KC vs St. Louis

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,717
13,543
113
Parts Unknown
KC is a second class city. Omaha would be a 4th or 5th tier city down there with Des Moines, Wichita, and Albuquerque.
Its not what I'd call a "world city" but it's still a major city/metro. I think a metro population of 2 million is probably the cutoff for major cities. Its basically like Cleveland, Cincinnati, Columbus, and Pittsburgh. Greater Nashville, Sacramento, and Vegas have similar populations too.
 

CloneIce

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
37,750
21,126
113
I fly a bit and Southwest has a lot of connections in StL and KC has a nice new airport that is getting direct flights.

Maybe its just me but I feel like KC gets more "big time" events. Concerts, World Cup, etc.
Super Bowl championships…

Oh wait, St Louis lost their team while the Chiefs have been the best NFL team of the decade.
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,717
13,543
113
Parts Unknown
Super Bowl championships…

Oh wait, St Louis lost their team while the Chiefs have been the best NFL team of the decade.
They have lost 2 teams. The Big Red and the Rams. I actually went to a St. Louis Cardinals football game in the Kingdome out in Seattle in 1985. I was only 5 but still remember. Their ABA team the Spirits of St. Louis also didn't make the cut during the ABA/NBA merger. Having said that KC lost their NHL team the Scouts and NBA team the KC Kings.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: CloneIce

1UNI2ISU

Well-Known Member
Jan 30, 2013
8,958
12,048
113
Waterloo
That has less to do with the city and more to do with the participants. There are more ISU and KU fans in KC than there are people going to Arch Madness, period.
I, for one, am shocked that a league full of large state universities outdraws a collection of mostly rural teacher's colleges and small private schools :jimlad::jimlad:
 

CloneIce

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
37,750
21,126
113
I never thought I'd live on the KS side(especially in JoCo) but I absolutely love living in Old Shawnee. I lived a lot of places and it's the most "livable" place I've ever been. I dont even feel like I'm in the suburbs. It’s like small town America 10 minutes south of downtown KC. It’s not overrun by the snobs that occupy 90% of this county either.
In my experience the only real JoCo snob areas are Leawood and Mission Hills. Maybe PV is some parts. The bigger suburbs, not snobby.
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,193
79,028
113
DSM
Its not what I'd call a "world city" but it's still a major city/metro. I think a metro population of 2 million is probably the cutoff for major cities. Its basically like Cleveland, Cincinnati, Columbus, and Pittsburgh. Greater Nashville, Sacramento, and Vegas have similar populations too.

Well if everything is just based on population then we’re not talking about the same things. Importance of the city should factor in amongst many other things. Nashville and Vegas are in the second tier. My rough list. Moved KC down to tier 3 actually.

Tier 1: NY, LA, Chicago, Miami, Seattle, Philly, DC, SF, Atlanta, Boston
Tier 2: Nashville, Vegas, Orlando, Portland, Minneapolis, Denver, Phoenix, San Diego, Dallas, Houston, Austin
Tier 3: KC ( very close to tier 2), St. Louis, Charlotte, Milwaukee, Pittsburgh, Ohio 3C’s, New Orleans, Detroit, SLC, S.A., Indianapolis (barely, worse place to exist in the USA imo)
Tier 4: Sacramento, Grand Rapids, Jacksonville, Memphis, Baltimore, Buffalo, OKC, Providence, San Jose
Tier 5: Wichita, Omaha, Albuquerque, Tucson, Knoxville, Birmingham, Des Moines (barely, could be off the list), Boise, Louisville, Fresno, Madison

Didn’t rate: Honolulu, pretty unique situation there. Not an exhaustive list, just off the top of my head.
 

OPCyclone

Member
Dec 4, 2008
43
29
18
Overland Park, KS
Some comparisons not brought up. (I live in KC Metro and have been to StL many, many times for both work and pleasure.)

KC - Foodwise, known for some of the best BBQ in the country, and a quickly growing and great "foodie" scene, and some fantastic higher-end restaurants that can compete with the best on both coasts, with a little bit lower cost. KC has Swope Park with a great outdoor theater and an OK zoo; however, the park is not a safe place to be unless you are right by the attractions. KC has one of the best (if not the best) symphony and performance hall in the country - the Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts. After all the improvements over the past 15 years KC has a great downtown and areas north and south of downtown, and is still growing and developing. Baseball - Kauffman Stadium is a fun place to see a ballgame, but the stadium itself has nothing around it at all and is also falling apart in the areas you can't see. Limited history with the Royals.

St. Louis - Foodwise, known for some great old-style italian restaurants and St. Louis Style Pizza. Not a very robust "foodie" scene and not very many higher-end restaruants. St. Louis has Forest Park, which has a better zoo and is much more developed than Swope Park. Also, not the safest part of town to be in after dark. St. Louis downtown is pretty dead and not developing much. Baseball - St. Louis is better in all aspects, one of the best stadiums in baseball, things to do around the stadium on game days, and a team deep in history. (And I hate the Cardinals as a die-hard Cubbies fan and a Royals fan, but gotta be honest here about the stadiums and teams).
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,717
13,543
113
Parts Unknown
Well if everything is just based on population then we’re not talking about the same things. Importance of the city should factor in amongst many other things. Nashville and Vegas are in the second tier. My rough list. Moved KC down to tier 3 actually.

Tier 1: NY, LA, Chicago, Miami, Seattle, Philly, DC, SF, Atlanta, Boston
Tier 2: Nashville, Vegas, Orlando, Portland, Minneapolis, Denver, Phoenix, San Diego, Dallas, Houston, Austin
Tier 3: KC ( very close to tier 2), St. Louis, Charlotte, Milwaukee, Pittsburgh, Ohio 3C’s, New Orleans, Detroit, SLC, S.A., Indianapolis (barely, worse place to exist in the USA imo)
Tier 4: Sacramento, Grand Rapids, Jacksonville, Memphis, Baltimore, Buffalo, OKC, Providence, San Jose
Tier 5: Wichita, Omaha, Albuquerque, Tucson, Knoxville, Birmingham, Des Moines (barely, could be off the list), Boise, Louisville, Fresno, Madison

Didn’t rate: Honolulu, pretty unique situation there. Not an exhaustive list, just off the top of my head.
Dont disagree much. Imo you have tier 1(world cities) New York, LA, Chicago, maybe Houston that ends the list. You have tier 2. MSP, Phoenix, Boston, Philly, DFW, San Fran, Seattle, several others
Tier 3 KC, St. Louis, Pittsburgh, Sacramento, San Antonio, several others.
Tier 4 OKC, Louisville, Memphis, Salt Lake City, Tulsa, etc
Tier 5 Des Moines, Omaha, Grand Rapids, Spokane, etc.
Population carries a lot of weight with me. Fortune 500 companies and things like that come into play too.
What puts Grand Rapids in the same category as Memphis and Baltimore? That's seems like a hell of a stretch. Its Des Moines if was in Michigan to me. Great medium size city no doubt but thats what it is.
 
Last edited:

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,717
13,543
113
Parts Unknown
In my experience the only real JoCo snob areas are Leawood and Mission Hills. Maybe PV is some parts. The bigger suburbs, not snobby.
Yeah they are worse than others but I feel like a lot of people in OP and Olathe still look down on people in Shawnee, Merriam, and maybe Lenexa are bit. OP and Olathe remind me of giant versions of the Jordan Creek area too much.
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,717
13,543
113
Parts Unknown
That has less to do with the city and more to do with the participants. There are more ISU and KU fans in KC than there are people going to Arch Madness, period.
I despise KU sports but KU is a great school and KU med is the only reason my dad is still alive. One of the best hospitals in the US. Lawrence is a great college town. If Iowa City and Ames had a child it would look like Lawrence.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CloneIce

aeroclone

Well-Known Member
Oct 30, 2006
10,349
7,156
113
Yeah they are worse than others but I feel like a lot of people in OP and Olathe still look down on people in Shawnee, Merriam, and maybe Lenexa are bit. OP and Olathe remind me of giant versions of the Jordan Creek area too much.

judgemental-aristocrat.gif


As an OP resident, I really resent you grouping us in with the Olathe plebs.
 

1SEIACLONE

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2024
2,514
2,351
113
63
Ames Iowa
Some comparisons not brought up. (I live in KC Metro and have been to StL many, many times for both work and pleasure.)

KC - Foodwise, known for some of the best BBQ in the country, and a quickly growing and great "foodie" scene, and some fantastic higher-end restaurants that can compete with the best on both coasts, with a little bit lower cost. KC has Swope Park with a great outdoor theater and an OK zoo; however, the park is not a safe place to be unless you are right by the attractions. KC has one of the best (if not the best) symphony and performance hall in the country - the Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts. After all the improvements over the past 15 years KC has a great downtown and areas north and south of downtown, and is still growing and developing. Baseball - Kauffman Stadium is a fun place to see a ballgame, but the stadium itself has nothing around it at all and is also falling apart in the areas you can't see. Limited history with the Royals.

St. Louis - Foodwise, known for some great old-style italian restaurants and St. Louis Style Pizza. Not a very robust "foodie" scene and not very many higher-end restaruants. St. Louis has Forest Park, which has a better zoo and is much more developed than Swope Park. Also, not the safest part of town to be in after dark. St. Louis downtown is pretty dead and not developing much. Baseball - St. Louis is better in all aspects, one of the best stadiums in baseball, things to do around the stadium on game days, and a team deep in history. (And I hate the Cardinals as a die-hard Cubbies fan and a Royals fan, but gotta be honest here about the stadiums and teams).
St. Louis is and always have been a Cardinals town, with a strong following of the Blues, while KC has always been a Chiefs town first and foremost, and the Royals are a distance second.
 

CloneFanInKC

Well-Known Member
Jul 26, 2021
2,152
2,617
113
They have lost 2 teams. The Big Red and the Rams. I actually went to a St. Louis Cardinals football game in the Kingdome out in Seattle in 1985. I was only 5 but still remember. Their ABA team the Spirits of St. Louis also didn't make the cut during the ABA/NBA merger. Having said that KC lost their NHL team the Scouts and NBA team the KC Kings.
I believe the NHL or NBA team was “based” in KC for 3 years? but actually had home games in Omaha the final season….i think.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1SEIACLONE

cyguy9320

Well-Known Member
Nov 26, 2006
272
429
63
Some comparisons not brought up. (I live in KC Metro and have been to StL many, many times for both work and pleasure.)

KC - Foodwise, known for some of the best BBQ in the country, and a quickly growing and great "foodie" scene, and some fantastic higher-end restaurants that can compete with the best on both coasts, with a little bit lower cost. KC has Swope Park with a great outdoor theater and an OK zoo; however, the park is not a safe place to be unless you are right by the attractions. KC has one of the best (if not the best) symphony and performance hall in the country - the Kauffman Center for the Performing Arts. After all the improvements over the past 15 years KC has a great downtown and areas north and south of downtown, and is still growing and developing. Baseball - Kauffman Stadium is a fun place to see a ballgame, but the stadium itself has nothing around it at all and is also falling apart in the areas you can't see. Limited history with the Royals.

St. Louis - Foodwise, known for some great old-style italian restaurants and St. Louis Style Pizza. Not a very robust "foodie" scene and not very many higher-end restaruants. St. Louis has Forest Park, which has a better zoo and is much more developed than Swope Park. Also, not the safest part of town to be in after dark. St. Louis downtown is pretty dead and not developing much. Baseball - St. Louis is better in all aspects, one of the best stadiums in baseball, things to do around the stadium on game days, and a team deep in history. (And I hate the Cardinals as a die-hard Cubbies fan and a Royals fan, but gotta be honest here about the stadiums and teams).
St. Louis “pizza” is an abomination.
 

1SEIACLONE

Well-Known Member
Jun 2, 2024
2,514
2,351
113
63
Ames Iowa
I believe the NHL or NBA team was “based” in KC for 3 years? but actually had home games in Omaha the final season….i think.
They were the KC/Omaha Kings, much like the Packers did play games in Milwaukee and Green Bay, during the 80s and before.
The NBA then was not the NBA of today, and teams moved around looking for a solid place to call home.