Its really hard to compare because the surrounding cast and overall discipline of the teams are night and day.
It's not an easy choice and the people who think it's easily Brock probably aren't seeing it in full context.
Brock will get the nod because of 4 year vs 2 year and it's a credit to him he could excel as a freshman.
Comparing across eras is always tricky.
Terry Bradshaw had a completion percentage of 51.9%....also 4 championships and a HOF member.
Compare that to 2020 and those numbers get you sent home.
Different offense and surrounding cast. For mobility, ability to throw on the run (under duress), and the ability to will a team to win. I'm team SW.
Hell the team got to #9 with SW at QB.
Troy is right up there and I'm not sleeping on Sage and Reggie Hayward either. They should get some love too