Bill Lumbergh > Annie Wilkes as a villain is ridiculous.
Same with Jabba > Anton Chigurh.
Agree with you, lots of voters probably just haven't seen Misery or No Country for Old Men.
It depends on criteria. If it’s level of evil obviously Lumbergh is eliminated. If it’s identifying with any of our personal life villains he’d be the 1 seed.
Jabba is a pretty straight forward villain where the mafia leaders in most films are the anti-hero (none of the goodfellas or godfather gangsters are here). He murders slaves without remorse, enslaves two of our heroes, tries to kill all the heroes, and kind of sexually assaults one he put in a metal bikini.
I almost voted your way because I love both those books and films, but then I actually voted the other way. Honestly I’d probably rank all 4 films 8/10. Maybe misery and office space 7/10.
My beef with the voters are people who think agent smith is better than real life alien David Bowie.