 

[Wx4Cy]

David Archer....

 

[cyclonelifer]

Dean Carlson was a great QB ( first ever ISU bowl team,) but I wonder if he would have started if ISU didn't need Amundson as a RB that year

 

[CyclonesRule]

All the names mentioned have been good ones. Todd Bandhauer was pretty good too

 

[loboclone]

Here's my ratings
1. George Amundson-took Iowa State to Liberty Bowl, runner up in Heisman, drafted 14th in the first round. All American
2. Seneca Wallace-led Iowa state to multiple bowl games, brought ISU back from the dead, drafted 4th round 110th
3. Sage Rosenfelds-draftet 109 in 4th round
4. Bret Meyer-all time passing leader, led Iowa State to bowl game

After all these years and looking at responses.......no question, Geo. Amudson with Dean Carlson and Seneca after that. I've watched them all and based upon the young puppies here...you had to be there!

 

[bellzisu]

Sage brought this program back from the dead with his hard nosed gritty plays. He didn't have the speed of Seneca, and maybe the arm strength. What he had was heart.

Seneca led ISU to 2 bowl games in 2 years, but the second half of his senior year might of been the biggest collapse of ISU history.

Brett led us to two bowl games in his fresh and soph yrs. For whatever reason, and it's probably because of line play, but ISU went backwards his Jr and rebuilt his Sr year.

Big toss up between these three. I wish I was old enough to see someone like Archer and others. Although, I became a Cyclone fan when Bandhauer was QB. I just remember that he had one heck of an arm. Just too bad that was all he had going for him while here.