How to negotiate starting salary (mega-corps)?

Carlisle Clone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 2, 2019
435
773
93
50
I'd start at $125-$135k. If they like you as a candidate they won't eliminate you, they'll simply come back and say, "our offer is $XYZ". No one is walking away from a desired candidate because the candidate asked for a few grand more than HR was willing to pay.

Also how did they react / body language when you said at least $100k? Did they bat an eye?

When was this question asked in the interview process? If it was early on and talks continued they are ok with the 100k. They wouldnt waste their time with someone they couldnt afford after an earlier round of interviews failing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cowgirl836

3TrueFans

Just a Happily Married Man
Sep 10, 2009
63,136
61,688
113
Ames
so the position has been open for a while. and they weren't satisfied with the candidate pool during the first round of interviews (this was said during the interview).

I applied and had an email from the manager in like 3 hours. interviewed the next day
Ask for a milly.
 

KnappShack

Well-Known Member
May 26, 2008
23,656
31,927
113
Parts Unknown
its a 5 state area with the majority of the action in southern michigan, northern indiana, northern ohio.

I grew up VERY poor in western iowa. so thats why 100k sounds like a million dollars to me

$100k IS good money. We can get skewed when salaries and earnings are talked about. Isn't the median household income something like $65k?
That said, it's up to you to maximize your earnings and keep your personal goals in mind. Your salary impacts savings, retirement, lifestyle, etc.

Chasing the dollar has a cost. Not maximizing income also has a cost.
 
  • Like
Reactions: mramseyISU

Frog

Well-Known Member
May 6, 2021
399
482
63
56
Hope you land the job and get a good salary! Channel did its job. Filling a cart with DEKALB right now! Yields are great.
 

LeaningCy

Well-Known Member
Jan 18, 2008
3,299
6,040
113
It's the easy smart move longterm. I found out I was getting SCREWED salary wise at my old place. 10s of thousands. When I had concrete proof.....I didn't leave immediately. Took time to get things in place plus a pregnancy. But I definitely quiet quit. And then took a decade of institutional knowledge with me. Maybe they feel it was worth it but I know other coworkers in a similar spot and it just destroys morale. Especially after I and others were made to feel greedy after asking for higher at promotion time.

This brings to mind a response I like to use in these situations, it goes something like this:

"Ultimately, I want to be compensated fairly and in line with my peers at (fill in the blank company). I'd hate to find out in the future that I'm being paid significantly more or less than my peers for similar work. My hope is that (fill in the blank company) will place me in a similar salary band as my peers with equivalent education and experience. I'm confident I'll prove my worth and help the company grow toward (insert some specific example here)"

Lots of other good advice in this thread. Definitely have recent comps in your back pocket to support negotiations if needed.

I work in an R&D environment (albeit in a different industry) and think you could easily ask for $125-135k with a PhD depending on your experience.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,743
41,265
113
Waukee
its a 5 state area with the majority of the action in southern michigan, northern indiana, northern ohio.

I grew up VERY poor in western iowa. so thats why 100k sounds like a million dollars to me

Neither of my parents and none of my grandparents went to college.

It would be interesting to poll what those sorts of socioeconomics look like on here...
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Dr.bannedman

Nelcyn

Well-Known Member
Nov 29, 2012
732
712
93
Colorado
If they don't tell you the range you need to ask them again. Tell them it will be a waste of time if both of you get to the end and their salary is a joke. At least are they in the ball park. Otherwise, both parties are wasting their time. If you still can not get anything then I guess just wait until the end and see what they are willing to pay. They will pay if they really want you.
 

Nelcyn

Well-Known Member
Nov 29, 2012
732
712
93
Colorado
Those ranges can be pretty wild, though. I've seen some from those states (non-academic) that say things like "75-150k,) which isn't exactly helpful.
Even a wide salary range is ok and don't base it off you current salary. Really find the market price. I went to a interview just for practice and they didn't give me a range. Got through three interviews and they offered me 60k less than I was expecting. I felt embarrassed and then awkward for them.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Dr.bannedman

cowgirl836

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2009
50,970
42,363
113
This brings to mind a response I like to use in these situations, it goes something like this:

"Ultimately, I want to be compensated fairly and in line with my peers at (fill in the blank company). I'd hate to find out in the future that I'm being paid significantly more or less than my peers for similar work. My hope is that (fill in the blank company) will place me in a similar salary band as my peers with equivalent education and experience. I'm confident I'll prove my worth and help the company grow toward (insert some specific example here)"

Lots of other good advice in this thread. Definitely have recent comps in your back pocket to support negotiations if needed.

