If you want to blame Pollard...

Bobber

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
8,880
576
113
Hudson, Iowa
There are two moves JP has made that I'm highly critical of. That's one of them. The other is McD's endless contract. The thing that Pollard does that worries me is having too much pride/confidence/whatever it is in his own hires. I don't think he's critical enough there.

That said, he obviously wasn't satisfied w/the status quo, like BVD was, and he's making moves to try and get ISU up. Some haven't panned out very well, but I'd rather go down swinging than just sit here in the basement with our collective thumbs up our ***.

I'm NOT in the camp that thinks he's perfect, but the idea he's destroyed ISU sports is ********.

+1 good post.
 

MontyBurns

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2008
3,794
221
63
And yet we still have the lowest budget in the Big XII. If you spend money for ISU sporting events, then you are obviously not the problem. The problem is the hangers on who do nothing but complain. And even if you are contributing, you can always look to upgrade, which I try to do every year, even if it's only buying a VB season ticket where I didn't last year. Every little bit helps.

Our budget woes have little to do with "Average-Joe" fans like you and I, and little to do with our ticket prices.

They are 3-fold:

1. Our enrollment is 8th out of 12 Big XII schools, and we are in one of the smaller population states to boot. We are outnumbered in terms of both alumni and local fans. Nothing we can do about this.

2. We have few big donors. And when I say big, I mean really big. Along the lines of T. Boone Pickens at Oklahoma State. Obviously he is an exception, but all the "haves" in the Big XII like Texas, Oklahoma, and Nebraska, have lots of donors who will write 5-figure and even some who will write 6-figure and bigger checks for projects. Our "biggest" donors like Jacobsen and Krause give more to Iowa than they give to us. Cultivating big donors is one of the most important things an AD should do, and our recent AD's (including Pollard but not just him) have not done it.

3. The Big XII splits TV, bowl, and NCAA tournament revenue inequitably -- more for the haves, less for the have-nots.
 

CyBobby

Well-Known Member
Oct 18, 2006
7,561
2,130
113
Central Iowa
So are you trying to say that if you don't donate at least $100.00 to ISU don't bother being a Cyclone fan? That is just ridiculous. Alot of people go to games, buy tickets, pay for parking, etc and don't donate to the NCC. Are those people not Cyclone fans?


Evidently those people are NOT fans...they're just the majority of fans!!!!


dont be cheep...........buy football tickets!!!!!!!!!!!:yes:
 

Bobber

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
8,880
576
113
Hudson, Iowa
Evidently those people are NOT fans...they're just the majority of fans!!!!


dont be cheep...........buy football tickets!!!!!!!!!!!:yes:

And that's part of the problem.

I've got a buddy who can afford season tickets, but never buys because he can scalp them cheaper at the gate. He's also not a NCC member.

He get's a lot of value for his dollar. No doubt about it.

He could do a lot more to help ISU however...
 
Last edited:

CJDelmonico

Member
Aug 23, 2009
159
6
18
I won't say the top North teams are better but I think the bottom teams are a lot better. In the early Big 12 days KU and MU were so bad that D1A schools had a shot. ISU's team last year would have beaten those teams pretty easily.

Wrong. Mizzou had a couple of nice seasons with Corby Jones at QB in 97-98. KU had some very strong teams in the 90's as well under Glen Mason. The bottom didn't drop out on them until the Terry Allen years.

As for Wayne Morgan, I get tired of seeing the "If he's so good, why isn't he coaching now" argument. Maybe he has a successful business in Ames, is 60 years old, and has just decided not to pursue it anymore. Ever think of that?
 

MontyBurns

Well-Known Member
Jan 27, 2008
3,794
221
63
As for Wayne Morgan, I get tired of seeing the "If he's so good, why isn't he coaching now" argument. Maybe he has a successful business in Ames, is 60 years old, and has just decided not to pursue it anymore. Ever think of that?

I agree 100%. The fact that Wayne Morgan isn't coaching is probably more his choice than the fact that nobody will hire him. After all, fired ISU coaches don't get head coaching jobs at Duke or Kentucky. Most likely he would be looking at a small college head coaching job, or a job as an assistant coach/recruiter at another major college. I can't blame him for not wanting to go down that road at his age -- he may not want to move or do the traveling those jobs require (as I recall he has a son with special needs and built a custom house for him in Ames) and he doesn't need the money. Don't forget that Jamie gave him $1.5 million of our money and he can probably make as much as an assistant coach/recruiter makes from his own business without having to travel -- plus he gets to be his own boss.
 

