Ash tree replacement

cyinne

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Sep 4, 2009
2,087
624
113
O-town, Iowa
I live on a farm with a lot of ash trees that are dead or in the process of dying from EAB.
This since the weather has been nice this past few weeks we are taking down about 20 trees in our grove- next year will probably be the rest from around the rest of the yard.
I was wondering what we are going to replace these trees with. I would like something that is relatively fast growing for a hardwood tree, low maintenance, and is not really “dirty” once grown.
I an 43 and would like to enjoy these new trees at some point fully grown, or is that a pipe dream?
 

nfrine

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2006
9,842
12,009
113
Nearby
I live on a farm with a lot of ash trees that are dead or in the process of dying from that motherfucking EAB.
This since the weather has been nice this past few weeks we are taking down about 20 trees in our grove- next year will probably be the rest from around the rest of the yard.
I was wondering what we are going to replace these trees with. I would like something that is relatively fast growing for a hardwood tree, low maintenance, and is not really “dirty” once grown.
I an 43 and would like to enjoy these new trees at some point fully grown, or is that a pipe dream?
My dad always said the best time to plant a tree is 40 years ago, The next best time is today.

Where are you located?
 

nfrine

Well-Known Member
Mar 31, 2006
9,842
12,009
113
Nearby
Last edited:

SEIOWA CLONE

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2018
6,793
6,989
113
63
We have planted a couple Blaze Maple trees, they grow very fast, and look very nice with the red leaves in the fall. Elm trees also grow quickly.

The best time to plant trees in Iowa is during the fall, water the heck out of them and when they make it through the winter you will know that you have a keeper. We purchased all of ours online from here https://www.fast-growing-trees.com/collections/mapletrees.
 

carvers4math

Well-Known Member
Mar 15, 2012
21,351
17,736
113
We got the fast growing elms. They can grow three to six feet a year. All the neighbors have maples, and those whirly bird seeds were sprouting tiny trees all over our front yard one year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Turn2

Agclone91

Well-Known Member
Feb 5, 2011
2,858
977
113
Ames
I live on a farm with a lot of ash trees that are dead or in the process of dying from EAB.
This since the weather has been nice this past few weeks we are taking down about 20 trees in our grove- next year will probably be the rest from around the rest of the yard.
I was wondering what we are going to replace these trees with. I would like something that is relatively fast growing for a hardwood tree, low maintenance, and is not really “dirty” once grown.
I an 43 and would like to enjoy these new trees at some point fully grown, or is that a pipe dream?
The bolded part is what was so unique about Ash trees - They were an all around awesome tree. There's just not many other options out there that check all of the boxes. Damn shame what EAB has done to them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: wintersmd

dafarmer

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2012
7,213
6,903
113
SW Iowa
Mulberry and red cedar.... just kidding. Planted a Norway maple and a crimson maple. Also, spruce seems to survive in Iowa. Planted white oak(slow) and pin oak (moderate) growth. Heard oak trees are having insect and disease issues, too.
 

Stumper

Member
Jun 19, 2020
37
48
18
56
A variety. It's obvious that ash was used as a replacement when Dutch Elms disease hit in the 70's. This year, 75-80% of the tree stumps I've ground out have been ash trees. During the next tree pandemic, at least they won't lose all the trees.
 

RLD4ISU

Well-Known Member
Sep 13, 2018
794
998
93
Otsego, MN
IMO it's all about personal preference. Some unsolicited advice: Research each tree you're considering to learn more about size, root system, etc.

If I remember correctly, Maples have a shorter root system and the roots will gravitate toward a water source - potentially water lines, septic lines. Another rule of thumb I've always heard is that fast growing trees typically are "dirtier" than slow growing.

Fall is a great time to plant. The old saying is to plant a tree during a month that has an R in it.
 

CyCrazy

Well-Known Member
Dec 17, 2008
27,055
15,287
113
Ames
IMO it's all about personal preference. Some unsolicited advice: Research each tree you're considering to learn more about size, root system, etc.

If I remember correctly, Maples have a shorter root system and the roots will gravitate toward a water source - potentially water lines, septic lines. Another rule of thumb I've always heard is that fast growing trees typically are "dirtier" than slow growing.

