ISU lands a QB Commitment

Wow, a 3.4 not in the top half? That seems like a lot of grade inflation.
we like to think waukee is really smart haha. yeah. if you have all A+'s you can have a 4.33, and AP classes are weighted, so you can have up to a 4.58 GPA... its weird
 
Some of it could be if they have an advanced grading scale or not, or are pretty much all schools using that now? We switched systems my senior year, went from all grades whether + or - counting the same to one where you got less points for a - then you did the regular letter grade and more points for the +.
This is why they have standardized tests, such as the ACT.
 
Ah, you guys make a good point about the bonus points for GPA, that does explain a lot.

I love standardized testing, but I know it isn't great for everyone.
 
Depends on your high school, too.

Depends on the school as well as the students in that particular class. This probably doesn't vary as much in larger high schools, but it makes a lot of difference smaller school districts like mine, where I graduated with just over 30 students.
 
Anyways, yeah, I'm guessing the QB pickings weren't real great out there at this point, so the staff identified a quarterback who may not be ready now but is certainly projectable. One of those things where he more than likely won't play at all until he's a junior (don't expect JT or AA to get unseated). He looks like a good developmental guy and Herman can mold him the way he wants. Kind of needed a QB in this class, but we had a chance to not have to look for an instant impact, rather a guy that can fit how we need him to.
 
3.0 gpa for today's kids is pretty good I think. Kids are caring less and less about their grades.
Even if you don't care, you should be able to get at least a 3.5.

There are plenty of kids in my school with 4.0 or very close to 4.0 who never study and don't do homework.

High school is really easy to get by with a 3.5 unless you do absolutely nothing, or just aren't smart at all.
 
Even if you don't care, you should be able to get at least a 3.5.

There are plenty of kids in my school with 4.0 or very close to 4.0 who never study and don't do homework.

High school is really easy to get by with a 3.5 unless you do absolutely nothing, or just aren't smart at all.

A 4.0 takes some effort.

A 3.0 student tends to be the kid that just wants to enjoy high school.
 
My GPA in college is considerably better than it was in high school. Either way, GPA is fairly irrelevant.

We did need to sign a QB this class with Bates leaving. This guy doesn't seem that bad. It'd make me feel better if he had more (any?) offers but oh well.
 
This is the generation that is used to awarding 20 trophy's at an event vs the old 3 that that I remember.

Do they still give out A, B. C's, D's, and F's or is that system in the stong age now?

Who cares what the quarterbacks grades are as long as he makes grades at ISU and can play well.:yes:
 
Even if you don't care, you should be able to get at least a 3.5.

There are plenty of kids in my school with 4.0 or very close to 4.0 who never study and don't do homework.

High school is really easy to get by with a 3.5 unless you do absolutely nothing, or just aren't smart at all.

Honestly it depends on the school, and upon what classes you take, there are huge differences from school to school. For instance when I went to HS they adjusted grades(to get rid of the fact that there were 14 valedictorians, the proceeded to make it much tougher to get a high gpa and thus a 3.0 the proceeded to be top 50% of the class whereas 3.5 was the previous mark. Calling your 3.5 equivalent to another schools 3.5 is like saying if UNI went 10-3 that its equivalent to ISU going 10-3, different play fields.
 
I wouldn't read too much into a high school GPA. Many students, athletes in particular, just sorta coast by.

Apparently the kid gets it done on the football field, and he has grades good enough to get him into school. Just fine by me.

Nice get this late in the game by PR.


That's just the opposite of how you should really feel! A small high school where a kid pulls a 3.0 is not good. It would be impossible for a good athlete to receive less than a B at a school like this. Oh well, I'm sure he'll work out
 
Interestingly enough they ran the Tony Franklin system at the high school in Penn. Obviously Franklin was the OC at Auburn last season. It seems to me Herman and Rhoads went and found a guy who knows the system comparable to the one they will run to get as their QB. He is obviously not a guy with a lot of stars, but he has a good knowledge of the spread offense and he has a good amount of talent to work with. Capello won't be a guy looked to be the guy until he is a junior or senior unless he shows he is better than Tiller. I really like the get looking over it. I think this will be a kid we can really develop over the next several years.
 
Interestingly enough they ran the Tony Franklin system at the high school in Penn. Obviously Franklin was the OC at Auburn last season. It seems to me Herman and Rhoads went and found a guy who knows the system comparable to the one they will run to get as their QB. He is obviously not a guy with a lot of stars, but he has a good knowledge of the spread offense and he has a good amount of talent to work with. Capello won't be a guy looked to be the guy until he is a junior or senior unless he shows he is better than Tiller. I really like the get looking over it. I think this will be a kid we can really develop over the next several years.



Thank you Marv, a positive post!!!!:notworthy:
 
welcome aboard James. he looks pretty good with his feet and throws a nice deep ball.

Yeah, on his highlights video, he's constantly dodging and weavin' and ducking and rolling out . . . he does have good feet. On one pass completion, he's rocking back on his rear foot yet launches a long pass.

I recall that Chizik said the no. 1 quality that he looked for in a quarterback was the ability to elude defenders. This kid appears to have that, plus a nice arm.

Isn't Lebanon, Pa., known as the cradle of quarterbacks or some such? Isn't Namath and/or Theisman from the neighborhood?

Last thing, on his Web site, James lists himself at 6-1 1/2 as opposed to the 6-0 on recruiting sites. . . .
 
You guys are deriding a kid for having a solid B average? Good god, half the time we're praying for kids to qualify and pass the clearing house and now some kid who's going to show up with no academic questions is being torn apart for having a 3.0? We need something positive to happen in ISU sports if our negativity is driving us to this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LindenCy
Come on, I had a 3.0 in high school and never once tried, I am guessing this guy is much the same. He is an elite football player in high school standards, I have no worries about his mind.
 
I had 2.2 until I got my **** together and upped it to a 2.8 in high school. I went to ISU for four years and finished with above a 3.0, I think I made it just fine without doing outstanding in high school. The thing is some kids don't try in high school. That was my deal, I had no motivation until I was a junior. I just didn't really care. The thing that matters is will this guy make it in college. Lets judge him after he gets here, which looks like will be the case.
 
  • Like
Reactions: BCforISU

Help Support Us

Become a patron