Hey 19 - Random Thoughts: In the year 2525...more or less

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,343
31,481
113
I'm not sure how good Menards trees are but they are priced right. The folks were looking for some trees called around 1.5 inch trunks from local nurseries over $300. Similar tree at Menards was 90. Apple trees $40.
My only concern is the size/health of the root ball. But for that price difference it was worth taking a chance we figured.
 

qwerty

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 3, 2020
7,670
11,604
113
60
Muscatine, IA
I'm not sure how good Menards trees are but they are priced right. The folks were looking for some trees called around 1.5 inch trunks from local nurseries over $300. Similar tree at Menards was 90. Apple trees $40.
My only concern is the size/health of the root ball. But for that price difference it was worth taking a chance we figured.
I bought two from Menards 4 years ago and both are doing fine.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NWICY

2122

Well-Known Member
Mar 21, 2021
1,431
1,827
113
63
I'm not sure how good Menards trees are but they are priced right. The folks were looking for some trees called around 1.5 inch trunks from local nurseries over $300. Similar tree at Menards was 90. Apple trees $40.
My only concern is the size/health of the root ball. But for that price difference it was worth taking a chance we figured.
The adventurous can save a bit by purchasing tree seedlings online. I have Osage orange, shellbark hickory, pitch pine, sycamore, paw paw, Rocky Mountain Douglas fir, Kentucky coffee tree and other species dong well on my lot, purchased online from eBay sellers, Arbor Day Foundation, and other sites.
 

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,259
26,175
113
Minneapolis
I'm not sure how good Menards trees are but they are priced right. The folks were looking for some trees called around 1.5 inch trunks from local nurseries over $300. Similar tree at Menards was 90. Apple trees $40.
My only concern is the size/health of the root ball. But for that price difference it was worth taking a chance we figured.
We bought a couple trees from Menards and they were growing great for over 15 years until we cut them out. They were healthy but I will never plant another Ash tree because of the messy roots all over the yard. That's probably academic anyway with the borer.
 

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,343
31,481
113
We bought a couple trees from Menards and they were growing great for over 15 years until we cut them out. They were healthy but I will never plant another Ash tree because of the messy roots all over the yard. That's probably academic anyway with the borer.
The trees the folks took out were 50+ yr old ash trees that us kids brought home from Arbor Day at school.

I reckon that's not even a thing anymore.
 

jcyclonee

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
23,259
26,175
113
Minneapolis
The trees the folks took out were 50+ yr old ash trees that us kids brought home from Arbor Day at school.

I reckon that's not even a thing anymore.
Our kids brought home a tree every year at about that time. I don't remember if it was for Arbor Day or Earth Day. Arbor Day was a big deal at my elementary school growing up. We had an Arbor Day song and every kids that went to my school can still sing it word-for-word.
 
  • Like
Reactions: NWICY

frackincygy

Well-Known Member
Jul 13, 2015
1,030
1,414
113
The adventurous can save a bit by purchasing tree seedlings online. I have Osage orange, shellbark hickory, pitch pine, sycamore, paw paw, Rocky Mountain Douglas fir, Kentucky coffee tree and other species dong well on my lot, purchased online from eBay sellers, Arbor Day Foundation, and other sites.
Depending on your location, you can get good deals on seedlings from the Iowa DNR Forestry (https://nursery.iowadnr.gov/Native-Iowa-Hardwoods_c_1.html) I planted 25 of each - Pecan, Kentucky Coffee, and Bald Cypress last spring and I think my total bill was under $80. Now if I could just figure out how to keep the deer from nibbling the tops off the Pecan trees :rolleyes:
 

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,599
63,658
113
Not exactly sure.
Depending on your location, you can get good deals on seedlings from the Iowa DNR Forestry (https://nursery.iowadnr.gov/Native-Iowa-Hardwoods_c_1.html) I planted 25 of each - Pecan, Kentucky Coffee, and Bald Cypress last spring and I think my total bill was under $80. Now if I could just figure out how to keep the deer from nibbling the tops off the Pecan trees :rolleyes:
Pheasants forever for Winnebago county sells cheap bare root trees. I used to run a tree sale through them.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: NWICY

Cyclones_R_GR8

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Feb 10, 2007
23,942
25,928
113
Omaha
We bought a couple trees from Menards and they were growing great for over 15 years until we cut them out. They were healthy but I will never plant another Ash tree because of the messy roots all over the yard. That's probably academic anyway with the borer.
I bought a couple of ash trees from Walmart back in 98. Had to get them cut down 2-3 years ago. One was absolutely gorgeous.
 
  • Informative
  • Like
Reactions: jcyclonee and NWICY

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,343
31,481
113

stormchaser2014

Well-Known Member
Mar 12, 2012
23,824
12,659
113
Wisconsin
I'm not too upset i never heard back, didn't really see it going any further than just drinks, but she seemed a nice girl. I'm guessing she didn't like the place I picked.