When do you consider an opinion 'Dumb'?

I'm no goddam snowflake.

Someone posts something dumb (and you know who you are) they get the dumb button

Our society has gotten worse once we stopped calling ideas like flat earth or conspiracy theories "dumb".
I have 95 dumbs since 2020...so the dumb button hasn't really worked for me. I had to laugh because like 10 of my first 15 dumbs are from surly.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: CYCLNST8
If something is legitimately a dumb take, I’ll call it out- or if after discussing a topic for the better part of a day a poster is just digging in and being obtuse, Ill start calling something dumb. I generally don’t use it outside of the cave, but some posters in the cave (you know who you are) just go through and dumb a post without explaining why the think the post is dumb, then subsequently delete posts to improve their reaction score- that typically earns an insta-dumb from me.
 
I've used the 'Dumb' emoji here a few times on some posts and it got me thinking. What makes you consider an opinion dumb?
Is it when it's something you disagree with?
When it's something you know is factually incorrect?
Some other reason?
I've only used the dumb icon a handful of times. And, it's often the case of an 'opinion' which is not only factually ignorant, but slants to harmful information.
 
I don’t usually use it. In sports threads it’s only when people ruthlessly attack Cyclone players/coaches irrationally, in non-sports threads it’s a “bigot button” and I rarely use it.
 
and matt campbell needs to be gone. he's dead. rip CMC.

LONG LIVE CJR
 
I'm no goddam snowflake.

Snowflakes are beautiful, unique and they serve a purpose. Sorry you don't want to be one.

Someone posts something dumb (and you know who you are) they get the dumb button

And that serves what purpose? I'm not sure it actually makes you feel better, because you seem kinda grumpy. And, yes, judgy.

my-dog-is-judgmental-v0-n7m04vor595e1-removebg-preview.png

Our society has gotten worse once we stopped calling ideas like flat earth or conspiracy theories "dumb".

"Dumb" does nothing to improve the situation. If you hold knowledge in the palm of your hand, you need to share it with the person, nay, the very universe.

Enlighten, not beknighten.
 
  • Dumb
Reactions: WIBadger