I thought about it. I'm really a Star Wars geek. Not really bad though. I'm not totally tubby and I don't live in my parent's basement.
I love A New Hope and Empire. The problem is that I start to look at the six movies as a whole and I'm less enthusiastic.
Part of me thinks that I want to glorify them because I remember them from my childhood. People always remember things better than they actually are/were.
Then there is the fact that Episodes I, II, and III completely sucked.
The kid in I couldn't act and the story sucked, the kid in II couldn't cat and the story sucked, and in III...well you see that pattern.
A good thing was ruined by 3 average movies, at best.
I felt that the last 30 minutes of II and all of III were pretty good because Lucas finally gave us Jedi, and lots of them, doing awesome Jedi ****. But the contrived romance and Natalie Portman trying to act were just awful. The new trilogy as a whole however really soils the original trilogy, and that is unfortunate. It's almost best to think of them as entirely separate entities.
My list would be:
The Rock
Transformers
Batman Begins/The Dark Knight (it's not out yet, but it will kick some serious posterior)
The Matrix (1)
Anchorman