Some revisions are in order IMO:
Grayer would have been a 5 star (5 star very doubtful, 4 star yes)
Hoiberg a low 5 star possibly high 5 star (same as Grayer, his football options perhaps hurt his basketball stock, he really wasn't a typical 5-star recruiting commodity at the time)
Hurl Beachum would have been top 150 (probably not that high)
Lafester Rhodes was actually a huge recruit. Probably 4 star (Agree)
Sam Mack was a huge recruit (not a 5 star, likely a 4 star)
Big Vic was a 4 star type player (I don't recall his stock being that high)
Hornacek was a walkon but he was known. Probably a 3 star player (Absolutely not, a 2 star kid at the high major level)
Barry Stevens was probably a 3 or 4 star guy. Ended up a 5 star in my book. (Agree)
Ronnie Virgil 3 star type guy. (Agree)
Elmer Robinson 3 or 4 star guy (Baseball options for Elmer reduced his stock to no more than a 3 star)
Loren Meyer was a 4 star guy (Actually he might have been a 5 star, he was a Top 5 or 10 center recruit but his early commitment to ISU reduced his recruiting buzz)
Julius was probably a 2 star guy since nobody knew who he was (ISU beat UCLA for Julo so he was at least a 3 star type)