Principal Financial-Remote work

cowgirl836

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2009
51,454
43,329
113
Devils advocate: What about the factory workers who typically are at their stations longer than desk jobs, and allowed specific time breaks.

Automate it. Robots. Think it's super unhealthy for people unless they dramatically reduce output expectations.
 
  • Like
Reactions: madguy30

NorthCyd

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Aug 22, 2011
21,168
35,740
113
Devils advocate: What about the factory workers who typically are at their stations longer than desk jobs, and allowed specific time breaks.
Work from home does not work for every job. Does that mean no one should do it even if some jobs can be done at home effectively?
 

MeowingCows

Well-Known Member
Jun 1, 2015
40,031
40,818
113
Iowa
Devils advocate: What about the factory workers who typically are at their stations longer than desk jobs, and allowed specific time breaks.
No devils advocate about it -- WFH simply doesn't apply to those roles. There's nothing wrong with that, it just is what it is... but, that's the role making that decision for them. Not a measure of efficacy in both places -- the option just isn't possible.
 

madguy30

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Nov 15, 2011
57,313
55,213
113
Manager here as well. My team has some folks who are WFH part of the time, and others who are full time remote. No issues with productivity or lack of personal connection. Shoot, 90% of meetings take place on Teams, regardless of if people are in the office or not. I don't care where people work from, so long as we're hitting our commitments on time. The way I see it, if someone thinks they need to have people in the office in order to properly manage them, it says far more about their managerial skills than anything else.

The best manager I had in the public sector roughly 15 years ago was someone who lived two states away.

They were very clear with what was needed and we only really heard from her if there was a problem (rare).

The manager title/duties eventually got handed to my colleague who could make a mess out of just about anything.

It's about the ability to delegate and if someone needs people in the office in order to 'manage' they're probably pretty weak at that part.

As an aside, I've also had it where the managers were the ones going around taking up others' time with with water cooler type talk, or nipping at their heals just to keep the dust kicked up.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gunnerclone

ISU_Guy

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2021
5,107
4,093
113
47
Des Moines
congrats on being an ineffective employee today.

part of RTO is culture. face-to-face interactions are clearly different from Teams meetings. I know some people just can't bear to put on pants, hire a babysitter, and drive to the office but, in some cases, it's better for the team, business, organization.
my point is all these people that go into the office want some sort of war hero award for going in and half of them waste more time in the office on extended lunches, chit chat, smoke breaks and live and die by the clock. Half the people that complain are the ones that have a job that actually requires being there or has ROI with what your stating.

To answer your part about face to face interaction:
the building I am assigned to go into the office to has ~1,000 people that go there.
I have nothing to do with any of them.

My small team of 10 is located in DC, Maryland, NC, CO, AZ, FL, TN, MN, VA, TX.
If/when I am required to go back into the office (sounds like my company is going to be soon), I am driving to my assigned office, taking Teams calls with my team around the country and customers around the world.

So maybe there isn't a one size fits all approach is all i was getting at.

And yes...... I raised 3 kids commuting, dropping off at daycare, and learned how to put pants on, etc, so I get how that works, thanks.
 

Cloned4Life

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Mar 5, 2006
3,610
3,369
113
my point is all these people that go into the office want some sort of war hero award for going in and half of them waste more time in the office on extended lunches, chit chat, smoke breaks and live and die by the clock. Half the people that complain are the ones that have a job that actually requires being there or has ROI with what your stating.

To answer your part about face to face interaction:
the building I am assigned to go into the office to has ~1,000 people that go there.
I have nothing to do with any of them.

My small team of 10 is located in DC, Maryland, NC, CO, AZ, FL, TN, MN, VA, TX.
If/when I am required to go back into the office (sounds like my company is going to be soon), I am driving to my assigned office, taking Teams calls with my team around the country and customers around the world.

So maybe there isn't a one size fits all approach is all i was getting at.

And yes...... I raised 3 kids commuting, dropping off at daycare, and learned how to put pants on, etc, so I get how that works, thanks.
Well said, good points here.

