How many other Islands and resorts have you been to? I've been wanting to try that place out as well. Looks like our next trip is going to be Disneyworld though.
I'm just wondering, because in general, it seems the Carribean is pretty much kick *** no matter what. So, if you've only been to one, it's the best place ever. I will admit that I'm exactly that way. I've been to Aruba Three times, but no where else. The reason, it was the best vacations we've ever had and it's tough to turn that down to chance somewhere else. I say this because I know a lot of people who have been to the carribean and been to different places, but have yet to hear from anyone who had a bad time.
I think in general it depends what exactly you like. Aruba is small and a climate and look much like Pheonix, AZ with a lot of wind and in the middle of the ocean. It's not the tropical paradise some might be looking for. It can be quite expensive too, but doesn't seem as far out of line compared to other resort areas as it used to be. Also, the last time we were in Aruba, it did lose a little of it's charm as it is much More Americanized than the last trip and especially the first trip we made there. It used to have moer of a European feel to it than it does now. That could also be from getting used to it more as well.
Aruba fits our vacation style though. It's a very small Island (20 mi. x 6 mi.) and you can see it all easily in a day. So that leaves a lot more time for us to sit around the pool bar, the beach bar and enjoy relaxing as much as possible. I'm not really an adventurer for those kinds of vacations. I want to sit and relax and not feel like I missed out on something by not seeing the whole Island. And besides the 2 missing US ladies, I've always felt more than safe there going anywhere on the Island. There doesn't' seem to be the Locals only areas or places you have to avoid. My wife and I regularly used the local bus service even to get into the Downtown area.