Look...nobody's arguing the the player's don't love it. They love the swag. They love the attention (although I find it a BIT of a stretch that the Pinstripe Bowl is the talk of NYC). I've got no problem with any of that.
But what's good for the players' entertainment is not good for the sport. If you want to treat it like an exhibition, make it a true exhibition - like the Pro Bowl in Hawaii. Everybody has fun...the outcome doesn't matter.
But if these bowls are supposed to be the postseason to determine the overall success of a team, we can do better than this. Match teams up based on objective measures...not who will best prop up the casinos around town. Put the games on campus, or create "mini-playoffs" of 4 teams from different conferences, and make postseason wins meaningful again.
Is there a more compelling postseason in ANY sport than the NCAA Basketball Tournament? How could we get college basketball's postseason so right, and college football's so wrong?
1) I think he means the talk of their hometown, not the bowl town.
2) So you're saying that the bowl system once worked? What about it has changed? It's always been ruled by money/power rather than merit. Just having more bowl games doesn't really change anything.
3) It's apples to mosquitoes. You can't get nearly as many people watching NCAA basketball games live as you can football games. Hardly anyone even bothers attemtpting to travel to NCAA basketball games. You have far more teams, and in basketball (unlike football) you can play 2 games in a weekend, which means the tourney can be played in a few weekends. Also, college basketball's tournament is inclusive enough that the underdog can get a shot. In college football, a playoff would be structured in a way that essentially shut out anyone who wasn't a Top 15 program perrenially. In order for a college football play off to appeal beyond to the fanbases of 75% of the programs (you know, the people who buy tickets and make this thing work), it has to be small enough to preserve the bowl system, or gigantic. Because there are fewer teams playing less games in football, it becomes a lot more difficult to duplicate the magic of March Madness.