Always funny to me the "hero award" office-goers. They love to get (or believe they should get) credit for going into an office and promoting "culture" (or just saying words like "culture"). For many of us with global teams, nothing deflates culture more than forcing a group of people to take 1 - 2 full hours OUT of their day - some more depending on commute distance, kids in school, daycare, etc. - to go to a place (office) to sit on Teams calls by themselves.
 

cowgirl836

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2009
51,454
43,329
113
Well said, good points here.

Always funny to me the "hero award" office-goers. They love to get (or believe they should get) credit for going into an office and promoting "culture" (or just saying words like "culture"). For many of us with global teams, nothing deflates culture more than forcing a group of people to take 1 - 2 full hours OUT of their day - some more depending on commute distance, kids in school, daycare, etc. - to go to a place (office) to sit on Teams calls by themselves.

Purposeful, intentional office time is fine. But most RTOs are just **** like this. Sitting on Teams calls in a different spot.
 

Mr Janny

Welcome to the Office of Secret Intelligence
Staff member
Bookie
SuperFanatic
Mar 27, 2006
42,740
33,760
113
Well said, good points here.

Always funny to me the "hero award" office-goers. They love to get (or believe they should get) credit for going into an office and promoting "culture" (or just saying words like "culture"). For many of us with global teams, nothing deflates culture more than forcing a group of people to take 1 - 2 full hours OUT of their day - some more depending on commute distance, kids in school, daycare, etc. - to go to a place (office) to sit on Teams calls by themselves.
Similar to the "hero award" people are the "Extra Hours" flex folks.
"I always put in at least 50 hours, and most weeks more than that!"

Ok... congratulations on being taken advantage of? It you were getting overtime, that might be one thing, but you're a salaried system engineer. If you have to put in those kind of hours to accomplish your job, you've either got a manager who is doing you dirty, or you're not very good at your job.
 

MJ29

Well-Known Member
Aug 21, 2020
3,406
7,085
113
Similar to the "hero award" people are the "Extra Hours" flex folks.
"I always put in at least 50 hours, and most weeks more than that!"

Ok... congratulations on being taken advantage of? It you were getting overtime, that might be one thing, but you're a salaried system engineer. If you have to put in those kind of hours to accomplish your job, you've either got a manager who is doing you dirty, or you're not very good at your job.

I used to have two friends who were constantly comparing how many hours a week they worked. They thought it was a flex when they worked 60+ hours and looked down on the sane ones in my friend group who were like, "I put in my 40 and my work is done. I'm out." I always wondered how efficient they were if their jobs were requiring so many hours a week.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: mynameisjonas

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,674
63,742
113
Not exactly sure.
Similar to the "hero award" people are the "Extra Hours" flex folks.
"I always put in at least 50 hours, and most weeks more than that!"

Ok... congratulations on being taken advantage of? It you were getting overtime, that might be one thing, but you're a salaried system engineer. If you have to put in those kind of hours to accomplish your job, you've either got a manager who is doing you dirty, or you're not very good at your job.
What if they actually like what they do? They are problem solvers maybe. As my kids leave home, I find myself doing more of my own stuff that I may have hired done and doing other part time jobs because I enjoy that stuff. I have free time and would rather do that than pound the pud somewhere either watching TV or hearing others complain about their work.
 

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,353
17,736
113
A friend was going in one day a week because they made her, even though they didn’t have a quiet space for her to take calls, mostly from India. She wound up working that day mostly in the women’s restroom or a hallway. Taking the train two hours for that. The killer was when they wanted to make her boss come in, who they allowed to be remote several states away when they hired her. Best boss she ever had. She’s already in her upper 60’s so decided she was done. Gets calls several times a week asking how to do her job and she quit four months ago.
 

Gunnerclone

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2010
75,663
80,000
113
DSM
Well said, good points here.

Always funny to me the "hero award" office-goers. They love to get (or believe they should get) credit for going into an office and promoting "culture" (or just saying words like "culture"). For many of us with global teams, nothing deflates culture more than forcing a group of people to take 1 - 2 full hours OUT of their day - some more depending on commute distance, kids in school, daycare, etc. - to go to a place (office) to sit on Teams calls by themselves.

It’s going to be hilarious if/when layoffs and down sizing happen there are going to be people that get asked “why should we keep you?” And they are going to say “I come in to the office!” And they are going to get canned like some crushed pineapple. Then we’re going to have ANOTHER aggrieved group or grievance trait attached to the already aggrieved aggrievers.
 

Rabbuk

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2011
56,961
46,117
113
A friend was going in one day a week because they made her, even though they didn’t have a quiet space for her to take calls, mostly from India. She wound up working that day mostly in the women’s restroom or a hallway. Taking the train two hours for that. The killer was when they wanted to make her boss come in, who they allowed to be remote several states away when they hired her. Best boss she ever had. She’s already in her upper 60’s so decided she was done. Gets calls several times a week asking how to do her job and she quit four months ago.
I'd be invoicing for consulting work. My phone doesn't even work if I'm on a day off or pto.
 

bos

Legend
Staff member
Apr 10, 2006
30,629
6,415
113
Similar to the "hero award" people are the "Extra Hours" flex folks.
"I always put in at least 50 hours, and most weeks more than that!"

Ok... congratulations on being taken advantage of? It you were getting overtime, that might be one thing, but you're a salaried system engineer. If you have to put in those kind of hours to accomplish your job, you've either got a manager who is doing you dirty, or you're not very good at your job.


Our VP said that we dont have flex time and are expected to be here 8-5. We are salary and do work outside of hours now and then. The salary extra hours thing was fine (IT related stuff) until they said "no flex time". F that noise. A lot of IT is thankless enough, but being on call and getting extra hours with no flex is ******* dumb. We take our bites where we can now. Leave a smidge early, take a bit longer lunch etc. At this point as long as we arent harming our coworkers, we self govern appropriately. Its clear management is a bit out of touch in this arena.
 

KnappShack

Well-Known Member
May 26, 2008
23,890
32,242
113
Parts Unknown
Purposeful, intentional office time is fine. But most RTOs are just **** like this. Sitting on Teams calls in a different spot.

Our leaders have made the point many times.

It's up to them to convince us that it's worth our time to come in.

Felt like Jerry McGuire.....you complete me!
 

Mr Janny

Welcome to the Office of Secret Intelligence
Staff member
Bookie
SuperFanatic
Mar 27, 2006
42,740
33,760
113
What if they actually like what they do? They are problem solvers maybe. As my kids leave home, I find myself doing more of my own stuff that I may have hired done and doing other part time jobs because I enjoy that stuff. I have free time and would rather do that than pound the pud somewhere either watching TV or hearing others complain about their work.
Whether or not you enjoy being taken advantage of, doesn't mean that it's not happening.

The biggest epiphany I ever had in my career is to treat every job for what it is, a transaction.

That doesn't mean you can't be loyal. It doesn't mean you can't give extra effort. It doesn't mean you can't be the best employee in the organization. Just never lose sight of the fact that you are selling the most precious commodity that you have, which is your time.
 

BCClone

Well Seen Member.
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2011
67,674
63,742
113
Not exactly sure.
Whether or not you enjoy being taken advantage of, doesn't mean that it's not happening.

The biggest epiphany I ever had in my career is to treat every job for what it is, a transaction.

That doesn't mean you can't be loyal. It doesn't mean you can't give extra effort. It doesn't mean you can't be the best employee in the organization. Just never lose sight of the fact that you are selling the most precious commodity that you have, which is your time.
We "sell" our time in everything we do. Heck, CF is pretty much a huge waste of time when you use that avenue of thought.
 

cowgirl836

Well-Known Member
Sep 3, 2009
51,454
43,329
113
We "sell" our time in everything we do. Heck, CF is pretty much a huge waste of time when you use that avenue of thought.
You also mentioned that you put in extra time via paid PT jobs or work on your own projects. Those generate a direct return to you. That's not the same as putting in extra time on a salaried job. Sure, if someone *likes* doing those things, that's fine. But putting in extra hours thinking it proves something or earns some invisible badge of honor - that's a choice.

If I have extra time, it's not going to my salaried role. It's going to advocacy, family, hobbies, sleep - however else I want to spend my time.
 

SCNCY

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 11, 2009
10,703
8,511
113
37
La Fox, IL
We "sell" our time in everything we do. Heck, CF is pretty much a huge waste of time when you use that avenue of thought.

You mean you don't get enjoyment or, using the economic term, utility from posting on CycloneFanatic!?
 

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron