All-Time Iowa State Team...

bostrem00

Well-Known Member
Feb 23, 2009
3,299
556
113
Des Moines
Awesome heres the wild card at QB, Marv Seiler! Ik that Seneca and Sage are legitimately better but seriously theres no way they could do that against a Nebraska team coached by Tom Osborne . And for a kicker, Carl Gomez
 

Cyphor

Member
Aug 9, 2006
677
12
18
DEFENSE
DE - Reggie Heyward
DT - James Reed
DT - Jorden Carstens
DE - Jason Berryman
OLB - Matt Blair
ILB - Tim Dobbins
ILB - Dennis Gibson
OLB - Ace Bowen
CB - Ellis Hobbs
CB - Barry Hill
FS - Marcus Robertson
SS - Nick Moser
P - Tony Yelk (in his good years - fresh and soph)

Holy Crap that's a good D. :yes:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Clonegrad07

cc1091

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2007
1,146
305
83
Minneapolis
I'd eat my shorts if Todd Doxon EVER ran a 4.1. He was fast for sure, but the fastest guys in the NFL draft hardly ever run under 4.3. Hayward-Bay was a top 10 pick because he ran a 4.3. I'm betting someone was a little quick on the stopwatch with Doxon.

:biglaugh:
Don't be eating those shorts. Rumor was that no one at the camp believed it either, that's why they timed it twice. 4.1 or not, the speed was probably the ONLY reason that he hung out in the NFL for a season or two. Then played some in the World League. Then played in the XFL (often being the guy who ran to the ball in the middle of the field in that weird thing they did en lieu of a coin flip).
 

cc1091

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2007
1,146
305
83
Minneapolis
celoni played for stapelton in the early 60's. larry vanderheyden was a star lineman for the dirty 30 and would be a top selection for an outstanding lineman at isu.celoni when he first became elgible for the varsity was quite a blowhard that he was going to beat vanderheyden out of his starting assignment on the offensive lne.larry v. got wind of celoni's bragging remerks and if i remember right vanderheyden literallly kicked celoni's arse in a very good arse kicking by larry v. over windbag celoni.

Good info.
 

cc1091

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2007
1,146
305
83
Minneapolis
bret meyer was a ton better than most will give him credit for.

He is like top 5 all time big 12 passing yards

He also played on some bad teams and had two seasons with coaches that were either leaving or just coming...

He led us to two good bowl games and nearly two division titles

and he started all 4 years

Dont give the argument that he didn't improve from freshman to senior because i guarentee you he did, but the players around him were young and the coaching staff was even younger...

Meyer built up a lot of yards, but he was probably the only throwing QB (at least in a long while) to start at ISU for all four years. Archer was a JC transfer, as was Seneca. Rosenfels grew into the position, earning the startingjob as a junior. No one could beat him after that. Amundson was a starting running back his junior year, then the starting QB his senior season. Not sure what position Amundson played his sophmore year. I believe before sometime in the 80's, freshmen were inelligible to play in the games.

I never liked the way Meyer waggled his leg behind him when he passed. Arnaud also occaisionally has that same flaw in his form. Hopefully the new coaches will clean that up.
 

cc1091

Well-Known Member
Oct 10, 2007
1,146
305
83
Minneapolis
Awesome heres the wild card at QB, Marv Seiler! Ik that Seneca and Sage are legitimately better but seriously theres no way they could do that against a Nebraska team coached by Tom Osborne . And for a kicker, Carl Gomez

I suppose if there's a place on the all time team for guys who played both sides of the ball, and guys who are best described as Athletes, then there's probably a place for #1 All Time Unlikely Legend. I don't know if anyone can compare.

Gomez...didn't he miss a Kick vs Oklahoma? Or am I thinking of someone else who was usually reliable and had range, but missed one really important kick (there are so many to choose from).

Someone mentioned Dexter Green, which made me think of John Quinn at QB. Competent, but probably too far down the QB list.
 
Last edited:

podo67

Member
Apr 3, 2006
56
3
8
Most of you are too young to have watched Matt Blair play, but he was undoubtebly the best DE we have ever had. He played for the Vikings after ISU. He was a great athlete and a good person.
 

swammi

Well-Known Member
May 10, 2009
1,667
83
48
79
Apollo Beach, Florida
I haven't seen Larry Crawford on anyone's list yet. (As good a DB as we ever had.) Also, I really like Dan Johnson at Tight End and Keith Sims at Center.

Ron MacFarland and Maynard Stensrud were very good Nose Guards.