IcSyU

Well-Known Member
Nov 27, 2007
28,307
6,981
113
Just to throw fuel on the fire, or you know, it's because he's a great recruiter, and awful coach. NIT Final Four? Yippee. NO reason that team shouldn't have been dancing. None. It was sickening how bad we played to our competition. Beat Kansas one game, lose to Colorado the next. That shouldn't happen.
 

IceCyIce

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2009
2,632
1,644
113
Grimes
It's Pollards job to hire the person who is the best fit for his program. imo he whiffed big time when he hired the flashy guy with no ties to the area. However he may have hit it out of the park with the Rhoads hire. Only time will tell.

Pollard wanted to take a risk and hit a home run. He got a D Coordinator that nobody knows unless your in the inner circles of college football. Cheezits resume is impressive and the long shot was that he would be at
ISU as well. Pollard knew if he was right Cheezit would be here for 4 maybe 5 years. But he got a buzz going within Cyclone Nation which is what we needed, ticket sales increased. I respect the fact that he got up to the plate swung and missed. It beat the Wayne Morgan last man standing hire by vandevelde.
 

BigBake

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2006
6,768
628
113
50
U'dale
We asked Pollard to raise up all of our programs. That doesn't happen overnight. He got rid of one good (but stuck in neutral) coach and another "problem" waiting to happen coach.

The "he's not coaching anywhere else now" argument does hold water. How many coaches worth a lick do just fade away after getting fired? Yeah, exactly, he wasn't a good coach period, end of story. We are just now crawling out from the hold Floyd left for us when he jetted for the Bulls.
 

IceCyIce

Well-Known Member
Aug 17, 2009
2,632
1,644
113
Grimes
I agree 100%. The fact that Wayne Morgan isn't coaching is probably more his choice than the fact that nobody will hire him.

This is true however if he was passonate about coaching he would coach. Coaching is a ton of work. The way it works is, if Morgan gets another job he must pay back the $$$ to the university and ISU picks up the excess. So Morgan makes 750,000 a year he gets a contract with another school for 500,000 ISU Liability is for 250,000. If he gets a job for 750,000+ ISU does not pay. I think this is how it works for fired coaches. Chuck long is the same way. He is now a researcher for the SDSU. Dan McCarney took the high road because he loves to coach our liability for Dan should have been much less. He earned his cash.
 

CloneIce

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
37,774
21,154
113
I am in the camp that he's a mover and shaker, action-oriented, but in many ways uproven as an AD. He is very fortunate that his first job as the head man is at a school like ISU with a very loyal, enthusiastic, and despite the product, very large fan base. He could be in a lot worse situations.
He does have an ego. His contempt for Wayne Morgan grew to a point where he convinced Prez Geoffrey that the firing of WM absolutely HAD to be at 9 pm in the evening at Geoffrey's Beardshear office. There was no reason it couldn't have waited until normal hours the next day, and made Wayne more angry than ever.

+1

I agree with most of what this guy says.
 

CloneIce

Well-Known Member
Apr 11, 2006
37,774
21,154
113
Wrong. Mizzou had a couple of nice seasons with Corby Jones at QB in 97-98. KU had some very strong teams in the 90's as well under Glen Mason. The bottom didn't drop out on them until the Terry Allen years.

As for Wayne Morgan, I get tired of seeing the "If he's so good, why isn't he coaching now" argument. Maybe he has a successful business in Ames, is 60 years old, and has just decided not to pursue it anymore. Ever think of that?

Exactly. The people who makes that argument simply don't get or igonre the main pont: What Wayne is doing now has no tangible bearing or effect on how good of a job he did at ISU or on any of the decisions the AD did before or after he was fired.

His current career decisions are a non-factor and say nothing about the issue as it relates to ISU.... though I wish him well on his current endeavors and would rather have him out of the coaching business than competing with us.
 

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
Here is a few other people, besides Jamie Pollard, who deserve part of the 'blame' for ISU's recent lack of success.

