Smoking Meat Questions and Discussion

Jer

CF Founder, Creator
Feb 28, 2006
23,580
23,427
10,030
All things equal, I find cooking fat up actually results in maybe 40-50% more moisture in the final meat. I don’t think it penetrates, but the constant basting of the outside provides a bit of a protective barrier. Causes a longer stall, but so damn worth it and the butcher paper offsets a lot.
 

tm3308

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2010
8,189
1,608
113
Can I use the enamel one on the pellet grill? I would prefer to only buy one.
I have an enamel one. It's perfectly safe for a smoker or pellet grill as long as you're not exceeding the temperature range the manufacturer recommends, but don't ever put one over direct heat; it'll damage the enamel. As someone else mentioned, enamel on a smoker/pellet grill is harder to clean than plain cast iron, but that's a purely cosmetic issue. It'll perform the same whether you work to get it spotless or don't care about the effect that the smoke has on the appearance. I've made a few batches of smoked beans using mine and it's worked just fine.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: ScottyP

CYdTracked

Well-Known Member
Mar 23, 2006
18,583
9,413
113
Grimes, IA
This dude is pretty good. I'm not a fanatic about wrapping like he is, but everything else is spot on IMO.



His videos are good. For guys like me that still use an offset charcoal/wood smoker he has a really good one on how to season your smoker which I have started doing now to protect my smoker as I already had 1 firebox rust out on me so trying to do this once in awhile to help protect it more. He has some really good reviews too on various products he's tried out.

 

viking63

Well-Known Member
Aug 28, 2010
390
616
93
WDM, Iowa
How do you cook yours?
I am no purist but this it works for me. Lather shoulder with yellow mustard. Generously season with favorite rub. Smoke to stall. Wrap in foil. Cook at 300 until internal temp reaches 200-205 F. Cool, retaining all the juices. Pull. Incorporate back in the juices. Enjoy. Incorporating the juices back in isn't critical but it keeps meet nice and juicy which is particularly nice if you have left overs to reheat.

The reason I say I may have got lucky this time is many of the variables were different from last shoulder smoked. New pellet grill, new wood blend (maple & cherry), different rub (thought I had Meatheads Dust Rub Blend left, didn't. Had some Famous Dave Rib Rub that I used with additional paprika.) and smoked at 275 instead of usual 225.

Maybe the smoker goods were looking down upon me that day. Nah, just got lucky. It was a delicious lucky though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tm3308

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,744
31,095
113
Behind you
I am no purist but this it works for me. Lather shoulder with yellow mustard. Generously season with favorite rub. Smoke to stall. Wrap in foil. Cook at 300 until internal temp reaches 200-205 F. Cool, retaining all the juices. Pull. Incorporate back in the juices. Enjoy. Incorporating the juices back in isn't critical but it keeps meet nice and juicy which is particularly nice if you have left overs to reheat.

The reason I say I may have got lucky this time is many of the variables were different from last shoulder smoked. New pellet grill, new wood blend (maple & cherry), different rub (thought I had Meatheads Dust Rub Blend left, didn't. Had some Famous Dave Rib Rub that I used with additional paprika.) and smoked at 275 instead of usual 225.

Maybe the smoker goods were looking down upon me that day. Nah, just got lucky. It was a delicious lucky though.
If you find a system that works for you and is delicious, go with it. I like the look of the pan on the left especially, nice ring and I'm not one for completely shredding the pork, I like some larger chunks like what you have going on there. Looks amazing.
 

tm3308

Well-Known Member
Jun 13, 2010
8,189
1,608
113
I am no purist but this it works for me. Lather shoulder with yellow mustard. Generously season with favorite rub. Smoke to stall. Wrap in foil. Cook at 300 until internal temp reaches 200-205 F. Cool, retaining all the juices. Pull. Incorporate back in the juices. Enjoy. Incorporating the juices back in isn't critical but it keeps meet nice and juicy which is particularly nice if you have left overs to reheat.

The reason I say I may have got lucky this time is many of the variables were different from last shoulder smoked. New pellet grill, new wood blend (maple & cherry), different rub (thought I had Meatheads Dust Rub Blend left, didn't. Had some Famous Dave Rib Rub that I used with additional paprika.) and smoked at 275 instead of usual 225.

Maybe the smoker goods were looking down upon me that day. Nah, just got lucky. It was a delicious lucky though.
I try to keep my temp steady throughout the cook, though I'll crank it up to push through the stall if I'm running late. I go 250-260 and wrap with butcher paper once I'm happy with the bark, then take it off and rest it in a cooler for at least an hour, though usually longer. I also inject my butts with 50/50 apple juice and bourbon just before putting it on the smoker. My best results have come with a hickory/apple blend of wood chunks.
 

kentkel

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
5,407
5,630
113
57
I am a person who really does NOT like meatloaf (probably cuz I don't particularly care for ketchup). I follow a pit master on YouTube & he links his recipes to his website (I included the video below). I have a LOT of hamburger and ground pork sausage & I decided to make this guy's smoked meatloaf (a no-ketchup recipe). It was FANTASTIC!! The only variance from his recipe is that I did not have any specialty worcestershire sauce. I used plain old BBQ sauce as a substitute. I ended up loving this more than any pork fatty or smoked sausage I have done.
 

BillBrasky4Cy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 10, 2013
17,479
31,791
113
Did a 50/50 kosher salt black pepper rub/dry brine. I trimmed the brisket and separated the point and flat and applied the rub the night before. Smoked it fat side down at 225 and wrapped it when it hit 160-165. If you roll fat side down don’t over trim the flat, that’s one of the secrets I figured out. I cut the point into burnt ends and put those back on for about a hour and a half.
 

cycloner29

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
12,839
12,396
113
Ames
Did a wedding rehearsal last night. Citrus brined porkloin, brisket, and Dutch’s baked beans. Got a ton of rave reviews!! The beans were the big hit. Had people from Texas here for the wedding and they said they were some of the best beans they ever had. Had a bottle of Jimmy’s BBQ Pit sauce (Battle’s Sauce) in an unmarked bottle and told people to use it on the pork. Bottle didn’t last but 15 minutes. Two thirteen pound briskets and two eighth pound pork loins.

DA757DA8-714F-4F05-8A88-7536E3681A31.jpeg E3067897-3BDD-4C74-9E47-50989E6DD243.jpeg 6E5F5B29-B39A-4A72-B5EE-6B4C8A48C6B2.jpeg
 

JP4CY

Lord, beer me strength.
Staff member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Dec 19, 2008
74,557
95,547
113
Testifying
Did a wedding rehearsal last night. Citrus brined porkloin, brisket, and Dutch’s baked beans. Got a ton of rave reviews!! The beans were the big hit. Had people from Texas here for the wedding and they said they were some of the best beans they ever had. Had a bottle of Jimmy’s BBQ Pit sauce (Battle’s Sauce) in an unmarked bottle and told people to use it on the pork. Bottle didn’t last but 15 minutes. Two thirteen pound briskets and two eighth pound pork loins.

View attachment 100979 View attachment 100980 View attachment 100981
Love BBQ beans. Best I've had are at Jack Stack.
 
  • Like
Reactions: kentkel

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,744
31,095
113
Behind you
Did a 50/50 kosher salt black pepper rub/dry brine. I trimmed the brisket and separated the point and flat and applied the rub the night before. Smoked it fat side down at 225 and wrapped it when it hit 160-165. If you roll fat side down don’t over trim the flat, that’s one of the secrets I figured out. I cut the point into burnt ends and put those back on for about a hour and a half.
The only thing that really matters is, paper or foil?

;jimlad
 
  • Haha
Reactions: BillBrasky4Cy

Gonzo

Well-Known Member
Mar 10, 2009
26,744
31,095
113
Behind you
Did a wedding rehearsal last night. Citrus brined porkloin, brisket, and Dutch’s baked beans. Got a ton of rave reviews!! The beans were the big hit. Had people from Texas here for the wedding and they said they were some of the best beans they ever had. Had a bottle of Jimmy’s BBQ Pit sauce (Battle’s Sauce) in an unmarked bottle and told people to use it on the pork. Bottle didn’t last but 15 minutes. Two thirteen pound briskets and two eighth pound pork loins.

View attachment 100979 View attachment 100980 View attachment 100981
Nice. Did you smoke the BBQ sauce?