Dubuque photo with Chicago and Orion's Belt in the background [edited, not Des Moines]

cyfanatic

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2006
7,099
3,131
113
Cedar Rapids, Iowa
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.

View attachment 91982

View attachment 91983

That does seem to line up correctly...so the QC is not in the original photo...and Clinton's lights might be HWY 30...not neccesarily the riverfront.
 

AuH2O

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2013
13,017
20,997
113
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.

View attachment 91982

View attachment 91983
Nailed it. Down to the shape of 20 heading west out of town. On top of that if you look at satellite images around the Asbury area North of 20 there are a couple of big swaths of land that looks like it's being developed that are dark on the map.

Lastly, there is an abrupt halt to the lights along what sure would line up with a river. That's not how the DM river is at all in DM.
 

HFCS

Well-Known Member
Aug 13, 2010
75,861
66,304
113
LA LA Land
Chicago is closer to dm than people think of in day to day life and the light or light pollution is pretty massive compared to Iowa cities and probably even compared to places like KC or STL.

Growing up around Sioux City, Ames,DM and Omaha I never got the whole “stars are so bright in the country” thing because the stars seemed pretty bright everywhere. The past 24 years in Chi and LA make it really obvious that I don’t see as many stars. Takes about 50 miles away from either metro to start getting the change.
 

JBone84

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
2,825
1,378
113
Rochester, MN
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.

View attachment 91982

View attachment 91983
Winner winner, chicken dinner!
 
  • Like
Reactions: aauummm

crzy4st

Member
Sep 18, 2007
85
49
18
How does she know that glow isn't from the Quad Cities? Or the World's Biggest Truck Stop?
I would say because she is a pilot, and is kind of her job to know where she is at. Plus there is probably some sort of instrumentation in the cockpit that tells you where she is at. Maybe she had an app on her phone as well.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: Clone83

CySki

Active Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
May 3, 2010
101
99
28
47
Waukee, IA
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.
Agreed, 100%. The satellite view could be zoomed out just a bit, and you can clearly follow the light trail all the way down to Peosta in the bottom right corner and you can also see the dark areas of the Swiss Valley Park/Nature preserve just south of that light trail.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aauummm

Clonefan32

Well-Known Member
Nov 19, 2008
23,531
25,985
113
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.

View attachment 91982

View attachment 91983

So does your employer send this pilot lady a bill for the time you spent on this today or how does that work?

(Good work, by the way).
 

mp444

Active Member
Nov 4, 2014
219
-220
28
Here's the image with some drawing on it for towns around Dubuque. Screenshot 2021-11-15 131840.jpg
Blue line: Mississippi River
Red line: US 20
Orange line: US 151
Pink circle: Dubuque Area Airport
Green circle, west side (below) river: John Deere Dubuque Works
towns along river: purple = Bellevue, red = Savanna, yellow = Clinton
towns in Illinois/Wisconsin: magenta (lower left) = Dickeyville, pink = Kieler, yellow = Cuba City, blue = Benton, red = Hazel Green, green = Galena, white = Shullsburg, purple=Monroe
towns along 20 (red line): purple = Peosta, green = Epworth
 

Clone83

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2006
5,074
1,075
113
I just showed this to a coworker that also deals with maps and aerials all day. We've come to the consensus that it's Dubuque. The blue is the river, the lights on the right are Clinton in the distance. Not familiar enough with Dubuque to really do a street layout. However, this matches well with the idea that the distant glow is Chicago and the street grid meets the proper layout. See the google earth shot.

View attachment 91982

View attachment 91983
This sure looks correct. So many things align. There's Highway 20, it looks like lights on a bridge over the Mississippi, and that big string of lights that otherwise looks out of place south of Des Moines.

I was going to post satellite images of lights at night over North America, but decided not to. If you look at Chicago, though, you will see it very bright more towards the south, merging into Gary, IN, on the south side of the lake. Other images looked closer to a solid block up to Milwaukee, but generally, the light looked more centered towards the southside than what you might think if you just thought of downtown.

Regardless, it looks like the correct view towards Chicago, what you would expect.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: aauummm

BigBake

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2006
6,768
628
113
49
U'dale
So, kind of unsettling this pilot was 200 miles from where she thought she was, no?

Except someone already posted the flights went by DSM. And she flies this route regularly it appears. I'm gonna trust the pilot with the off chance she did pick the wrong picture from her camera roll the next day when she posted it.
 
  • Like
  • Winner
Reactions: aauummm and Clone83

Clone83

Well-Known Member
Mar 25, 2006
5,074
1,075
113
Except someone already posted the flights went by DSM. And she flies this route regularly it appears. I'm gonna trust the pilot with the off chance she did pick the wrong picture from her camera roll the next day when she posted it.

It isn't clear, but it seems there may have been a mix up here regarding the two images in her Twitter feed that were discussed:

Surely someone has a flight tracker they can pull up to answer this question.
I looked it up and there were like 4 UPS flights from Anchorage to Louisville early Sunday morning. Two were flying along the Mississippi River near the Iowa - Illinois state line, and two went right through Des Moines basically.

CYaeger here tracked flights for "early Sunday morning." But the image we are all talking about now, -- the one many think is instead of Dubuque -- was posted to her Twitter feed 11-6 at 1:46 AM, which is early Saturday morning (not Sunday). The DMR article linked in the OP said it "was on a UPS cargo flight from Anchorage to Louisville, Kentucky, around 1:45 a.m. Saturday." Some discussion above was that that could have reasonably just been when she posted it to Twitter, but that it might have been taken the prior evening (late on that prior Friday evening, 11-5).

So I'm not sure that the flight under discussion was previously tracked. Even though I'm not sure the correct flight (date) was tracked, note what else I bolded in CYeager's post:

"Two were flying along the Mississippi River near the Iowa - Illinois state line,"

In any case, it seems like she likely does regularly travel through Iowa and is familiar with the terrain.
 

EnhancedFujita

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Jan 28, 2013
2,211
2,179
113
Johnston
Didn't she double down to a response on Twitter by saying you can see I-80?

Her response was the line of lights on the right was I-80, which would be impossible if this were a shot of Des Moines from the west looking east, where I-80 would go through the middle of the lights.

I think she just confused Dubuque for Des Moines, which is understandable for someone that flies over and sees a lot of the area from maps and high in the sky. If you assume that she confused the names, the idea that the line of lights being I-80 makes more sense as they would be to the south in the image. Though I still believe that those lights are US 30 in Clinton, but again, as someone not familiar with the State the mistake is reasonable.