You’re obviously a youngster who doesn’t remember (recently) Mevis, Owens and Shaggy. Assalley was good, not great. Historically we’ve had Kohl, Shudak, Netten, Stewart and many others. That’s only place kickers. Punters creates another long list of talented folk.
We've had decent kickers, but people only remember the couple key missed FGs that would have gotten us to champ games, and assume our kickers sucked. They were at worst average for FBS college place-kickers.
The punting the previous two years (did the australian guy punt in the covid year? I forget) was unbelievably bad, though, until Mevis took over. It was fine before that.
Our kicking GAME has been god-awful in the CMC era. Coverage, returns, blocking, etc. 90% of that is not the kicker's fault