Which NBA era wins...

Rural

Well-Known Member
Feb 3, 2010
42,667
35,890
113
If you want more scoring for Boomer team, replace Chalz with Alex English. He scored more points than any other player during the '80s. (I assume he got at least some boost from Nuggets/Doug Moe offensive style).

He wasn't a good 3pt shooter, so maybe not a spread-the-floor addition, as discussed earlier.
Thousands of baseline jump shots.

(Non-existent today)
 
  • Like
Reactions: cyclones500

ISUTex

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2012
9,841
9,581
113
Rural U.S.A.
I know Barkley was athletic. But he was still always fat, and never had much stamina. Watch the crazy rotations teams have to make when the ball is moving during these playoffs.

Two of the better players in the league today are slow and chubby white dudes.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
12,931
20,820
113
He still would. NBA is glorified AAU at this point. It’s been going steadily downhill in toughness since X

I think most would agree with the drop in physicality and toughness. But the skill, height and athleticism of the average player has gone through the roof. Last night we've got the 6'11" backup center on the 6 seed draining step back threes off the dribble.

The games are just very different. Rules and skills/attributes that work best in each era are very different.
 

Sigmapolis

Minister of Economy
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 10, 2011
26,836
41,381
113
Waukee
It's so funny they kept saying that Dudley was upset about the shove after the play. Dudley was likely more upset about Shaq wrapping his legs around him and trying to stick his crotch in his face.

Reminds me of this story I heard on Bill Simmons' podcast one time.

I forget who he was interviewing, but he was an old 90s NBA guy. Said he was guarding somebody on the perimeter with his back to the basket when Shaq got the ball on the block.

He didn't see anything but he did hear something like...

DRIBBLE

DRIBBLE

DRIBBLE

BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOMMMMMM

BASKET RATTLING

GIGGLING

Turns around and sees the defender on his ass under the rattling basket.

Shaq stepping away with a smug grin on his face laughing his ass off.
 

Dgilbertson

Well-Known Member
Sep 16, 2023
1,662
2,033
113
I think most would agree with the drop in physicality and toughness. But the skill, height and athleticism of the average player has gone through the roof. Last night we've got the 6'11" backup center on the 6 seed draining step back threes off the dribble.

The games are just very different. Rules and skills/attributes that work best in each era are very different.
Still think Larry Johnson and Chuck would adapt better to todays Gabe than vice versa.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
12,931
20,820
113
Still think Larry Johnson and Chuck would adapt better to today’s Gabe than vice versa.
I guess I look at it as if those types of guys came up through HS and college with the emphasis like it is, they’d have developed differently and would kick ass today. Same for Magic, Bird, Hakeem and of course MJ. But I think you drop some of the current guys with their insane skills and athleticism into the 90s, they are going to have to adjust to the style of play, but would still be great as well. The idea that some the Millenial guys would struggle in the era that guys like Reggie Miller, Isaiah Thomas, Clyde, Mullin, Mark Price, Stockton and Kevin Johnson were all NBAis hard for me to buy.
 

cyclonefan0705

New Member
Dec 31, 2024
5
4
3
Hear me out... Baby boomers are solid, but Gen X dominates. Also, Jokic and Wembenyama are getting bodied by shaq
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,680
13,514
113
Parts Unknown
Been an NBA fan for 30+ years and while I always found the 90s the most entertaining ill take the talent from the last 10-15 years over any generation of talent ever. There is nothing that "today's" player can't do. When 7 footers are handling the ball and crossing people over 30ft from the basket anyone who is unbiased with a functioning brain should understand it's another level. The idea that's it's somehow less physical today than 20-30 years ago is the laziest ******* argument by people who clearly don't watch I've ever heard
 
  • Like
Reactions: madguy30

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,680
13,514
113
Parts Unknown
Malone had an outstanding jumpshot from 15 to 18 ft. Bird Obviously. For a true big Hakeem had great footwork and fadeway that I feel like could hit a slashing Jordan or Magic.
Not a great arc team but I'd really trust that lineup.
As great as Malone was If you don't have a 4 that can put the ball on the floor and hit from 25ft you aren't beating the current generation of players. Do I think he could score? Yes but it's the defense you would expect those guys to play against the players of today. Can Malone be a good perimeter defender? I have my doubts.
 

deadeyededric

Well-Known Member
Dec 12, 2009
15,680
13,514
113
Parts Unknown
Malone and Hakeem would drain 3s today no different than guys like Kat and Myles Turner. Hakeem especially had limitless athletic ability and reflexes. He focused on shot blocking, rebounding and post moves because of his era but he did everything in a graceful beautiful way which is insane for someone who started playing at 18. Had he grown up playing in USA he may have been the goat.
They would not hit 3s like today's players. Come on dude. Especially with the expanded 3 point line. They weren't even good 3 point shooters when they played. You're a smart guy but come on.