Not trying to fact check but, according to Wiki, both (Smart and Prohm) have been at their respected schools the same amount of seasons and both have the same conference record (40-50). Overall, SP has 5 more wins 95 vs. 90 in that same time frame. To me these are the relevant statistics in this debate. I would say that both have underachieved in their respective roles. One could definitely argue that Smart is the bigger underachiever of the two because, well Texas, and Barnes left the program in a very solid spot of consistency. I would say that both have been pretty.....meh. It will be interesting to follow the story lines here as both came in at the same time, and have the same conference record at present. Will one, or both, rise up, or will either of them fall out of favor?