2025 Transfer Options

[Cyclad]

I think some (many?) would disagree. People pay over FMV all the time for things that are of particular value to them specifically. FMV is the price that the open market would bring from a willing buyer who's informed and acting in their own best interest. It's pretty obvious, based on loads of market data, that local car dealership would not be acting in their own best interest (as a busniess) to pay someone 10x what is "normal" for a comparable marketing deal.

Now it'll definitely be challenged in court. Whether it'd hold up or not, we'll see! Deloitte doesn't get to tell a dealership what they can pay but, if approved, the NCAA may have the ability to tell a player what they can accept if they want to be eligible to participate. Then the same deal is never going to be on the table if the player can't participate.

From my accountant acquaintance :

I know they claim to be able to compare it to similar deals, but I think they’re wrong. Fair value is what a buyer and seller are willing to pay in the Principal market they operate in. In this case the Principal market is college sports NIL deals.

For what it’s worth.
I guess time will tell. My prediction is that this will help the situation very little, but I am just an engineer.

 

[RagingCloner]

I'm confused.

There are no visits today

 

[WastedTalent]

No idea but Nelson will be here tomorrow

There are no visits today

Hmmmm

 

[psycln11]

It is just so the coached don't have visits scheduled during the Final 4 and they can attend.

Portal Closes April 22nd. That just means you need to have your name in if you potentially want to transfer though not that you have to be committed.
Big date for ISU just incase there are any more back door offers still being sent.

Definitely gotta watch out for those back door offers!!

 

[KennyPratt42]

At this point, I'm just hoping to get through the 22nd with the current roster we have. If we add somebody it would almost have to be in the Mulder price range or below. I wouldn't be shocked to see them find a JUCO, foreign player, or late developing high school guy to fill out a roster spot between now and the summer.

 

[SoleCyclone]

Hard to run practices with an 11 man+ Kelderman roster. Injuries are there now and guys will.be out, preseason and in-season.
It has been mentioned that with the increase in pay "nil" for some of the current roster, we may just not sign anymore. I think that could be dangerous.

 

[cyfan92]

It's too early to be concerned. Plus the entire big 12 looks rough right now (BYU exception)

 

[Drew0311]

Hard to run practices with an 11 man+ Kelderman roster. Injuries are there now and guys will.be out, preseason and in-season.
It has been mentioned that with the increase in pay "nil" for some of the current roster, we may just not sign anymore. I think that could be dangerous.

We will get a couple more guys. Not sure if they will be high quality but we will have enough to have a good practice second team.

 

[SoleCyclone]

We will get a couple more guys. Not sure if they will be high quality but we will have enough to have a good practice second team.

A combo guard and a guy that can play both 4/5 is probably necessary

 

[jcyclonee]

From my accountant acquaintance :

I know they claim to be able to compare it to similar deals, but I think they’re wrong. Fair value is what a buyer and seller are willing to pay in the Principal market they operate in. In this case the Principal market is college sports NIL deals.

For what it’s worth.
I guess time will tell. My prediction is that this will help the situation very little, but I am just an engineer.

College NIL deals are so new. Establishing somewhat standard FMV for these transactions will take time. Plus, advertising value is so subjective. I don't know how they can not accept a company's estimated FMV as long as they have an equation with no simple math errors.

 

[SoleCyclone]

There are no visits today

I guess you can believe who you want but Busse is pretty involved and seems he got another source to confirm...

Transfer Portal Target: Iowa State focusing on Dominick Nelson

Evaluating Dominick Nelson, who has one more year of eligibility

247sports.com

 

[Drew0311]

I guess you can believe who you want but Busse is pretty involved and seems he got another source to confirm...

Transfer Portal Target: Iowa State focusing on Dominick Nelson

Evaluating Dominick Nelson, who has one more year of eligibility

247sports.com

I think we have a website owner showdown for supremacy on this one. Which Cyclone website owner knows more. I like it. A clone off

 

[SoleCyclone]

I think we have a website owner showdown for supremacy on this one. Which Cyclone website owner knows more. I like it. A clone off

Cy-clopoliptic

 

[isucy86]

College NIL deals are so new. Establishing somewhat standard FMV for these transactions will take time. Plus, advertising value is so subjective. I don't know how they can not accept a company's estimated FMV as long as they have an equation with no simple math errors.

College NIL deals are new. But there is a long history of professional athlete deals and celebrity spokesperson deals to create a comparative database.

I am not saying there will be a system with teeth, but if they wanted to it could be created.

 

[TheDudeAbides]

As Dominick Nelson visits today I became interested to see his history. WAC player on the year this past and only season in D1. Prior to that was in JUCO meaning we may get those years back.
The main thing I was looking for was 3pt% as it wasn't good this past season (25%). In his last year at JUCO he shot 32% definitely better. But the most incredible thing I saw is he avg 20pts per game in only 18min per game. Wtf. That 45pt/40min of game time.

https://www.njcaa.org/sports/mbkb/2023-24/div1/players/dominicknelsongc1u

Just watched his transfer highlight video. Man that is a funky shot...understandable why he has such inconsistent shooting numbers.

 

[bosco]

Fighting the war of attrition. Save our money so when a late entry comes in everyone else will be broke and we swoop in with our 2 for one coupons.

 

[enisthemenace]

Sounds to me like we might be done. May as well shut this thread down.

Hope the young bucks are ready to play, because we’re gonna need them.

 

[Cyclonepride]

Sounds to me like we might be done. May as well shut this thread down.

Hope the young bucks are ready to play, because we’re gonna need them.

Lol, I doubt it

 

[alexssdean12]

It's too early to be concerned. Plus the entire big 12 looks rough right now (BYU exception)

Them and Houston. It looks like they are in a tier of their own

 

[FinalFourCy]

Fighting the war of attrition. Save our money so when a late entry comes in everyone else will be broke and we swoop in with our 2 for one coupons.

You mean save for when good supply is at its lowest point? After the scramble for players has had full time to inflate the market

Sounds like when you’d pay the most for what you’d get