1) Gene Chizik- Claiming he was firmly entrenched in Ames, leaves 6 weeks later.
2) Wesley Johnson- No communication with coach, then transfers to Syracuse.
3) Jim Boeheim- Gives coaching clinic at AIB, ISU player transfers to his school within days.
4) Mike Taylor- Lack of judgment
5) NCAA Committee- denied Lucca's FR season
6) Wayne Morgan- Lack of discipline, not bringing players good for ISU
7) The best Big 12 North Football Conference in history
8) The sudden rising of teams like Missouri and Oklahoma in basketball
9) The Iowa State Athletic Budget in comparison to other schools
10) Bret Culbertson- if only, if only, Bret makes that kick against KU...

Ahhh...one of the things many Cyclone fans seem to have a mastery of...excuse making!

What is interesting about this list from 1-10 is that it holds no one that is currently in place at ISU responsible for anything and many of the "goats" listed above are either long gone from ISU or have never even had anything to do with ISU.

Crazy.
 
  • Like
Reactions: j4state

cyclonenum1

Well-Known Member
Nov 30, 2006
7,191
330
83
Pollard wanted to take a risk and hit a home run. He got a D Coordinator that nobody knows unless your in the inner circles of college football. Cheezits resume is impressive and the long shot was that he would be at
ISU as well. Pollard knew if he was right Cheezit would be here for 4 maybe 5 years. But he got a buzz going within Cyclone Nation which is what we needed, ticket sales increased. I respect the fact that he got up to the plate swung and missed. It beat the Wayne Morgan last man standing hire by vandevelde.

You could not be more wrong.

You did not have to be in the "inner circles of college football" to know who Gene Chizik was. He had been the DC for two undefeated teams (AU and UT), he had been selected as the top assistant in the country, and his name was routinely bandied about (on ESPN and elsewhere) when new jobs opened up (some of them very high profile jobs) around the country because of what he had done at AU and UT.

His hiring by ISU was considered a stunning success for our program when it happened by nearly everyone around the country. I was disappointed with the record on the field...especially in year two but his time at ISU is better graded as an Incomplete than a Fail. He certainly appears to have had us moving in the right direction from the standpoint of improving the talent (especially speed) on our roster...which is the number one thing in building a successful college FB team.

I always viewed him as someone that probably would not be at ISU very long. And I was OK with that because I thought he would have to do something great at ISU before another higher profile program would give him the chance. Unfortunately, he left prematurely because AU gave him that chance before he finished the job of turning ISU around.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Aclone

Bobber

Well-Known Member
Apr 12, 2006
8,880
576
113
Hudson, Iowa
You could not be more wrong.

You did not have to be in the "inner circles of college football" to know who Gene Chizik was. He had been the DC for two undefeated teams (AU and UT), he had been selected as the top assistant in the country, and his name was routinely bandied about (on ESPN and elsewhere) when new jobs opened up (some of them very high profile jobs) around the country because of what he had done at AU and UT.

His hiring by ISU was considered a stunning success for our program when it happened by nearly everyone around the country. I was disappointed with the record on the field...especially in year two but his time at ISU is better graded as an Incomplete than a Fail. He certainly appears to have had us moving in the right direction from the standpoint of improving the talent (especially speed) on our roster...which is the number one thing in building a successful college FB team.

I always viewed him as someone that probably would not be at ISU very long. And I was OK with that because I thought he would have to do something great at ISU before another higher profile program would give him the chance. Unfortunately, he left prematurely because AU gave him that chance before he finished the job of turning ISU around.

Very good post. I can't write it any better than that. Good job.
 

wiscocyclone

Member
Sep 13, 2007
244
14
18
Pollard has done something for ISU that hadn't happened for a long time--he created a focus on winning. Except for wrestling, it is arguable that focus was lost. We are walking but the cadence is increasing....soon it will be a full gallop.
 

j4state

Well-Known Member
May 21, 2006
1,016
50
48
Visit site
Ahhh...one of the things many Cyclone fans seem to have a mastery of...excuse making!

What is interesting about this list from 1-10 is that it holds no one that is currently in place at ISU responsible for anything and many of the "goats" listed above are either long gone from ISU or have never even had anything to do with ISU.

Crazy.

Right on the money here. It's funny how many "objective" arguments out there fail to ever blame anything internally but as soon as the person leaves ISU they were the reason for all of our problems. Can't have it both ways.