"Most Colorful" I'd have to say Johnny Orr gets my vote.
I do have a Chris Taylor memory though. When I was a kid my Dad took me to see Cyclone wrestling. We bought a program on the way in and at some point before the meet was over I worked up enough nerve to go down and ask Chris for an autograph. He politely said yes, and I'll never forget that when he took the pen from me to sign the program the pen literally disappeared due to his hand being so huge. I still have that program packed away in a box somewhere.
I do have a Chris Taylor memory though. When I was a kid my Dad took me to see Cyclone wrestling. We bought a program on the way in and at some point before the meet was over I worked up enough nerve to go down and ask Chris for an autograph. He politely said yes, and I'll never forget that when he took the pen from me to sign the program the pen literally disappeared due to his hand being so huge. I still have that program packed away in a box somewhere.