As a frequent fan and alum who has come over to Ames for a few decades now, it's sad to see Ames so stagnant over the years, while Grimes, Waukee, Ankeny, WDM, Iowa City, North Liberty, Coralville-- exploded. The latter two in the eastern Corridor are unrecognizable vs 20 years ago. We spend some time in Coralville this month, and were extremely impressed. The Iowa River Landing area alone is great, as well as the Coralville strip and 1st Ave--once kind of run down for years. ~And I loathe the Hawkeyes.
Well, first for some context:
Iowa City, Coralville, North Lib 2000-2020 growth 37%
Ames 2000-2020 growth 32%
North Liberty has basically quadrupled in that time. Now the growth in Iowa City area expresses itself pretty differently and I think it's impressive, but let's be realistic. In 2000 Iowa City, North Liberty and Coralville had 85k people. And while CR/Marion are close, it wasn't great, and at the time had maybe 150-160k. So, hats off to the Iowa City region for growing and being very much a self sustaining area that doesn't really need CR. I'm sure there's plenty of people that go between the two for certain things, but for the most part you probably don't need to leave it to do/get about anything, and there are probably more entertainment options. But it's a whole different world thinking of IC vs. CR compared to Ames vs. the DM metro.
The growth in the IC region has been impressive, and I'd say it's pretty well done, and isn't just gross massive sprawl like I consider Grimes and Ankeny. And the IC area has absolutely grown to be University-focused, but not dominated by U of I like Ames is by ISU.
Not saying Ames' growth couldn't have been bigger or done in a way that would be more appealing, but its location from Des Moines is good and bad. On the good side, it likely will always provide some support for growth. But the negative is that it's 30 miles from Des Moines, which is now over 700k metro. It's too close to expect much, if any duplication of what happens to the adjacent burbs like Grimes, Waukee and Ankeny, but too far away to take part in that type of growth. Why try to develop 30 miles from Des Moines when there are still lots of wide open cornfields in the adjacent surrounding areas?
People saying Ames could've had Ankeny's or Waukee's growth seem to be missing the fact that suburbs 30 miles away aren't going to be massive growth areas when you've got other suburbs on multiple sides of a metro 0-10 miles away. It's just not happening.
I would like Ames to be more of a city that has a university rather than a university that has a town around it, but that's probably not going to happen due to the proximity and size of the DM metro.