I work in an R&D environment (albeit in a different industry) and think you could easily ask for $125-135k with a PhD depending on your experience.
Part 2 to this is if you have a good to high performing employee several years in with no promotion and they come asking for one - you're already behind the 8 ball. Seen this play out too many times.
 

besserheimerphat

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
11,377
15,075
113
Mount Vernon, WA
There is big industry in that MI/OH/IN corridor. They shouldn't shut down discussion at $130ish. I'm sure every company out there has or knows of others making that and more with the auto industry. Especially given your apparent qualifications. Lots of competition for high performing professionals, and the auto industry can pay. That drives up wages for everyone.

Is relocation a factor? That's another place you can negotiate. They should make it easy for you to start working there. Paying for a moving company, several months of storage, possibly cover food or a per diem for the first month, temporary housing, etc. But it's a one time benefit rather than an ongoing one like salary.

When I relocated to western WA, my employer paid for food and put me in a company-paid apartment for 3 months while we looked for housing. Also flew my wife out here to look for houses before we moved the family out.
 

TitanClone

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 21, 2008
3,315
2,562
113
I've worked for Cerner for over 7 years, Oracle now since they bought us this year. Know that your offer for an entry level position will likely be around 80% of what the companies target for the role is. Check https://www.levels.fyi/ and ask for at least the average stated on there. I've talked with college buddies who work for Microsoft and Amazon and they follow the same practice. Start people at 80%, target to get them to 100%, cap at 120% until they get promoted. Before I was "high" enough to see salary ranges I got a random bump that was like 13% because unknown to me I was that much less than the 80% mark for my role. That was a fun conversation with my boss.

Also somethings that's paid off for me was making it clear to my boss right after I started that money is key. Companies are buying our services and it's not 1972 with the attitude of just be grateful for having a job.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gunnerclone

simply1

Rec Center HOF
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 10, 2009
44,777
33,460
113
Pdx
Some states now have to publish ranges. CO, CA, NY I believe. There's also ranges for..I forget...some visa thing, there's a database you can look in, bawbie probably knows of what I speak. Typing and chasing kid on the road.
This. A lot of listings now try to hide this info in the job listing, but it’s there.
 

1100011CS

Well-Known Member
Oct 5, 2007
16,078
5,788
113
Marshalltown
Know your worth. Know the salary midpoint and range for the job.

Then stick to it. Because they also have this info.
I had an employee come in and tell me exactly what she wanted for a salary and said she did her homework. She came in about $20k less than I was going to pay.

Her starting salary was exactly what she said she was worth.
How do you know this? It's not like companies publish their salaries. I don't even know how I compare to my co-workers in the company I work for.
 

cowgirl836

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2009
50,970
42,363
113
How do you know this? It's not like companies publish their salaries. I don't even know how I compare to my co-workers in the company I work for.

And for companies too small to be on a subreddit, ask coworkers you are close with as long as you aren't senior to them like a manager. Reach out to coworkers who've left. Look for similar job postings in states required to disclose.
 

cycloner29

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
12,749
12,268
113
Ames
I was selling equipment in the seven and eight figure range for a number of years. Was approached for a different job. Went back to the my current employer and told them were I wanted to be at. My boss told me I needed provide him with reasons I needed that amount. JFC!!! Dude couldn't even look at any of my prior years sales to show my growth in sales. Was in his office talking with him about it and his phone rings. He took the damn call!! That was the last straw. I was upfront and told him I had another job offer and that I had two let them know it two weeks thinking that would speed up a new offer. He himmed and hawwed around for two weeks. He came back with a measley raise of less that a grand. I told him "I need to do what's best for me and my family" and I slide my resignation letter to him right then and there. He said I had this all planned out. I reminded him that I told him I was going to make a decision in a two weeks.

My new job that I took I had negotiated a 30% pay increase and they also made my monthly payments on my new car. Before I accepted, I wanted to toy with my current employer as I new full well they would never match it. Felt so damn good to play mind games with them!