stabbing outside of pella middle school

nfrine

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2006
9,901
12,098
113
Nearby
Part of the problem is you’re dealing with motivated kids and it’s one teacher (who’s also trying to teach) trying to keep track of 20-30 students.

I went to school before smart phones, but I had classmates who could text without looking at their phone. That’s going to be difficult to police even if your sole job is to pay attention to the kids
Just one more thing for teachers to do....set in on a few classes and see that they already have their hands full.
 

Clonehomer

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
26,891
25,024
113
I'm talking about not giving them smart phones in the first place.

I realize that being left out can be damaging, but I think we're at a point where it's like "yeah, all your classmates are smoking and I wouldn't want you to be left out of that". That's how dangerous I think smart phones are for adolescent minds.

When it's a school-wide ban, no kid is getting left out on their own.

Give them a smart phone and put restrictions on it. Parental controls have come a long ways and you can control what they use and how long they use it for. Problem is that most schools are giving students Chromebooks that are more difficult to lock down as they are setup with student accounts that you don’t have control over. So banning devices completely is a losing battle. Embrace the tech, control it, and educate your kids on its usage.
 

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
9,900
9,652
113
Rural U.S.A.
that's insane. my kids have now had two incidents in the last couple years and we're in one of the safest towns in Iowa (which is one of the safest states in the nation)

it's pretty much a fact these days that children won't make it to senior year without seeing some ****.

It's a fact that you're a little unhinged right now and should back away from the keyboard.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,680
7,527
113
Just saying that I've seen firsthand what can happen. Both daughters had friends whose parents did this and it very much heightened their levels of anxiety and depression... feeling left out and cut off, wondering what was being said about them, being made fun of, etc. I know this because I heard them talk about it themselves.

I'd never tell anyone how to parent their kid. And I 100% agree that so many of these apps and social media in general is a very toxic and damaging cesspool. All I'm saying is that I don't agree with others who think taking their phone away is some magic bullet that will make everything better.

I do agree that during the school day phones should not be allowed.
No one is left out when the school takes them away from everyone.

There are way more issues with phones and social media, than when without. And its not even close.
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,680
7,527
113
That was part of the point of my post. Let’s stop pushing this problem onto somebody else. He’s homeschooled or we reopen the Clarinda academy.
Clarinda wasnt the only facility.

Woodward comes to mind. Not sure how many total there are.
 

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,801
31,183
113
Behind you
No one is left out when the school takes them away from everyone.

There are way more issues with phones and social media, than when without. And its not even close.
You must have missed the part of my post where I said I agree that during the school day phones should not be allowed.
 
Last edited:

MountainManHawk

Active Member
Sep 10, 2015
237
194
43
45
my high schooler has Snapchat otherwise they both just use text messaging and watching youtube the most part.

truth is all the kids of today think you're LAME if you're on FB, Insta, X, etc, etc. if parents use it, it's basically poisoned lol.

... but let me tell you about a game called Gorilla Tag ... that f'ing thing needs to be shot to the moon. it's how to make middle schoolers even more annoying - this time in VR!
My kids are the same. I was debating what age I should allow them to be on Facebook and Instagram, etc. and then come to find out kids have no interest in that anyway.

For my kids it’s mainly Snapchat, TikTok, and YouTube. And my nieces and nephews (who are a bit older) are into a bunch of apps I had never heard of like BeReal.

And also, the more that I thought about it I started to feel like the bullying behavior I was trying to protect them from is going to be there with simple texting even if I never allowed them on these other apps.

They all started giant group chats with all their friends just from their iPads before I ever gave them a phone anyway. I’m not even sure how they got connected on there, one kid figures it out and they tell others and pretty soon all the kids know how.
 

Clonehomer

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
26,891
25,024
113
No one is left out when the school takes them away from everyone.

There are way more issues with phones and social media, than when without. And its not even close.

Blaming everything on phones is missing the bigger issue. The lack of discipline in general is a bigger problem IMO. If a kid is being bullied at school, the school has no ability to intervene anymore. And at home, there’s too many parents that don’t care. All they care about is whether they will be inconvenienced with having to come to the school to meet with the principal or pick up their kid. Which leads to them making waves if the school tries to suspend a kid. And the school will always cave to a parent that makes those waves. So you have situations that keep progressing until they boil over.

Cause we see this same issue with younger kids that do not have phones.
 

FriendlySpartan

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
9,709
10,165
113
38
m
Blaming everything on phones is missing the bigger issue. The lack of discipline in general is a bigger problem IMO. If a kid is being bullied at school, the school has no ability to intervene anymore. And at home, there’s too many parents that don’t care. All they care about is whether they will be inconvenienced with having to come to the school to meet with the principal or pick up their kid. Which leads to them making waves if the school tries to suspend a kid. And the school will always cave to a parent that makes those waves. So you have situations that keep progressing until they boil over.

Cause we see this same issue with younger kids that do not have phones.
i mean most younger kids are being raised on phones/tablets from the time they can hold something these days but I get your point
 

2speedy1

Well-Known Member
Jan 4, 2014
6,680
7,527
113
Blaming everything on phones is missing the bigger issue. The lack of discipline in general is a bigger problem IMO. If a kid is being bullied at school, the school has no ability to intervene anymore. And at home, there’s too many parents that don’t care. All they care about is whether they will be inconvenienced with having to come to the school to meet with the principal or pick up their kid. Which leads to them making waves if the school tries to suspend a kid. And the school will always cave to a parent that makes those waves. So you have situations that keep progressing until they boil over.

Cause we see this same issue with younger kids that do not have phones.
I never said everything was because of phones.

I said phones cause issues. Way more issues than without. Phones and access to all types of social media instant messaging etc. causes way more issues, from bullying, privacy issues, etc. to just plain distractions.

Parents and kids think phones are necessary to daily life. They think they have to have that access at all times. Both are not true. Kids can and do, manage just fine without them. Parents can and do manage to contact them through the school all the time. My kids schools banned all phones and smart watches. Both kids have smart watches, one is allowed to wear theirs because it is in school mode during the day and only is able to be a watch, the other has to leave it home or in their bag, even in school mode. And... we manage just fine. There is nothing that we need to get ahold of them for that can not be relayed through the office.

And the fact that a few on here are saying the info came out faster from kids with phones than from school or authorities all I can say is of course, but that doesnt make it better. Kids panic, parents panic, information gets told wrong, and just causes more chaos.

In a safety situation it is the school and the authorities first priority to get the situation under control, make sure everyone is safe and the situation resolved. Before, talking to anyone, and causing more mass panic and confusion. In a severe situation having parents, media, and other bystanders showing up, trying to intervene, trying to enter and or remove kids only makes the situation worse. It only complicates everything, and in turn can cause more people to get hurt.

What good is it going to do if a parent rushes into the school, gets themselves in the line of fire so to speak, and hinders the duties of officials trying to get things under control or eliminate the threat? A parent rushing in trying to get involved, trying to take their child out of a locked and safe location to an open and vulnerable location is not a good situation.

In any case if my kids were in a situation like this I understand the want to get instant info, I can understand the want to intervene and try to remove my kid from the situation etc. But in many cases until the threat is eliminated and the situation is under control, doing such things only makes it worse.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: LancelotClone

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,801
31,183
113
Behind you
I never said everything was because of phones.

I said phones cause issues. Way more issues than without. Phones and access to all types of social media instant messaging etc. causes way more issues, from bullying, privacy issues, etc. to just plain distractions.

Parents and kids think phones are necessary to daily life. They think they have to have that access at all times. Both are not true. Kids can and do, manage just fine without them. Parents can and do manage to contact them through the school all the time. My kids schools banned all phones and smart watches. Both kids have smart watches, one is allowed to wear theirs because it is in school mode during the day and only is able to be a watch, the other has to leave it home or in their bag, even in school mode. And... we manage just fine. There is nothing that we need to get ahold of them for that can not be relayed through the office.

And the fact that a few on here are saying the info came out faster from kids with phones than from school or authorities all I can say is of course, but that doesnt make it better. Kids panic, parents panic, information gets told wrong, and just causes more chaos.

In a safety situation it is the school and the authorities first priority to get the situation under control, make sure everyone is safe and the situation resolved. Before, talking to anyone, and causing more mass panic and confusion. In a severe situation having parents, media, and other bystanders showing up, trying to intervene, trying to enter and or remove kids only makes the situation worse. It only complicates everything, and in turn can cause more people to get hurt.

What good is it going to do if a parent rushes into the school, gets themselves in the line of fire so to speak, and hinders the duties of officials trying to get things under control or eliminate the threat? A parent rushing in trying to get involved, trying to take their child out of a locked and safe location to an open and vulnerable location is not a good situation.

In any case if my kids were in a situation like this I understand the want to get instant info, I can understand the want to intervene and try to remove my kid from the situation etc. But in many cases until the threat is eliminated and the situation is under control, doing such things only makes it worse.
I don't disagree with some of this but the simple reality is that phones and social media are here and it's not going back.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MJ29

clones_jer

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2006
8,613
844
113
IA
saw some pics of the one girl, it really was kind of a stabbing motion that landed just shy of her neck. thank goodness she was wearing a hoodie, knife created quarter-sized hole near where the hood and sweatshirt meet near the collarbone. the actual cut on her was very small, but to create the hole in the hoodie it did have some force behind it.
 

clones_jer

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2006
8,613
844
113
IA
Did the incident happen inside the school or in the cafeteria?
the "cafeteria" area at the middle schools is right inside the main entry doors. you walk in to a big open space and that's the "cafeteria" which you basically have to walk through to get anywhere else in the school. so yes to both questions.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: ruflosn

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,619
31,754
113
walked into my 4 year old beating the everloving crap out of her tonie. Apparently thats how you switch to the next song/story.

These damn kids are way smarter than we give them credit for
All right I openly admit it I have no idea what the heck is a tonie?
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron