By all appearances, it looks like today was it for Joe Mauer. Walked off into the sunset wearing his catcher's gear after doubling in his last AB.
May not be a first ballot guy, but he'll be in the running. Let the HOF coffee shop talk begin.
I'll bite. I do think he is done based on the way the Twins played him this weekend.
If he retires now his case is not that strong. Outside of the three batting titles and the lifetime .306. Only 2000 hits and never drove in or scored 100 in any of his seasons.
Reminded me of one of my fav Yanks whose career was cut short. When I looked it up I was shocked
at how Don Mattingly's career stats are almost
identical to Mauer's. Mattingly is .307, Mauer is .306, and the rest of their stats are nearly identical except Mattingly hit more homers and Mauer has three batting titles to Mattingly's one. Mattingly also has a shelf full of Golden Gloves, nine, to Mauer's two. Mattingly had to retire (back) at 34 and Mauer may leave at 35.
Both of these guys looked like shoo-in for HOF when they were 26 or so, assuming they stayed healthy which neither did. Consensus is that Mattingly has NO shot at the HOF. You need 75% of the votes and the best he ever got was 28%.
Take a look at these graphic summaries and tell me that aren't mirror images for career stats!