The Dumb Tiebreaker Problem

These giant conferences have to find a better way to determine who goes to the conference championship games, or else they should just get rid of the conference championship games entirely. We all know about Duke getting into the ACC championship game over Miami based on some weird formula, but it’s even dumber in a couple of the G5 conferences.

The Mountain West’s team selection for the championship game is a joke. All these teams finished 6-2 and it came down to analytics:

UNLV (10-2)
New Mexico (9-3)
San Diego State (9-3)
Boise State (8-4)

So what’s the championship game?

UNLV at Boise State. Because of course.

The MAC’s selection process was also stupid. They had:

Western Michigan (7-1)
Ohio (6-2)
Toledo (6-2)
Miami-Ohio (6-2)

Miami-Ohio lost to both Ohio and Toledo, but Ohio and Toledo didn’t play each other. So who plays Western Michigan in the conference championship game. Well, Miami-Ohio obviously.

Dumb.

Driving to Ames? Listen to this week's podcast on your drive!

Check out this week's Reaction Time!


Ben and I preview which matches we're looking forward to the most plus big storylines going into today's match. PLUS, Eli from The Register joined me to give insight into what to expect from the Hawkeyes.

Enjoy!

SEC = AVERAGE OR AWESOME

Over the last number of weeks I have seen many a SEC game where a below. 500 or right at .500 team has come oh so close to beating CFP teams or teams being considered for the CFP. Is the league just that good? Or overhyped and average?

IMHO they are not better than the other power conferences top to bottom. Many of the offenses in the SEC are awful, makes us look great. Just not sold on then getting 4, 5 or even 6 teams in the playoff.

Thoughts on how tough the SEC is?

By the way no clue why my first part is in italics.

ROAD RECAP: ISU corrals Oklahoma State, 20-13, to close 8-win regular season

How Great is 8?

So I have lived though so many terrible seasons (born 1966 and ISU graduate in 1988). My wife and I were chatting about how an 8-win season would have felt when we were seniors in 1987 (3-8 season for football). Yet we both feel excited and disappointed with this year's 8-4 team. Should we feel 8-4 is the floor or is 8-4 an acceptable season with a 10-2 season once every five years or so about all we can ever expect at ISU? By the way, I fully applaud this year's team on eight wins.

Dominick Nelson vs. Andrew Rohde

After watching Rady's Children Tournament here in San Diego the past couple of days, I came away with two observations:

1. TCU, with former F_ckeye, Brock Hardings, looks legit. Especially after they only lost to Michigan by 4 (at home) and seeing what Michigan did to the PE Tournament...
2. Andrew Rohde looked lost in a Wisconsin uniform...

Which led me to thinking was Dominick Nelson the fallback to Rohde? If so, fast-forward to present day and I'd take Nelson everyday of the week and twice on Sunday over Rohde. Further, while KT and Blake's play get a majority of the newcomer talk...I'm absolutely in love with Nelson's game. Dude just balls and has a knack for getting to the hole (something I was concerned wouldn't translate...).

Any other thoughts? Comments?

CF PREGAME: Iowa State closes regular season at Oklahoma State

Jake Brend and Chris Williams preview Iowa State’s last regular-season game of the 2025 campaign as they hit the road to face Oklahoma State. Presented by Channel Seed.

Enjoy!

Iowa State will "tell its story" at the end — and faces Oklahoma State on Saturday

Let Him Cook: Feast Week Recap

Dylan Coon and Nigel Dyson take a deep dive into Iowa State’s 3-0 finish at the Players Era Invitational. What did we learn about the Cyclones? Getting into the analytics and more.

Enjoy!

Filter