Daily article about Cael.

cigaretteman

Well-Known Member
Nov 8, 2006
3,591
91
48
Iowa
What bothers me about Cael is that ISU basically made Bobby Douglas step aside so that Cael could run the program to keep Cael from bolting for another school's head coaching job. Bobby was an excellent coach, but he knew to keep ISU growing and to capitalize on it's potential, Cael had to be the coach. Bobby graciously obliged and gave Cael the raines. Then, for Cael to bolt to Penn State because it was easier and more money, it just struck me as a slap in the face to Bobby Douglas. Yes, I agree, if I get paid more money to do an easier job I would be crazy not to jump on it. Hard to fault Cael for leaving, but the job security he had at ISU was infinite, money would have been ponied up at some time, and it is achieving success at a place you made a name for yourself. He wasn't coaching at a mid-major, he was coaching at a traditional power. Titles could have been won at ISU. Is Cael a sellout...yes. But let me say this, Cael will win titles because of his recruiting, not because of his coaching. At ISU, Cael implemented a methodical, tactical wrestling style that left us losing a lot of matches late and getting upset by guy or teams that we should have beat. Jackson brings more of the aggressive approach that will be much more successful...if he can get the athletes in here.

:policeman:

People, the word is reins, not reigns or raines. Reins are what are used to control a horse. A king reigns over his country.

As you were:smile:
 

RayShimley

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2008
6,298
343
83
41
White Bear Lake, MN
You're right, ISU wrestling was nothing before Cael. - Did you talk to my wife? She has a habbit of reading into things I say. Did I say that ISU wasn't anything before Cael? Nope. Did I say that Cael did a lot for wrestling and ISU as far as exposure? Yep.
And BS he didn't take those kids with him. You are delusional if you think otherwise. - I must be delusional then. There is no way Cael went to those kids and said that they had to leave ISU. They chose on their own to follow the coach that recruited them. I'm sure if they felt like they wanted to stay, they could've stayed at ISU.

Any good Cael did for ISU wrestling he undid, and then some, when he left.
 

LutherBlue

Well-Known Member
Oct 19, 2006
2,311
660
113
This is not the same at all. Cael wasn't even from Iowa. Yes, he did go to school here and won more than anyone ever. Yes, he did coach here after he was done. However he felt it was in his best interest to leave. He didn't owe ISU anything. If anyone owes, ISU should owe him for everything that he accomplished and the exposure he gave wrestling and ISU. He also didn't take those kids with him. After Cael left, they chose on their own to leave ISU. Just like hundreds of kids do after they leave when the head coach leaves that recruited them.

All to often people on this board take things way to personal about ISU. People need to remember that it is a business and shouldn't blame others for making decision on what is best for their own family. I think we all would take a new job if it was the best decision for their own family.
Thank you.

Not every ISU alum is ga-ga in love with ISU and Ames. And if they're not, it doesn't make them a bad person. What was Cael's experience like here as a coach? Does anyone know besides him? Maybe he just didn't like as much as we want to believe. You may be beloved in your job but if there are things about it you don't like, you would leave if/when a better opportunity came along. And you shouldn't have to apologize for that.

I have no idea what was going through his head. Maybe he hated Pollard. Maybe he was sick of being the Chosen One. Maybe he just wanted more money. Maybe he was tired of Hickory Park. Maybe Tom Brands was in his head. I just don't care. Once he decided to move on, I moved on. He was a great Cyclone and brought more fame to ISU than ISU could ever give back to him. Let it go. We have a great coach now and ISU wrestling will be back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CyBobby and CykoAGR

isukendall

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
2,446
581
113
Fort Collins, CO
:policeman:

People, the word is reins, not reigns or raines. Reins are what are used to control a horse. A king reigns over his country.

As you were:smile:

When Cael left he took the entire 2009 recruiting class other than Weatherman with him. His timing was such that it was too late for Jackson to recruit any other elite guys. Additionally, it also caused us to lose a big portion of the 2008 recruiting class. Finally, he took his brother Cyler with him. If I recall he tried to bring other guys with him, but ISU wouldn't release them. The points that Cyler would have scored for us would have likely been the difference between our third place finish and first place finish last year.

Cael cleaned out the cubbard and left it totally bare for Jackson, that's why people have a problem with how he left.

:policeman: Well while we're at it, it's a cupboard. :confused:
 

jdoggivjc

Well-Known Member
Sep 27, 2006
61,623
23,874
113
Macomb, MI
One, I have not heard anywhere that JP wasn't willing to match whatever salary PSU offered Cael. So it wasn't the money.

"Money" isn't solely about salary, as in the money he would personally earn, but it's also about the amount that the AD is willing/able to sink into the program to enable success.

There is no doubt that JP was, if not willing, then at least able to match whatever salary Penn St might have thrown at Cael (within reason, obviously). What JP might not have been able to match is the open checkbook for wrestling-specific facilities. ISU has historically had issues funding a $5 million scoreboard and a $10 million combo soccer/track/softball facility. Other sports, such as volleyball and gymnastics, have to make do with facilities likely not up to par with little to no hope of ever getting top-notch facilities. So was Cael likely ever to get anywhere close to the facilities he was being promised at Penn St? Unlikely, unless some anonymous donor/s stepped up to provide, which, apparently, there was no indication they existed.

Like I said, "money" is an issue that extends far beyond what an AD is willing/able to pay a coach.
 

isukendall

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
2,446
581
113
Fort Collins, CO
Thank you.

Not every ISU alum is ga-ga in love with ISU and Ames. And if they're not, it doesn't make them a bad person. What was Cael's experience like here as a coach? Does anyone know besides him? Maybe he just didn't like as much as we want to believe. You may be beloved in your job but if there are things about it you don't like, you would leave if/when a better opportunity came along. And you shouldn't have to apologize for that.

I have no idea what was going through his head. Maybe he hated Pollard. Maybe he was sick of being the Chosen One. Maybe he just wanted more money. Maybe he was tired of Hickory Park. Maybe Tom Brands was in his head. I just don't care. Once he decided to move on, I moved on. He was a great Cyclone and brought more fame to ISU than ISU could ever give back to him. Let it go. We have a great coach now and ISU wrestling will be back.

If this is true there's an easy solution. I could never get tired of Battle's......
 

joefrog

Well-Known Member
Apr 29, 2008
8,207
2,543
113
Clive, Iowa
Any good Cael did for ISU wrestling he undid, and then some, when he left.

Absolutely.

And everyone else, with your bashing of Cael, I agree with you too. Absolutely disgusting what he did to his alma mater, and his coach. We pushed aside a great man and mentor, just to give Cael his shot. He responded by running away and poaching recruits on the way out. Not cool.

I do think that while KJ may not get quite the recruits CS would, he will get more out of the ones he brings to Ames. They will wrestle to win, and they will wrestle hard, and they will be tough. I love the KJ attitude way more than what CS brought.

May I just say that I am thrilled to see Iowa State fans not cheering those who use and abandon us. Ostracism and shame work. Let's make this practice common for all sports too. I don't care what sport, if you could have gone to ISU and done us all proud, but you ran away to a "glamorous" school to just be another in the crowd, sorry, I am not going to cheer for you or hope you did well. I am a Cyclone. You chose not to be. Buh-bye.
 
  • Like
Reactions: skibumspe

LutherBlue

Well-Known Member
Oct 19, 2006
2,311
660
113
When Cael left he took the entire 2009 recruiting class other than Weatherman with him.
We released David Taylor and Luke Macchioroli (sp?) from Arizona who's since transferred to ASU. Cael did not "take" Boaz Beard or Weatherman. And Jamie Clark decided to go to Illinois, not PSU.

Of course Cyler went with his brothers. And Iowa beat us at nationals by almost 60 points, I don't think Cyler was the difference.
 

CykoAGR

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2008
1,691
69
48
44
Waukee, IA
Wow, I cant believe the grudge that some people still have against Cael. Did he “sell out”, to some extent sure, again I just don’t buy for one second that anyone else in their right mind would not have done the same thing.

For the person who said that Cael would not have had the success that he did had he not come to ISU, I guess I disagree to some extent. Would he have been undefeated, maybe not. However the fact that Cael had the dedication and put in the time to achieve what he did tells me that he would have still been pretty damn good, like probably still a 3-4 time Champ but no one will ever know that.

ISU did Cael a “favor” by allowing him to stay on and coach while training for the Olympics, but you’re crazy if you don’t think that the ISU wrestlers and the program as a whole benefited from this time as an assistant. The positive publicity brought in talent and the practice time with someone as good as him can only improve others in the room. I would say that it was a win-win for both Cael and ISU at this time. As for him getting preferential treatment and what others have called forcing Bobby D out, look at the NCAA final rankings from Bobby’s last 5 yrs, a 2nd place finish in 01-02 then a best of 6th with 3 finishes at 10th or worse. Not exactly lighting things up or carrying on the tradition of being a “power” in college wrestling.

Cael was hired because ISU didn’t want another Gable incident where a superior ISU wrestler went to another school and have success. Oh yeah and the fact that he was the GREATEST college wrestler of all time. In his three years as coach Cael equaled the best finish that Bobby D had nationally and ISU won 3 consecutive B12 tittles.

It sucks that he “took” wrestlers with him when he left but lets face it, these kids sign up to wrestle for the COACH not the school. I know they commit to the school but the reality is it's the coach that makes the difference. Let me ask you this, if this would have been the other way around and we brought in a new coach who “took” wrestlers from his old school and brought them to ISU, would you still be on you moral high horse? I'm guessing you would be giddy to have the talent and say that the kids deserve a chance to wrestle for the coach that they chose even if it meant changing schools.

Sure it stung when he left, but I for one still don’t blame him. Does it suck? Sure. Am I over it, well if KJ is as good as some think he is I will be in a few years when ISU is back in the hunt.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cyclone06

weR138

Well-Known Member
Feb 20, 2008
12,187
5,138
113
Thank you.

Not every ISU alum is ga-ga in love with ISU and Ames. And if they're not, it doesn't make them a bad person. What was Cael's experience like here as a coach? Does anyone know besides him? Maybe he just didn't like as much as we want to believe. You may be beloved in your job but if there are things about it you don't like, you would leave if/when a better opportunity came along. And you shouldn't have to apologize for that.

I have no idea what was going through his head. Maybe he hated Pollard. Maybe he was sick of being the Chosen One. Maybe he just wanted more money. Maybe he was tired of Hickory Park. Maybe Tom Brands was in his head. I just don't care. Once he decided to move on, I moved on. He was a great Cyclone and brought more fame to ISU than ISU could ever give back to him. Let it go. We have a great coach now and ISU wrestling will be back.

It seems like you care, a lot.
 

Madclone1

Well-Known Member
Oct 21, 2007
2,035
69
48
We released David Taylor and Luke Macchioroli (sp?) from Arizona who's since transferred to ASU. Cael did not "take" Boaz Beard or Weatherman. And Jamie Clark decided to go to Illinois, not PSU.

Of course Cyler went with his brothers. And Iowa beat us at nationals by almost 60 points, I don't think Cyler was the difference.

What's your point/s? Let me guess . . "everything is Cool with Cael. Don't criticize . . no derogatories . . . everything is fair when it comes to chasing BIG MONEY." "Screw ISU!" Correct?
 

LutherBlue

Well-Known Member
Oct 19, 2006
2,311
660
113
What's your point/s? Let me guess . . "everything is Cool with Cael. Don't criticize . . no derogatories . . . everything is fair when it comes to chasing BIG MONEY." "Screw ISU!" Correct?
Crying about fairness is for *******. Life isn't fair, where have you been? You won't hear Kevin Jackson crying about what's "fair" or "unfair."
 

Madclone1

Well-Known Member
Oct 21, 2007
2,035
69
48
Thank you.

Not every ISU alum is ga-ga in love with ISU and Ames. And if they're not, it doesn't make them a bad person. What was Cael's experience like here as a coach? Does anyone know besides him? Maybe he just didn't like as much as we want to believe. You may be beloved in your job but if there are things about it you don't like, you would leave if/when a better opportunity came along. And you shouldn't have to apologize for that.

I have no idea what was going through his head. Maybe he hated Pollard. Maybe he was sick of being the Chosen One. Maybe he just wanted more money. Maybe he was tired of Hickory Park. Maybe Tom Brands was in his head. I just don't care. Once he decided to move on, I moved on. He was a great Cyclone and brought more fame to ISU than ISU could ever give back to him. Let it go. We have a great coach now and ISU wrestling will be back.

You are not Clone. But I bet you are a hawkster . . nice try. Now go away.
 

weR138

Well-Known Member
Feb 20, 2008
12,187
5,138
113
LOL, should I take my Cyclone Wrestling Club membership and season tickets with me?

Only if you feel like it would be more advatageous to be the fan of a team that wins more often. After all, it's a business right? An emotional attachment to your alma mater shouldn't cloud a decision to cheer for an athletic team... or make more money.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron