Hall was a first team freshman All American by two publications and second team All Big 12. Goodson was nothing. Hall had a worse OL and played a tougher schedule. I assume/hope you're trolling at this point
Hall was a first team freshman All American by two publications and second team All Big 12. Goodson was nothing. Hall had a worse OL and played a tougher schedule. I assume/hope you're trolling at this point
Between Sargent and Young they were more effective with their carries than Goodson...
How so? I am not being sarcastic just wondering how you classify effective.
He also loses 4/5 of that bad OL. I am not saying he will be bad at all, I just think Goodson will be very good. I pick Iowa but it is a push in my mind considering all the variables.
So your logic is Hall was very good last year and won't improve and Goodson could be very good to get to Hall's level if Hall doesn't improve so it's a push? Lol genius
This reminds me of:
Between those 2 guys you have 995 yards, 5 TDs, and a close to 5ypc average. Considering you can’t point to a difference in supporting cast due to it obviously being the same, I would say that is inarguably more effective.
No, Hall was very good and will improve, Goodson was very good and will improve/ have a bigger role, which in turn will get him more exposure and could make him better. The OL will also have a role in this for obvious reasons and ISU losing 4/5 of starters there should be cause for some concern. Iowa loses 2/3 starters. Iowa does traditionally have a better OL than ISU. Which is why I have come to my conclusion that Goodson will have a big year for Iowa. Not saying Hall will not for ISU. Also Brock will probably get some time for ISU this year too.
That kind of helps my argument when Goodson had 4.8 ypc and will see more of the carries this coming year.
Ehh, I’d argue that ISU returns 3 of their top 4 DL.
Lima was really good for what they asked him to do. He’s not a dynamic, irreplaceable DL.
OK so you are saying Hall was better last year but Goodson could be as good as Hall this year? I'm confused
Lol so the fact that 2 other guys did better with their carries on the same team helps your argument???
ISU returns 2 of their top 5-6 OL. Also, the ISU OL was not this “bad” unit that everyone claims. They were average at best, yes.
The most talented O-Linemen on the team are waiting in the wings. This isn’t a secret.
2 others had 5 ypc vs 4.8........ and between the 2 had an average of around 450 yards and 2 tds.....
yes, but I have high hopes and think he will have a better year than Hall. Not saying Hall will be bad at all. You can think Hall will have a better year than Goodson based on last year and I would say that is not a reach at all. I might be reaching with my prediction, but it is not impossible to see it coming true.
I just think it's silly to give Iowa the nod when Hall was better last year and they are the same age. Especially when you consider their recruitments
Separating from the pack on a mediocre 7-6 team isn’t as hard as doing it on a 10-3 top 15 squad. Apples and Oranges really....
Also, Hall was not clearly better. He had more opportunity though. 52 more carries and same ypc indicates they would be about equal.
I mean I think it's fair to say Hall has more upside based off his recruitment but yeah Hall was a freshman All American and Goodson was a freshman
