STEVE DEACE: The future of college football

MeanDean

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
Jan 5, 2009
14,571
20,757
113
Blue Grass IA-Jensen Beach FL
No, no, no, no, no, no, no....

"Playoff consists of the four winners of the super conferences, seeded by the playoff selection committee, unless a non-super conference team is ranked in the top four. In that case, they would replace the lowest ranked super conference champion."
 
  • Dislike
Reactions: CycoCyclone

Die4Cy

Well-Known Member
Jan 2, 2010
14,972
15,857
113
I think if it were up to one person to make these decsions, something like this would have happened already.

But the reason college football finds itself where it currently is at, is because these decisions are being made in a decentralized manner by parties fully acting in their own self interest.

So no, it'll never happen.
 

NATEizKING

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2011
19,646
12,054
113
Hilton
The college football model just sucks, am I'm not sure there is much you can do to fix it. College basketball is the ideal model, but you can't play that many football games. The best thing they did in college football was make a playoff.
 

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,089
31,186
113
So he rehashes the same stuff everyone else does? By the way I think he still owes me a refund from the cyclone magazine he had many years ago. Let him go back to preaching on the radio, or whatever he is doing now days. CF has a great staff and he would add nothing to it.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,837
41,381
113
Waukee
K St. and Texas Tech are the newest and proudest members of the American if that went down, yes.

64 - 14 (B1G) - 14 (SEC) - 14 (ACC) - 12 (Pac-16) leaves 10 slots remaining

Those ten slots don't all go to the Big 12... Two go to Notre Dame and BYU, leaving two out of the game of musical chairs.

He throws Iowa State a bone as a good geographical an academic fit with the Big Ten. That is nice. I could just as easily see them going for Kansas, though, given their academics and basketball program. They're not that much worse of geographic fit, either, for that matter.

TTU could be a package deal with UT.

I could easily see Kansas State and Iowa State being the two left out in the cold. Each are midwestern agricultural schools with small but dedicated fan bases but nothing to offer in terms of television or much of a tradition. They both have fell universities in the state that might not help them very much, either.
 

jdoggivjc

Well-Known Member
Sep 27, 2006
61,617
23,870
113
Macomb, MI
K St. and Texas Tech are the newest and proudest members of the American if that went down, yes.

64 - 14 (B1G) - 14 (SEC) - 14 (ACC) - 12 (Pac-16) leaves 10 slots remaining

Those ten slots don't all go to the Big 12... Two go to Notre Dame and BYU, leaving two out of the game of musical chairs.

He throws Iowa State a bone as a good geographical an academic fit with the Big Ten. That is nice. I could just as easily see them going for Kansas, though, given their academics and basketball program. They're not that much worse of geographic fit, either, for that matter.

TTU could be a package deal with UT.

I could easily see Kansas State and Iowa State being the two left out in the cold. Each are midwestern agricultural schools with small but dedicated fan bases but nothing to offer in terms of television or much of a tradition. They both have fell universities in the state that might not help them very much, either.

Iowa State isn't getting left out - the Pac 12 is our worst-case scenario. Everyone keeps acting like Iowa is this small population state with no TV sets - it's not. 3 million new TV sets is a lot more than most states between the Missouri River and the Pacific Ocean can offer, and excluding the existing states in the Pac 12 (California, Arizona, Washington, Oregon, Colorado, and Utah - and, for the record, Iowa has more people than Utah and only 1 million less than Oregon), the states that have greater populations than that (only Texas, Oklahoma, and Colorado) either won't be going to the Pac 12 (maybe Texas goes, but they sure as hell won't take TCU or BYU, and Tech only goes only if Texas goes to bat for them, and then the academics are so bad they may not want them anyway; OU and OSU probably go to the SEC; and Colorado is already there and CSU likely won't go). The only other two states that are even close in population are Nevada (no Nevada school will end up in the Pac 12) and Kansas (KU could be a "travel partner" with us, if they don't get picked up by the Big 10. K-State will likely never get taken to the Pac 12 for the same reasons as TT, except KU doesn't have nearly the same leverage as Texas).

The Pac 12 wants public universities and/or private, non-religious universities, both with high academic profiles. Once you get past Texas, Oklahoma, and Kansas, three schools that may not even be there for the Pac 12, who the hell else is there for the Pac 12 to take? ISU would be a damn good school for them, even if there's a 2000-mile gap between us and most of them.
 

jwrussel

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 29, 2006
157
135
43
40
Ankeny, IA
Sorry Steve but this is an out-of-date theory. The super-conferences that we see now are just step to the ultimate end of one giant "conference." The single conference model will allow the schools to leverage the most out of TV money. In essence, if the TV companies want major college football they will have to negotiate with the single conference.
Within the single conference, there will be divisions. Expect the divisions to be regional. This will allow for efficient use of resources, create more natural rivals (or recreate one's that have been split by conference realignment). It will also help with another issue, attendance. As all the money is pooled there will no longer be the need for conferences to be spread out to garner more TV markets.
Also, expect more than 64. I would suspect more likely in the range of 75-80 teams. There may be some left out, but I do not suspect a lot. Why cut out fans when you can make money off them instead?
Look for 7-8 divisions of 10-11 teams. Schedules will be round robin (double round-robin in basketball).
 

Beyerball

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jun 18, 2013
7,470
6,805
113
Texas
Like others have said..no way PAC takes BYU, Baylor or TCU...lol..So you can start over and take that into account...PAC presidents worry more than the BIG presidents about academics..Don't think for one second that half of these Presidents really care about Athletics cause they don't. Athletics to them is a drop in the bucket compared to the billions research brings in...drop in the bucket.

Just because those are TExas schools doesn't mean they will get into this situation at all. Accept BYU that is.
 

Rogue52

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Oct 20, 2006
8,964
3,601
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
Another super conference proposal...

Except this one thinks some magical higher-up negotiates among the four remaining conferences for dividing the Big 12 AND some members are still left out?!

This should have just been posted in the realignment thread by the writer if he wished. Not sure why it necessitated a special post.

Actually, a new forum for "Fantasy" would have been a better fit.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron