Annual All-Iowa combined team thread

DJK15

Well-Known Member
Apr 17, 2008
3,690
138
63
This one is always fun.

Build the starting lineup for an imaginary State of Iowa team using players from Iowa and ISU.
 

Luth4Cy

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2012
5,520
134
63
Ames, IA
Iowa's o-line and d-line. Everybody else from Iowa State.

This isn't spot on what I'd do, but I don't care enough to go through player by player.
 

RubyClone

Active Member
Mar 21, 2014
3,110
17
38
This one is always fun.

Build the starting lineup for an imaginary State of Iowa team using players from Iowa and ISU.

Wow. I don't know about iowa's team at all, but I think all I can throw out there (knowing what I'm hearing about your secondary) is Tribune and given the way he played last week, Cotton-Moya. Farniok, but I don't know about your center. Jarvis West after last week as well should easily have a spot. I suppose Bibbs. Beyond that - I'm at a loss. Don't know enough about iowa, but I'm not sure anyone from ISU stands out enough to be a clear choice.

Downing has been kicking well too. Perhaps Netten as pk. I understand iowa is kinda suffering there....
 
Last edited:

jburke

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
4,572
839
113
44
Ankeny, IA
I hope after Saturday most Hawk fans will ask for Mangino over Greg 'Vanilla' Davis.......
 

CyTwins

Well-Known Member
Jan 20, 2010
80,179
65,789
113
Ankeny
Morrissey, LTP, Ott and Davis would be a super salty D-line. King and Tribune would be great CB's. Toss up on Safety and LB's. The best OL IMO are Scherff, Farniok, and Blythe. Smith, West and Bibbs for sure then a toss up everywhere else.
 

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
52,866
43,083
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
Offense:
QB - Rudock (IOWA)
RB - Johnson (UNI) - as suggested downthread
TE - Bibbs (ISU)
WR - Martin-Manley (IOWA)
WR - West (ISU)
WR - Lazard (ISU) or Smith (IOWA)
LT - Scherff (IOWA)
LG - Burton(ISU)
C - Fariok (ISU)
RG - Walsh (IOWA)
RT - Donnal (IOWA)

Defense:
LE - Morrissey (ISU)
DT - Davis (IOWA)
DT - Trinca-Passat (IOWA)
RE - Ott (IOWA)
LOLB - Knott (ISU)
MLB - Alston (IOWA)
ROLB - Spearman (IOWA)
CB - Tribune (ISU)
FS - Lomax (IOWA)
SS - Cotton-Moya (ISU)
CB - King (IOWA)

PK - Netten (ISU)
P - Downing (ISU)
 
Last edited:

jburke

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
4,572
839
113
44
Ankeny, IA
Offense:
QB - Rudock (IOWA) OR Richardson (ISU)
RB - I have no ******* clue
TE - Bibbs (ISU)
WR - Martin-Manley (IOWA)
WR - West (ISU)
WR - Lazard (ISU) or Smith (IOWA)
LT - Scherff (IOWA)
LG - Lalk (ISU)
C - Fariok (ISU)
RG - Walsh (IOWA)
RT - Donnal (IOWA)

Defense:
LE - Morrissey (ISU)
DT - Davis (IOWA)
DT - Trinca-Passat (IOWA)
RE - Ott (IOWA)
LOLB - Knott (ISU)
MLB - Alston (IOWA)
ROLB - Spearman (IOWA)
CB - Tribune (ISU)
FS - Lomax (IOWA)
SS - Cotton-Moya (ISU)
CB - King (IOWA)

PK - Netten (ISU)
P - Downing (ISU)

Quarterback controversy!!!!
 

CyTwins

Well-Known Member
Jan 20, 2010
80,179
65,789
113
Ankeny
Offense:
QB - Rudock (IOWA) OR Richardson (ISU)
RB - Johnson (UNI) - as suggested downthread
TE - Bibbs (ISU)
WR - Martin-Manley (IOWA)
WR - West (ISU)
WR - Lazard (ISU) or Smith (IOWA)
LT - Scherff (IOWA)
LG - Lalk (ISU)
C - Fariok (ISU)
RG - Walsh (IOWA)
RT - Donnal (IOWA)

Defense:
LE - Morrissey (ISU)
DT - Davis (IOWA)
DT - Trinca-Passat (IOWA)
RE - Ott (IOWA)
LOLB - Knott (ISU)
MLB - Alston (IOWA)
ROLB - Spearman (IOWA)
CB - Tribune (ISU)
FS - Lomax (IOWA)
SS - Cotton-Moya (ISU)
CB - King (IOWA)

PK - Netten (ISU)
P - Downing (ISU)

I think Burton is better than Lalk. Donnal isn't that good so you could maybe but Dagel there but that's a toss up. Iowa and ISU's LB's aren't very good
 

bawbie

Moderator
Staff member
Mar 17, 2006
52,866
43,083
113
Cedar Rapids, IA
I think Burton is better than Lalk. Donnal isn't that good so you could maybe but Dagel there but that's a toss up. Iowa and ISU's LB's aren't very good

Yeah, I started keeping with the L/R designation from the depth chart, then ditched it when it came to the defense :)

Other than Scherff and Farniok, I have no clue on the OL. Might as well put Campos at RT after the way he played Saturday.
 

Cyclonin

Well-Known Member
Feb 18, 2012
2,586
55
48
Dallas, TX
Offense:
QB - Rudock (IOWA) OR Richardson (ISU)
RB - Johnson (UNI) - as suggested downthread
TE - Bibbs (ISU)
WR - Martin-Manley (IOWA)
WR - West (ISU)
WR - Lazard (ISU) or Smith (IOWA)
LT - Scherff (IOWA)
LG - Lalk (ISU)
C - Fariok (ISU)
RG - Walsh (IOWA)
RT - Donnal (IOWA)

Defense:
LE - Morrissey (ISU)
DT - Davis (IOWA)
DT - Trinca-Passat (IOWA)
RE - Ott (IOWA)
LOLB - Knott (ISU)
MLB - Alston (IOWA)
ROLB - Spearman (IOWA)
CB - Tribune (ISU)
FS - Lomax (IOWA)
SS - Cotton-Moya (ISU)
CB - King (IOWA)

PK - Netten (ISU)
P - Downing (ISU)

I think this is pretty solid. Not sure who Iowa has on OL, but if you are throwing an ISU guy on there, Burton would easily trump Lalk.
 

ahaselhu

Well-Known Member
Sep 10, 2007
1,871
64
48
Clarinda, IA
I think there's no doubt that you take all of ISU's special teams at this point.

Rudock over Richardson, probably overall but especially if you look at closing out games. 4th quarter QB ratings:

Rudock 153.53
Richardson 78.74


Otherwise, I agree with bawbie, although there are several positions I'd consider toss-ups.
 

CUIClone

Member
Nov 11, 2009
187
5
18
Offense:
QB - Rohach (ISU)
RB - Johnson (UNI)
TE - Bibbs (ISU)
WR - Bundrage (ISU) When healthy obviously
WR - Smith (IOWA)
WR - Lazard (ISU)
LT - Scherff (IOWA)
LG - Lalk (ISU)
C - Fariok (ISU)
RG - Walsh (IOWA)
RT - Donnal (IOWA)

Defense:
LE - Morrissey (ISU)
DT - Davis (IOWA)
DT - Trinca-Passat (IOWA)
RE - Ott (IOWA)
LOLB - Knott (ISU)
MLB - Alston (IOWA)
ROLB - Brackens (ISU)
CB - Tribune (ISU)
FS - Lomax (IOWA)
SS - Cotton-Moya (ISU)
CB - King (IOWA)

PK - Netten (ISU)
P - Downing (ISU)