Apartment Legal Advice

Clonehomer

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
22,130
17,912
113
Thats the thing, the lady and I actually get along very well and I apologized for the inconvenience to them and she said no biggy they actually have a waiting list on apartments like mine. So I doubt it would be an option just based off the fact that they have a line of people already wanting to move in.

I actually told her, hey not to screw you guys over or whatever but what if I dont pay it and she said well we put it as a skip on your leasing record, she didnt like threaten me or say we sue you or whatever soooo thats why I wondered what actually would happen.

Whether they have a waiting list or not has no bearing on your ability to sublease. The subletter takes over the remainder of your contract. Unless your contract states that you cannot sublease, the only thing your landlord can do is to not give them an option of renewing when your contract is up.
 

cdnlngld

Well-Known Member
Feb 24, 2012
1,909
479
83
47
Ames, IA
Here's the thing..... the contracts are there to keep the landlord from getting hung out to dry and being stuck int he off season with an apartment he/she can't fill and thus will not make any money on. It sounds like they would have no problem filling the apartment in your stead. If they can fill the apartment before you leave then the right thing for THEM to do is to let you out of the lease minus the cost of preparing the apt for the next tenant. If they can't fill it before you move out then the right thing for YOU to do is fulfill the contract, and pay the fines/ rent. If they are double dipping (filling the apartment right away AND charging you rent penalties for the remainder of the contract) they are just trying to get as much money as they can out of you and that is not right. This is coming from somebody that owns a rental property.
 

longtimeclone

Well-Known Member
Dec 8, 2009
7,952
230
63
Up north
Just called them, they said I can find someone to take over the lease, just not sublease. Whatever the difference is, either way, to craigslist I go.

It kind of sounds like they won't let you get out of the contract so if the subleasee stiffs you on the rent you are still liable for it.

Make sure to keep in mind your security deposit if this is the case.
 

azepp

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2009
3,964
140
63
Ankeny
Here's the thing..... the contracts are there to keep the landlord from getting hung out to dry and being stuck int he off season with an apartment he/she can't fill and thus will not make any money on. It sounds like they would have no problem filling the apartment in your stead. If they can fill the apartment before you leave then the right thing for THEM to do is to let you out of the lease minus the cost of preparing the apt for the next tenant. If they can't fill it before you move out then the right thing for YOU to do is fulfill the contract, and pay the fines/ rent. If they are double dipping (filling the apartment right away AND charging you rent penalties for the remainder of the contract) they are just trying to get as much money as they can out of you and that is not right. This is coming from somebody that owns a rental property.
Agree with this.

However, the fact remains that you signed a contract that says you're going to owe them $2,000. Negotiate your way out of it or be prepared for the ramifications. They might decide it's not worth the hassle and just let you go, but my guess is that a guy who owns 10,000 apartments didn't get there by letting people out of their leases with no penalty. Whether or not the owner is involved day-to-day, you can still go to him. He's human and he might be more willing to work with you than you think, but I doubt he's going to be ok with you just walking away without talking to you.
 

RayShimley

Well-Known Member
Sep 9, 2008
6,281
314
83
40
White Bear Lake, MN
Can you paste the exact language in the contract regarding the $2,000 dollar fine and subletting? Generally, if you are subletting you may void some portion of your security deposit, but I've never heard of someone dropping another 2 grand on top of that. That seems very excessive.

In regards to legal ramifications, being that the owed amount is less than $5,000, the rental company would have to take you to small claims court in order to legally compel you to pay. This is almost never done, and the larger the company, the less likely for them to bother with it (especially if they immediately fill the unit).
 

cy1010

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2009
3,047
86
48
I'm confused...if you find someone to sub-lease they are taking your lease. Why would you owe them an additional 2 grand as you are not terminating the contract (you are transferring it). I'm pretty sure it isn't kosher to charge you 2 grand while someone else rents the same space and are paying rent (as the amount of money is the same whether it comes from you or someone else).

You're not even transferring it. Your name is still on the rental agreement and you are still responsible for the monthly rent.

You need to see what the language says about sub-lessors and assignments.
 

kilgore_trout

Well-Known Member
Nov 10, 2006
2,190
101
63
Madison, WI
The landlord has a duty to attempt to re-rent the apartment. You can assist them with this, of course. The $2000 is just a buyout of the contract. You don't have to pay that to move out or to get another renter moved in.
 

erikbj

Well-Known Member
Aug 31, 2006
7,505
648
113
45
hiawatha, ia
Probably won't like my answer.

When you sign a contract, it is time to put on your big boy pants and honor the language of the contact (if negotiating out of it isn't successful). It may suck. It may be hard or inconvenient or expensive or any number of other unpleasant things, but a man (or woman) is only as good as his word, and by signing a contract, both parties are making a promise to each other.

He's right. IF you can find someone else to lease it, i am sure the company will let you do that. Just remember, they want the money that the apartment is going to generate. It's not a personal thing against you, its just business.

Just think if the apartment owner told you to move out next week because he had a buddy that needed a place to live. Wouldn't you expect the owner to live up to the contract you both signed?
 

Torks Pub

Well-Known Member
Dec 16, 2006
539
367
63
Ankeny
Thats the thing, the lady and I actually get along very well and I apologized for the inconvenience to them and she said no biggy they actually have a waiting list on apartments like mine. So I doubt it would be an option just based off the fact that they have a line of people already wanting to move in.

I actually told her, hey not to screw you guys over or whatever but what if I dont pay it and she said well we put it as a skip on your leasing record, she didnt like threaten me or say we sue you or whatever soooo thats why I wondered what actually would happen.

Given the apartment fire earlier this summer, and the number of residents that were forced out of their apartments, I would not be surprised if the manager did, indeed, have a wait list.

If that is the case, then they should sublease the unit for you and should only charge a leasing commission of $300 or so. Sticking the entire lease on you when they have a wait list would be unethical. Furthermore, you should be entitled to get back most of your security deposit as long as you leave the unit in shape per the requirements of your lease.

Most apartment managers in Ames will work with you, so keep in touch with the manager and ask about the subletting.

The apartments in Ames filled up at an unprecedented rate this year due to the fire. Many foreign students arriving late could not find suitable housing...
 

bringmagicback

Well-Known Member
Dec 3, 2009
7,858
1,110
83
CF Resident Dog Lover
Given the apartment fire earlier this summer, and the number of residents that were forced out of their apartments, I would not be surprised if the manager did, indeed, have a wait list.

If that is the case, then they should sublease the unit for you and should only charge a leasing commission of $300 or so. Sticking the entire lease on you when they have a wait list would be unethical. Furthermore, you should be entitled to get back most of your security deposit as long as you leave the unit in shape per the requirements of your lease.

Most apartment managers in Ames will work with you, so keep in touch with the manager and ask about the subletting.

The apartments in Ames filled up at an unprecedented rate this year due to the fire. Many foreign students arriving late could not find suitable housing...

I dont live in Ames, no fire.
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron