***Fresno State (2/9) and @ UNI (2/10) Duals***

Bam bam

Member
Nov 10, 2017
67
45
18
I think Degen is having a fine freshman year and hope he continues, but I really don't get the over the top love he gets here. His 2 best wins by far are against Jeffries of OK who is ranked 26/27. Next best win is against Dante 5-3, so yeah, I could see a case to be made for a wrestleoff based on what we know from the outside looking in.

Of course we do not see what goes on in the room. Call it favoritism if you like, I prefer to say that both St. John's and Degen have the advantage of familiarity with the staff
I think this is a fair assessment of the situation. Coaching changes are bumpy and these coaches don't likely know the other guys as well. These coaches have a history and developed relationships with these two guys. Naturally they will be more comfortable with the coaches and the coaches with them.
 

Bam bam

Member
Nov 10, 2017
67
45
18
I'm more concerned about the FIVE losses to UNI by 1-2 points than I am about the methodology behind determining who's wrestling 165 on any given day.
You are right, the big picture is whaatters here and this is worrisome. Several of our dual losses have gone down this way. I haven't watched all of the meets, but it appears that several of the dual losses were a lot closer than the final team score would indicate. This team is so close, they just have to find a way to win those close matches. I think they are headed in the right direction.
 

jkbuff98

Well-Known Member
Jan 3, 2017
2,902
4,125
113
I respectfully disagree. As someone else already pointed out, as long he shares the same last name as one of the coaches and posts the kind of results he has, then this is probably something he will have to deal with--right or wrong. I worked for my dad for years, so trust me, I know first hand what it is like. It goes with the territory. And, if you think for one minute that coaches don't have "their guys" then you are nuts and if you think the kids don't notice and discuss it, you are delusional. Of course they do. You don't have to have a connection to anyone to know that. I am new here and a wrestling fan from afar. I joined because I was excited about this new era and hoped to glean some insight about the program and engage in discussion with other fans. One other conclusion you could "infer" from these comments is that sometines the folks that are the least connected can see things that those that are most connected can't.

I am a little confused here, you seem to know all about the wrestle offs, the scores , when they were scheduled,what the team feels about it , but you aren't connected ?
 

buf87

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2010
12,071
12,421
113
Iowa
These 3 don't bother me that much, even any would be a great win for possible NCAA berths, but none hurt their chances since we were not favored in these
Degen vs Thomsen
Colbray vs Holschlag
Pestano vs Foster

but we needed wins by
Straw vs Ryan &
Harrington vs Isley.

I am more looking at NCAA bids.

Wrestling in West Gym is an environment that has a strong home advantage.
We are going to need to be ready at Big 12's
 
  • Like
  • Agree
Reactions: jkbuff98 and Judoka

Primetime26

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2012
633
525
93
These 3 don't bother me that much, even any would be a great win for possible NCAA berths, but none hurt their chances since we were not favored in these
Degen vs Thomsen
Colbray vs Holschlag
Pestano vs Foster

but we needed wins by
Straw vs Ryan &
Harrington vs Isley.

I am more looking at NCAA bids.

Wrestling in West Gym is an environment that has a strong home advantage.
We are going to need to be ready at Big 12's

Thanks for moving this on Buf. I am with you. I was expecting a win from Colbray after his run of late. If he could open his offense instead of winning in OT he can be very very good. I think he will keep improving.
 

Primetime26

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2012
633
525
93
He lost to the same guy 2-9 earlier this season so just making it close was a big step in the right direction

Your right.

To be clear, I didn't say he didn't improve. I was just saying that if/when he opens it up he will be lights out.
 

Bam bam

Member
Nov 10, 2017
67
45
18
I am a little confused here, you seem to know all about the wrestle offs, the scores , when they were scheduled,what the team feels about it , but you aren't connected ?
Oh Jesus, are you kidding me? No I am not connected to this team any more than anyone else that has an opinion or scores or anything else. Don't be confused, it's simple bud. I picked up the information I have from asking people that do know, reading other posts and following on Twitter. And when did I say I knew how the team feels about anything? I said I can guarantee that if there is perceived favoritism they are talking about it. You don't have to be connected to anyone or anything to know this. It happens in places of employment, on sports teams everywhere and in families. It is a part of life. By the logic of people like you, then every person that has questioned why one kid got a wrestle off when that didn't seem to be the precedent set at other weights is "connected" to the team. That's BS. It was a weird decision--lots of people agree on that-- and those of us looking for an explanation mentioned what a lot of people were thinking. Of course there is favoritism and of course there is nepotism at work everywhere in the world. Everywhere. To think that the ISU wrestling room is immune to it is just plain ignorant.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: blangISU

Bam bam

Member
Nov 10, 2017
67
45
18
These 3 don't bother me that much, even any would be a great win for possible NCAA berths, but none hurt their chances since we were not favored in these
Degen vs Thomsen
Colbray vs Holschlag
Pestano vs Foster

but we needed wins by
Straw vs Ryan &
Harrington vs Isley.

I am more looking at NCAA bids.

Wrestling in West Gym is an environment that has a strong home advantage.
We are going to need to be ready at Big 12's
What do you think Straw's chances are of getting an automatic bid? I don't really understand how all of that works.
 

Bam bam

Member
Nov 10, 2017
67
45
18
He lost to the same guy 2-9 earlier this season so just making it close was a big step in the right direction
I believe I read here or Dresser said in a press conference that Colbray was sick all week too. That may have affected his performance. I think he will peak at the right time.
 
  • Like
Reactions: csteve

Judoka

Well-Known Member
Jun 16, 2010
17,542
2,645
113
Timbuktu
What do you think Straw's chances are of getting an automatic bid? I don't really understand how all of that works.

Slightly better than zero but not much greater than that. Even if he beat Kemerer on Sunday it wouldn't be a sure thing that he'd show up in the coaches panel high enough to make the allocations cut.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: csteve

ISU22CY

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2012
5,116
6,736
113
Iowa
These 3 don't bother me that much, even any would be a great win for possible NCAA berths, but none hurt their chances since we were not favored in these
Degen vs Thomsen
Colbray vs Holschlag
Pestano vs Foster

but we needed wins by
Straw vs Ryan &
Harrington vs Isley.


I am more looking at NCAA bids.

Wrestling in West Gym is an environment that has a strong home advantage.
We are going to need to be ready at Big 12's

Harrington one I guess was the one that really took me. I know he was trying to go straight for the win but I thought he could have taken it in SV if he had ridden him out.
 

buf87

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2010
12,071
12,421
113
Iowa
Harrington hasn't had much luck riding these real big guys. I haven't seen the match to know if it was an intentional escape.
 

ISU22CY

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2012
5,116
6,736
113
Iowa
Harrington hasn't had much luck riding these real big guys. I haven't seen the match to know if it was an intentional escape.
Good point about him not doing well on top. From what I saw and what was written it appeared to be an intentional release.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: jkbuff98

Judoka

Well-Known Member
Jun 16, 2010
17,542
2,645
113
Timbuktu
Good point about him not doing well on top. From what I saw and what was written it appeared to be an intentional release.

There was a restart at 0:22 left in the match and Harrington did an optional start so just gave up the point to make it 4-3. He was looking over towards the bench when he did it so I'm not sure if it was his idea or the coaches.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: jkbuff98

ISU22CY

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2012
5,116
6,736
113
Iowa
There was a restart at 0:22 left in the match and Harrington did an optional start so just gave up the point to make it 4-3. He was looking over towards the bench when he did it so I'm not sure if it was his idea or the coaches.
That's kinda why it was somewhat of a take back for me. With :22 I thought he had a better chance of riding him out vs getting a take down.
 

csteve

Well-Known Member
Feb 11, 2011
563
562
93
These 3 don't bother me that much, even any would be a great win for possible NCAA berths, but none hurt their chances since we were not favored in these
Degen vs Thomsen
Colbray vs Holschlag
Pestano vs Foster

but we needed wins by
Straw vs Ryan &
Harrington vs Isley.

I am more looking at NCAA bids.

Wrestling in West Gym is an environment that has a strong home advantage.
We are going to need to be ready at Big 12's
I agree with your assessment of most the losses.

I do think that the Colbray loss hurt his chances. He wasn't favored, but I think a win would have gone a long way in getting a possible allocation as he is 33 in coaches poll and 23 in RPI. A win and he would have jumped up in the coaches poll to earn a likely allocation. With the loss, I think the only chance of gaining an allocation is a win against Wilke. His weight class is one of the deepest in the Big12, but will likely only have 3 to 5 allocations and there are 9 or 10 solid wrestlers. This weight will be interesting to see the seeding as he has wins against 2 of the top 4 wrestlers at this weight. Either way, he's going to have to wrestle his tail off and beat someone who's likely earned an allocation!
 

buf87

Well-Known Member
Dec 15, 2010
12,071
12,421
113
Iowa
I agree with your assessment of most the losses.

I do think that the Colbray loss hurt his chances. He wasn't favored, but I think a win would have gone a long way in getting a possible allocation as he is 33 in coaches poll and 23 in RPI. A win and he would have jumped up in the coaches poll to earn a likely allocation. With the loss, I think the only chance of gaining an allocation is a win against Wilke. His weight class is one of the deepest in the Big12, but will likely only have 3 to 5 allocations and there are 9 or 10 solid wrestlers. This weight will be interesting to see the seeding as he has wins against 2 of the top 4 wrestlers at this weight. Either way, he's going to have to wrestle his tail off and beat someone who's likely earned an allocation!

I agree that a win by Colbray would have probably earned him a bid. Wins over Smith, Rotert and Holschlag would be hard to ignore.

I was just thinking (Maybe it was hoping) that a win by Straw and Harrington would have got them enough of a boost to get them farther up the coaches ranking to get a berth, but losses to guys (Isley & Ryan) in a similiar positions (probably were a little behind our guys) isn't going to help their causes.

We as a team need Big 12 berths by anyone and are going to have to go steal some. I think we have a fair amount of guys in the 27-37 rankings. (They will be just in or just out depending on how they do at Big 12s)
 
  • Agree
Reactions: csteve