Great lists, brings back memories.
 

woodie

Well-Known Member
Apr 10, 2006
2,640
86
48
if they could have found a football uniform to fit him,chris taylor could have been one of the best offensive linemen ever in a cyclone uniform. chris was one helluva offensive tackle at muskegon michigan junior college before he came to iowa state to wrestle for coach nichols. taylor should be ranked as isu's best wrestler-even better than bael sanderson in my book.
 

swammi

Well-Known Member
May 10, 2009
1,667
83
48
79
Apollo Beach, Florida
Only A-C...

ATH Chin Achebe, Pat Curran

RB George Amundson, Blaise Bryant, Dwayne Crutchfield
WR Chris Anthony, Eppie Barney, Luther Blue
QB Dave Archer
FB Tony Baker
G **** Barker, Stan Campbell, Don Celoni

LB Matt Blair, Carl Brettschneider, Jeff Braswell
DB John Arnaud, Tommy Campbell, Larry Carwell, Larry Crawford
S Joe Beauchamp
NT Bill Berthusen
DE Hal Crisler

Special shout out to Larry Crawford who roamed the sidelines in the wild days of the CFL and had incredible longevity in a tough time for defenses back then.


I love that picture. FLOPPY!!
 

weR138

Well-Known Member
Feb 20, 2008
12,187
5,138
113
Only A-C...

ATH Chin Achebe, Pat Curran

RB George Amundson, Blaise Bryant, Dwayne Crutchfield
WR Chris Anthony, Eppie Barney, Luther Blue
QB Dave Archer
FB Tony Baker
G **** Barker, Stan Campbell, Don Celoni

LB Matt Blair, Carl Brettschneider, Jeff Braswell
DB John Arnaud, Tommy Campbell, Larry Carwell, Larry Crawford
S Joe Beauchamp
NT Bill Berthusen
DE Hal Crisler

duh...duh...
duh...duh...
duhduh duhduh duhduh...
 
Last edited by a moderator:

johnsonjj

Member
Apr 11, 2006
878
15
18
61
Johnston
Alex Espinosa should be in the discussion. Dwayne Crutchfield and Blaise Bryant after the davis boys. The best reciever I have ever seen in an Iowa State uniform is Tracy Henderson.

I will never forget Espinoza getting in trouble for jumping out of the back of a pick-up in campus town and getting into a fight. His quotes later in the paper were something akin to "I have to remember I am in Iowa can't do that here. That was normal where I am from (cali if I remember correctly.)
 

johnsonjj

Member
Apr 11, 2006
878
15
18
61
Johnston
I evidently don't go back as far as you do, but here's my vote...but I for the most part have fairly recent players:

QB: Wallace, Archer, Rosenfels
RB: Troy Davis, Ennis Haywood, Crutchfield, Blaise Bryant, Joe Henderson
WR: Tracy Henderson, Horacek, Groce
WR: Danielsen, Lester, Chris Anthony
WR: Blythe, Ed Williams, JJ Moses
TE: Busch, Krepfle, Banks
OT: Karl Nelson, Ross, Kohn, Brant, Stensrud, Marsau
OG: Sims, Williams, Reimers, Lo White
OC: Bruns, Augafa, Butler, Stephenson

DE: Hayward, Berryman, DeRonde, Moorehead
DT: Stensrud, Carstens, Reed, Leaders, Randall, Curvey
LB: Blair, Dobbins, Gibson, Boskey, Goodwin, Shane, Bowen
CB: Robertson, Hobbs, Hicks, LJ, Deandre Jackson
S: DouBrava, Billups, Moser, Paris, Arnaud, Avey

PR: McMillan, Moses, Todd Miller
KR: Hobbs, LJ, Branch, Milan Moses

K: Shudak, Kohl, Benike
P: Harris, Johnston, Brandtner

I know Simms played Guard in the pros, but wasn't he a LT at ISU?
 

sugarfoot

New Member
Aug 31, 2011
1
0
1
46
I did a search, but didn't find a thread for the best Iowa State football players of all time. I'm looking to assemble an entire team. I need Name (obviously), Number, and Position. It would be good to go at least 2 deep.

Post your submission and I will update the list as we go.

Thanks!

QB Alex Espanoza
HB Troy Davis, Blaise Bryant
FB Joe Henderson
TE Jeff Wadka
WR Dennis Ross
WR Tracy Henderson
Tackle Keith Sims
Tackle Gene William
Gaurd Rick Wells
Gaurd Vince Jasper
Center
 

CycloneVet

Well-Known Member
Jul 17, 2011
9,913
11,724
113
Cedar Falls
OFFENSE

QB - Seneca
RB - Troy Davis, Darren Davis
FB - Kock
WR - Blythe, JJ Moses
WR - Danielson, Todd Doxson
TE - Mike Banks
OT - Tim Kohn
OG - Keith Sims
C - Ben Bruns
OG - Oliver Ross
OT - Bruce Reimers
K - Ty Stewart
Todd Doxson are you serious Clark?