Fall is a great time to plant. The old saying is to plant a tree during a month that has an R in it.
Any tree species can do that. Well except evergreens for the most part
 

Tri4Cy

Well-Known Member
SuperFanatic
SuperFanatic T2
Apr 4, 2012
1,521
1,421
113
Des Moines
A variety. It's obvious that ash was used as a replacement when Dutch Elms disease hit in the 70's. This year, 75-80% of the tree stumps I've ground out have been ash trees. During the next tree pandemic, at least they won't lose all the trees.
I was just talking to my wife about this. We have an old fence line in our back yard that is, well, unkempt. I'd like to rip out the honeysuckle and save some of the natives and supplement with some conifers of some sort for privacy. She'd like to just rip it all out and plant a wall of arborvitaes. I'm a fan of diversity as I'm terrified we'll get 20 years of growth then the "next" thing comes through and kills all of the same species like what happened with ash, elm, and the pines in CO.
 

Dirt Boy 2

Well-Known Member
Feb 23, 2013
317
341
63
Check with your DNR forester for options other than maple. You can receive cost share replacing trees in timbers through IDALS/County SWCD offices. There is a lot of money available if you are interested in timber work.
I remember a statistic that 60 some percent of Iowa’s trees are maples. If you want to avoid a potential problem like we have with ash, might be wise to consider something other than maple. DNR has an couple good pamphlets on trees for front yards that are native options.
 

ruflosn

Well-Known Member
Dec 21, 2008
1,092
674
113
I live on a farm with a lot of ash trees that are dead or in the process of dying from EAB.
This since the weather has been nice this past few weeks we are taking down about 20 trees in our grove- next year will probably be the rest from around the rest of the yard.
I was wondering what we are going to replace these trees with. I would like something that is relatively fast growing for a hardwood tree, low maintenance, and is not really “dirty” once grown.
I an 43 and would like to enjoy these new trees at some point fully grown, or is that a pipe dream?
Can I morel hunt your land next spring?
 
  • Winner
Reactions: Gorm

mkadl

Well-Known Member
Mar 17, 2006
2,129
927
113
Cornfield
We got the fast growing elms. They can grow three to six feet a year. All the neighbors have maples, and those whirly bird seeds were sprouting tiny trees all over our front yard one year.
Elms, whoduh thunk it? I know of one in the town that I have lived in for 6 decades. They all died in the 60s or 70s. Weird to think about it. This town had over 300 ash tress to take down in right of ways. Crazy I have seen two tree plagues in my lifetime.
 

NWICY

Well-Known Member
Sep 2, 2012
35,326
31,467
113
I live on a farm with a lot of ash trees that are dead or in the process of dying from EAB.
This since the weather has been nice this past few weeks we are taking down about 20 trees in our grove- next year will probably be the rest from around the rest of the yard.
I was wondering what we are going to replace these trees with. I would like something that is relatively fast growing for a hardwood tree, low maintenance, and is not really “dirty” once grown.
I an 43 and would like to enjoy these new trees at some point fully grown, or is that a pipe dream?
Check with ISU extension forestry. They can help and also point you in the right direction for wind break funding if you're interested in that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RLD4ISU

2122

Well-Known Member
Mar 21, 2021
1,431
1,827
113
63
You might consider tulip tree (liriodendron tulipfera). I have some growing here in So. Minn. even though they are only marginally hardy here. Wonderful species. Grows fast like a cottonwood, even faster. Gorgeous. Flowering. Wonderful scent. Doesn't have issue with roots in lawn like a cottonwood. You can buy seedlings online, no prob.

Hackberry is reliable, fairly fast growing.

Sycamore is fast growing, fairly messy.

European larch. Mine is growing pretty fast. Farmers used to plant them in their groves.

Northern red oak and Eastern White Oak are growing pretty fast for me too, for oaks.

I think black locust is gorgeous. Grows pretty fast. Young branches are thorny.

Kentucky coffeetree is a great native yard tree, grows fairly fast, bit messy with large double-compound leaves and seed pods.

Hickories generally slow, but I have a shellbark hickory that grew 4' this year......
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Help Support Us

Become a patron