LOST: This Place is Death

[LindenCy]

I just read in tv guide that Jacks grandfather knows something about the island. I think Jacks dad has been there before as well.


Also says that Sawyer, Juliette, Jin and crew will meet up with a young Ben for at least 4 episodes to fill in his rise to power.

One of these sentences is true according to writers:

A: Ben is Lockes brother
B: Charlotte is the grown up Annie (bens childhood friend)
C: Miles is Marvin Candles son.

Im not sure which one to believe, but if I were to pick one, I would say Ben and Locke are brothers. A Cain and Abel type dynamic.

I think I would go with C. if I were guessing. Charlotte seems too young for B, and A doesn't seem to make sense because we supposedly know who both of Ben's parents are and neither are Locke's. Could be interesting though. I was thinking Miles was Marvin Candle's son before.

 

[CycloneYoda]

All the little things are slowly being explained. In season 1 when Danielle led the Losties to the Black Rock, she mentioned someone losing their arm. The footprints Boone and Locke followed that eventually led them to the hatch now had an origin.

I swear Smokey looked like a dog dragging Montand through the jungle. This would support the Cereberus theory. Natural or mechinical, I have no idea.

Lost gave us a severed arm and a Theisman-esque leg injury.

This is why we watch Lost.

 

[Cloner97]

I just read in tv guide that Jacks grandfather knows something about the island. I think Jacks dad has been there before as well.


Also says that Sawyer, Juliette, Jin and crew will meet up with a young Ben for at least 4 episodes to fill in his rise to power.

One of these sentences is true according to writers:

A: Ben is Lockes brother
B: Charlotte is the grown up Annie (bens childhood friend)
C: Miles is Marvin Candles son.

Im not sure which one to believe, but if I were to pick one, I would say Ben and Locke are brothers. A Cain and Abel type dynamic.

It's C. If you recall the episode that begins with Candle's morning ritual; feeding the baby, etc...It's pretty obvious that they showed us this so they could tell us Miles was that baby.

 

[The_Architect]

OK, I'm stumped and I don't remember Marvin Candle. Who is that?

 

[LindenCy]

OK, I'm stumped and I don't remember Marvin Candle. Who is that?

The guy from the orientation films.

 

[clone52]

Only one of those things is true? Hmm... I'd never thought of or heard "A" before, but I've heard "B" mentioned elsewhere as a possibility and thought of "C" myself. I was kind of hoping one or all of them could be true.

Did they say 'only' one of them is true? Maybe they are all true.

 

[The_Architect]

Oh duh, I knew that.

 

[AirWalke]

Didn't some of the other time traveling losties get killed in the flaming arrow attack, and the "others" army attack. Granted they had the same story significance as the red-shirted Enterprise crew members that transported down to the planet with Kirk & Spock, but for them, a devastating occurance. They have been on that island all that time with their decaying corpses.

This could be completely possible, as the red shirts were always meant to die in the past. I'm talking about things like, encountering people you shouldn't, getting involved in situations you shouldn't be in, etc. Even though Faraday "changed" the timeline with Desmond (by telling him on the island to go find his mother), in telling this to Desmond, the flash started whisking him away, because interacting with Desmond in this manner would be "against the rules".

 

[LindenCy]

Oh duh, I knew that.

Yeah, we all space sometimes. There is a lot to keep track of.

 

[CTAClone]

This could be completely possible, as the red shirts were always meant to die in the past. I'm talking about things like, encountering people you shouldn't, getting involved in situations you shouldn't be in, etc. Even though Faraday "changed" the timeline with Desmond (by telling him on the island to go find his mother), in telling this to Desmond, the flash started whisking him away, because interacting with Desmond in this manner would be "against the rules".

I think that's why Desmond was time traveling in earlier episodes. The paradox created made him forget that he ever met Daniel, thus fixing the timeline in a sense.

 

[bos]

Did they say 'only' one of them is true? Maybe they are all true.

The article said one.

 

[bos]

Everyone always remembers the black rock. But remember there is another ship on the island as well. The big tanker or battleship. Its where Sawyer strangled the **** out of Lockes dad.

 

[CycloneYoda]

Everyone always remembers the black rock. But remember there is another ship on the island as well. The big tanker or battleship. Its where Sawyer strangled the **** out of Lockes dad.

Ummm, Locke toook Sawyer to the Black Rock, not a different boat.
The episode is titled "The Brig".

 

[bos]

Ummm, Locke toook Sawyer to the Black Rock, not a different boat.
The episode is titled "The Brig".

Was it? I swear there is another one. Oh well, my mind is mush after this show anyway. =)

 

[The_Architect]

Was it? I swear there is another one. Oh well, my mind is mush after this show anyway. =)

Yep, it was the Black Rock I remember that.

 

[dustinal]

3. The look on Ben's face when Desmond said "Are you guys here to see Farradays mother too?" It appeared Ben had no idea about that relationship.

I noticed that look too. It's the first time I can remember Ben looking surprised at something--well, other than when Keamy killed his daughter. It seems like he always knows what's going on, but he apparently didn't know this.