All Iowa Football Team---Post Bowl Edition

[CyTwins]

He’s had four months to watch film. If you think he’s just throwing **** at the wall, you’re not very bright.

Link to him saying he watched film on the Fumbler?

 

[benjimill]

Lol yeah that's it.

Serious question. You have two options, which one do you pick. Better college QB, worse NFL prospect or better NFL prospect and worse college QB?

I’ll take the better college QB who just so happens to also be a better NFL prospect, i.e. Nate Stanley.

 

[JP4CY]

Lol. You just can’t accept the fact that Stanley is a potential first round prospect. With as much equity as you have put in here talking about how bad he is, I don’t blame you.

Is he saying he's bad or is he saying Kempt is better?

Can you read?

 

[CyTwins]

I’ll take the better college QB who just so happens to also be a better NFL prospect, i.e. Nate Stanley.

Kempt was the better college QB last year. That's a fact, not an opinion. If you think Stanley will be better this upcoming year you're entitled to your opinion but you can't go back and pretend last season didn't happen

 

[benjimill]

Link to him saying he watched film on the Fumbler?

If you read his evaluation of Stanley it would be rather obvious. Would be very strange for a scout to list a player’s strengths and weaknesses without watching any film on them. How exactly would that work? Maybe he just reads CycloneFanatic to develop his Iowa player evaluations.

 

[benjimill]

Kempt was the better college QB last year. That's a fact, not an opinion. If you think Stanley will be better this upcoming year you're entitled to your opinion but you can't go back and pretend last season didn't happen

It’s literally not a fact.

 

[JP4CY]

Considering the Maxwell Award has been around for 40 years longer than the Davey O’Brien Award, and is awarded to the best all-around college football player, I don’t think there is any question that it is the much more prestigious award.

Derp.

The NCAA and NIT tournaments have been around longer than the AP poll but you think the AP means more than banners that hang in arenas.

 

[CyTwins]

If you read his evaluation of Stanley it would be rather obvious. Would be very strange for a scout to list a player’s strengths and weaknesses without watching any film on them. How exactly would that work? Maybe he just reads CycloneFanatic to develop his Iowa player evaluations.

This is what he said on Mitch without watching film on him

 

[benjimill]

The NCAA and NIT tournaments have been around longer than the AP poll but you think the AP means more than banners that hang in arenas.

Ive been told from CyFan that the AP Poll is the best way to determine which team is better.

 

[CyTwins]

It’s literally not a fact.

Statistically Kempt was better than Stanley. That's actually a fact, not an opinion

 

[benjimill]

This is what he said on Mitch without watching film on him

Exactly- there is nothing of substance there. “He’s a big guy that can run. Let’s see if he can improve his stats next year”

Lmao at thinking that is the same thing as his evaluation on Stanley. You are realllly reaching here.

 

[JP4CY]

Ive been told from CyFan that the AP Poll is the best way to determine which team is better.

Got it, so ISU was better in football last year.

 

[CyTwins]

Exactly- there is nothing of substance there. “He’s a big guy that can run. Let’s see if he can improve his stats next year”

Lmao at thinking that is the same thing as his evaluation on Stanley. You are realllly reaching here.

He said he has upside as a passer and has shown the ability to make plays with his legs without even watching film on him. Derp

 

[BCClone]

So what metric should we be using to evaluate QB's? You don't seem to like any stats at that position

Apparently use weight.

 

[CyTwins]

Apparently use weight.

Me: Stats say Kempt was better
Benji: I look at advanced stats when judging a player
Me: Advanced stats say Kempt was better
Benji: Well I don't like advanced stats in this instance

 

[Brandon]

Please explain to me how anything I said is inaccurate. If you think this is the same thing as McShay putting out a mock draft the day after the NFL Draft you are objectively an idiot.

FFS

 

[CyTwins]

FFS

He literally has no clue what he's talking about. It's sad to watch

 

[herbicide]

Please explain to me how anything I said is inaccurate. If you think this is the same thing as McShay putting out a mock draft the day after the NFL Draft you are objectively an idiot.

Are you McShay? Have you asked McShay how much Stanley film he has watched?

If you answer no to both of those, it is not a fact.

 

[BillBrasky4Cy]

Me: Stats say Kempt was better
Benji: I look at advanced stats when judging a player
Me: Advanced stats say Kempt was better
Benji: Well I don't like advanced stats in this instance

Apparently the new "McShay Scale" has become the new evaluation tool.

 

[CyTwins]

Are you McShay? Have you asked McShay how much Stanley film he has watched?

If you answer no to either of those, it is not a fact.

He can't grasp this concept. It's like talking to a toddler