WVU fans do NOT consider Cincinatti a rival. That said, WVU fans are passionate and travel. We had a strong presence at UCF last weekend. At least 5000, maybe more. I was there on the 50 yard line with a row 1 seat.
Finally, after 10 years without complaint, the Big 12 adds a team that WVU fans can easily travel to the away game. And while cinn. isnt a rival, like Pitt and VT, WVU was in the same conference with them for a while, and they were good with brian kelley as their coach.
Then the Big 12 adds some western schools, with WVU's blessing (big picture), but makes WVU travel out west twice in some years, and doesnt give WVU an annual game with the team in its backyard.
Pods would've worked. The only team that would've been screwed in a pod system was Houston, assuming they got kicked east. Even then, they would still be in a pod with former aac conference foes ucf and cinn.