All Iowa Football Team---Post Bowl Edition
- Thread starter YeahBuddy
- Start date
You are acting like Hall is some incredible receiver, but the vast majority of his receiving yards come from catching dump off passes and checkdowns and turning them into big gains. Iowa actually sends Goodson out on passing routes, while obviously still using him for dump offs and check downs.
Iowa’s checkdowns and dumpoffs don’t work as well as Iowa State’s for a number of reasons (scheme, quality of defenses, etc.). That is the reason why Goodson’s receiving stats are not more impressive. But Goodson’s abilities as a receiver exceed Hall’s. Hall isn’t doing anything in terms of route running or pass catching that the vast majority of P5 running backs couldn’t do.
He wants us to be impressed with Goodson having 15 rushing yards against Michigan, 26 against Wisconsin, and 35 with a fumble against Penn State.
Using this guy's logic, Toren Young was better than Breece as well because he had more ypc against top-40 defenses.
You are a moron. You completely ignore statistics and obviously don't watch Iowa State games
He's not an incredible receiver? No one said that lol he's a pretty good receiving running back though.. Breece had more receiving yards and ypc than JK Dobbins did this past year. He's pretty good.
He hates everything Iowa State so much more that he just ignores facts. Sad to watch
You are such a homer dude. You have to look at how the players are used in their team’s respective schemes. Hall catches dump offs and check downs. Almost any P5 RB could do that.
Big XII defense and a ton of touches, so I would expect a lot of forced missed tackles.
You think a running back on your favorite team is better than another on the basis of one single cherry picked stat that doesn't have complete data, and you have the audacity to call me a homer? Lol find me one single article written from the end of last year or this year that has Tyler Goodson listed / ranked better than Breece Hall is. Just one. I urge you to do it.
Good players get more touches. Hall wouldn't be splitting touches with Sargent and Young lol. Goodson is too small and slow to get used very much
Those are opinions though. Stats are the facts (unless it's about receiving, touchdowns, breaking tackles, etc)
So now your entire argument is based on the fact that the Big 12 defenses are bad, so therefore there can't be any good players in the Big 12 on offense?
Well just throw the Heisman trophy out the window. That's just an opinionated award too.
He said Stanley was better than Purdy for this very reason. He's such a homer he doesn't even make sense
Yep he didn't think David Montgomery was that good either. Only broke tackles because of the Big 12
And you think a RB on your favorite team is better on the basis of him racking up stats against some of the worst P5 defenses in the country.
And “articles” about each player don’t mean squat. There were a ton of articles talking about how good Mike Warren was after his freshman season, too. Even some national writers saying he could rush for 2,000 yards in a season. We all know how that one worked out.
